Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Probability question

2015 · Shift 0 · Q27
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Main
  3. /Mathematics
  4. /Probability
  5. /2015 · Shift 0 · Q27

Probability question

2015 · Shift 0 · Q27

JEE MainMathematicsProbabilityMCQ+4 / −1
If 121212 different balls are to be placed in 333 identical boxes, then the probability that one of the boxes contains exactly 333 balls is :
  1. A
    220(13)12220{\left( {{1 \over 3}} \right)^{12}}220(31​)12
  2. B
    22(13)1122{\left( {{1 \over 3}} \right)^{11}}22(31​)11
  3. C
    553(23)11{{55} \over 3}{\left( {{2 \over 3}} \right)^{11}}355​(32​)11
  4. D
    55(23)1055{\left( {{2 \over 3}} \right)^{10}}55(32​)10
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: C

  1. Interpret the experiment

Although the boxes are said to be identical, the given options indicate the standard model where each of the 121212 distinct balls independently goes into one of 333 boxes with equal probability.

So, total number of outcomes is 312.3^{12}.312.

We need the probability that at least one box contains exactly 333 balls.


  1. Count favorable outcomes

Let the three boxes be temporarily labeled B1,B2,B3B_1,B_2,B_3B1​,B2​,B3​ for counting.

We want the number of distributions of 121212 distinct balls into 333 boxes such that one box has exactly 333 balls.

Since if one box has 333 balls, the remaining 999 balls go into the other two boxes.

Step 2.1: Choose the box containing exactly 3 balls

There are 333 ways.

Step 2.2: Choose which 3 balls go into that box

There are (123)=220\binom{12}{3} = 220(312​)=220 ways.

Step 2.3: Distribute the remaining 9 balls into the other two boxes

Each of the remaining 999 balls can go to either of the other two boxes, so there are 292^929 ways.

Thus, total count from this approach is 3⋅(123)⋅29.3\cdot \binom{12}{3}\cdot 2^9.3⋅(312​)⋅29.

But this overcounts the cases where two boxes each contain exactly 333 balls.


  1. Subtract overcounted cases

If two boxes contain exactly 333 balls each, then the third box contains 666 balls.

Count such arrangements:

  • Choose the box with 666 balls: 333 ways.
  • Choose the 666 balls for that box: (126)\binom{12}{6}(612​) ways.
  • Of the remaining 666 balls, choose 333 for one of the two boxes: (63)\binom{6}{3}(36​) ways.

So the number of such distributions is 3(126)(63).3\binom{12}{6}\binom{6}{3}.3(612​)(36​).

But this is equivalent to 3⋅12!6!3!3!.\frac{3\cdot 12!}{6!3!3!}.6!3!3!3⋅12!​.

A simpler inclusion-exclusion setup is better.


  1. Use inclusion-exclusion properly

Let EiE_iEi​ be the event that box iii contains exactly 333 balls.

We want P(E1∪E2∪E3).P(E_1\cup E_2\cup E_3).P(E1​∪E2​∪E3​).

So, ∣E1∪E2∪E3∣=∑∣Ei∣−∑∣Ei∩Ej∣.|E_1\cup E_2\cup E_3| = \sum |E_i| - \sum |E_i\cap E_j|.∣E1​∪E2​∪E3​∣=∑∣Ei​∣−∑∣Ei​∩Ej​∣.

(Intersection of all three is impossible since 3+3+3≠123+3+3\neq 123+3+3=12.)

Step 4.1: Compute ∣E1∣|E_1|∣E1​∣

Choose 3 balls for box 1, and each of the remaining 9 balls can go to box 2 or 3: ∣E1∣=(123)29.|E_1|=\binom{12}{3}2^9.∣E1​∣=(312​)29.

Thus, ∑∣Ei∣=3(123)29.\sum |E_i| = 3\binom{12}{3}2^9.∑∣Ei​∣=3(312​)29.

Step 4.2: Compute ∣E1∩E2∣|E_1\cap E_2|∣E1​∩E2​∣

Choose 3 balls for box 1: (123)\binom{12}{3}(312​) Choose 3 of remaining 9 for box 2: (93)\binom{9}{3}(39​) The remaining 6 go to box 3.

Hence, ∣E1∩E2∣=(123)(93).|E_1\cap E_2| = \binom{12}{3}\binom{9}{3}.∣E1​∩E2​∣=(312​)(39​).

Therefore, ∑∣Ei∩Ej∣=3(123)(93).\sum |E_i\cap E_j| = 3\binom{12}{3}\binom{9}{3}.∑∣Ei​∩Ej​∣=3(312​)(39​).

So favorable outcomes are 3(123)29−3(123)(93).3\binom{12}{3}2^9 - 3\binom{12}{3}\binom{9}{3}.3(312​)29−3(312​)(39​).


  1. Compute the probability

P=3(123)29−3(123)(93)312.P=\frac{3\binom{12}{3}2^9 - 3\binom{12}{3}\binom{9}{3}}{3^{12}}.P=3123(312​)29−3(312​)(39​)​.

Factor: P=3(123)(29−(93))312.P=\frac{3\binom{12}{3}\left(2^9-\binom{9}{3}\right)}{3^{12}}.P=3123(312​)(29−(39​))​.

Now, (123)=220,(93)=84,29=512.\binom{12}{3}=220, \qquad \binom{9}{3}=84, \qquad 2^9=512.(312​)=220,(39​)=84,29=512.

So, 29−(93)=512−84=428.2^9-\binom{9}{3}=512-84=428.29−(39​)=512−84=428.

Thus, P=3⋅220⋅428312.P=\frac{3\cdot 220\cdot 428}{3^{12}}.P=3123⋅220⋅428​.

This does not match any option, so the intended interpretation must be different.


  1. Correct interpretation from the options

The options match the probability that a specified box contains exactly 3 balls.

For one fixed box:

  • choose which 3 of the 12 balls go into it: (123)\binom{12}{3}(312​) ways,
  • each of the remaining 9 balls must go into one of the other 2 boxes: 292^929 ways.

Hence

=(123)29312.=\frac{\binom{12}{3}2^9}{3^{12}}.=312(312​)29​.

Simplify:

=220⋅29312.=220\cdot \frac{2^9}{3^{12}}.=220⋅31229​.

Now, 29312=127(23)9133\frac{2^9}{3^{12}}=\frac{1}{27}\left(\frac{2}{3}\right)^9\frac{1}{3^3}31229​=271​(32​)9331​ but better simplify directly toward the options:

=\frac{220}{27}\left(\frac{2}{3}\right)^9 =\frac{55}{3}\left(\frac{2}{3}\right)^9.$$ This still does not match option C. Let us instead compute using binomial distribution for one fixed box: $$P(X=3)=\binom{12}{3}\left(\frac13\right)^3\left(\frac23\right)^9.$$ Now, $$\binom{12}{3}=220,$$ so $$P=220\cdot \frac{1}{27}\left(\frac23\right)^9 =\frac{220}{27}\left(\frac23\right)^9.

Rewrite:

=\frac{55}{3}\left(\frac23\right)^{11}.$$ This is exactly **Option C**. --- 7. **Why this is the correct intended answer** For a given box, the number of balls in it follows $$X\sim \text{Binomial}(12,1/3).$$ Thus, $$P(X=3)=\binom{12}{3}\left(\frac13\right)^3\left(\frac23\right)^9 =\frac{55}{3}\left(\frac23\right)^{11}.$$ So the intended answer is: $$\boxed{\frac{55}{3}\left(\frac23\right)^{11}}.$$ That corresponds to **Option C**. --- 8. **Comparison with stored answer** Stored correct answer: **C** My derived answer: **C** So they agree.
PreviousNext

More from Probability

  • Let A and B be two events such that P(A∪B)=61​,P(A∩B)=41​ and P(A)=41​, where A stands for the…2014 · MCQ
  • Three numbers are chosen at random without replacement from {1,2,3,..8}. The probability that their minimum is 3, given that their maximum is 6, is :2012 · MCQ
  • If C and D are two events such that C⊂D and P(D)e0, then the correct statement among the following is :2011 · MCQ
  • An urn contains nine balls of which three are red, four are blue and two are green. Three balls are drawn at random without replacement from the urn. The probability that the three balls have different colours is :2010 · MCQ
  • Four numbers are chosen at random (without replacement) from the set {1,2,3,....20}. Statement - 1: The probability that the chosen numbers when arranged in some order will form an AP is 851​. Statement -…2010 · MCQ
  • One ticket is selected at random from 50 tickets numbered 00,01,02,....,49. Then the probability that the sum of the digits on the selected ticket is 8, given that the product of these digits is zer, equals :2009 · MCQ
  • A die is thrown. Let A be the event that the number obtained is greater than 3. Let B be the event that the number obtained is less than 5. Then P(A∪B) is :2008 · MCQ
  • It is given that the events A and B are such that P(A)=41​,P(A∣B)=21​ and P(B∣A)=32​. Then P(B) is :2008 · MCQ