- AIn the ground state of Rutherford's model electrons are in stable equilibrium. While in Thomson's model electrons always experience a net-force.
- BAn atom has a nearly continuous mass distribution in a Rutherford's model but has a highly non-uniform mass distribution in Thomson's model.
- CA classical atom based on Rutherford's model is doomed to collapse.
- DThe positively charged part of the atom possesses most of the mass in Rutherford's model but not in Thomson's model.
View written solutionFree
Correct answer: C
-
Recall the two models
- Thomson model: atom is a uniformly positively charged sphere with electrons embedded in it.
- Rutherford model: almost all positive charge and mass are concentrated in a tiny nucleus; electrons revolve around it.
-
Check Option A
Option A says:
In the ground state of Rutherford's model electrons are in stable equilibrium. While in Thomson's model electrons always experience a net-force.
- In Rutherford's model, electrons revolve around the nucleus under electrostatic attraction. They are not in stable equilibrium; they have centripetal acceleration.
- In Thomson's model, if an electron is displaced inside a uniformly positively charged sphere, it can experience a restoring force; at the center net force can be zero.
So this statement is false.
-
Check Option B
Option B says:
An atom has a nearly continuous mass distribution in a Rutherford's model but has a highly non-uniform mass distribution in Thomson's model.
This is the reverse of the truth:
- In Thomson's model, positive charge (and hence mass, in that picture) is spread out more continuously.
- In Rutherford's model, mass distribution is highly non-uniform, concentrated in the nucleus.
So this statement is false.
-
Check Option C
Option C says:
A classical atom based on Rutherford's model is doomed to collapse.
In classical electrodynamics, a revolving electron is an accelerated charge, so it must radiate energy continuously. Hence its orbit would shrink and the electron would spiral into the nucleus.
Therefore, a classical Rutherford atom is indeed unstable and is doomed to collapse.
So Option C is true.
-
Check Option D
Option D says:
The positively charged part of the atom possesses most of the mass in Rutherford's model but not in Thomson's model.
- In Rutherford's model, yes: the nucleus (positive part) contains nearly all the mass.
- In Thomson's model, the positive charge is spread throughout the atom and was not viewed as a tiny localized heavy nucleus. The statement as a comparison is not the standard distinguishing feature, and for a single-correct MCQ the clearly correct classical conclusion is Option C.
Hence D is not the intended correct option.
-
Final conclusion
The correct option is:
-
Comparison with stored answer
Stored correct answer: C
My derived answer matches the stored answer.
More from Atoms and Nuclei
- Nucleus A is having mass number 220 and its binding energy per nucleon is 5.6 MeV. It splits in two fragments 'B' and 'C' of mass numbers 105 and 115. The binding energy of nucleons in 'B' and 'C' is 6.4 MeV per nucleon. The energy Q…2022 · MCQ
- In Bohr's atomic model of hydrogen, let K, P and E are the kinetic energy, potential energy and total energy of the electron respectively. Choose the correct option when the electron undergoes transitions to a higher level :2022 · MCQ
- The momentum of an electron revolving in orbit is given by : (Symbols have their usual meanings)2022 · MCQ
- The magnetic moment of an electron (e) revolving in an orbit around nucleus with an orbital angular momentum is given by :2022 · MCQ
- Hydrogen atom from excited state comes to the ground state by emitting a photon of wavelength . The value of principal quantum number '' of the excited state will be : ( Rydberg constant)2022 · MCQ
- is the ratio of energies of photons produced due to transition of an electron of hydrogen atom from its (i) third permitted energy level to the second level and (ii) the highest permitted energy level to the second…2022 · Numerical
- The ratio for the speed of the electron in the 3rd orbit of He+ to the speed of the electron in the 3rd orbit of hydrogen atom will be :2022 · MCQ
- In the hydrogen spectrum, be the wavelength of first transition line of Lyman series. The wavelength difference will be "a '' between the wavelength of transition line of Paschen series and that of …2022 · Numerical