Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Limits Continuity and Differentiability question

2018 · Shift 0 · Q42
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Main
  3. /Mathematics
  4. /Limits Continuity and Differentiability
  5. /2018 · Shift 0 · Q42

Limits Continuity and Differentiability question

2018 · Shift 0 · Q42

JEE MainMathematicsLimits Continuity and DifferentiabilityMCQ+4 / −1
Let S = { t ∈R:f(x)=∣x−π∣.(e∣x∣−1)sin⁡∣x∣\in R:f(x) = \left| {x - \pi } \right|.\left( {{e^{\left| x \right|}} - 1} \right)\sin \left| x \right|∈R:f(x)=∣x−π∣.(e∣x∣−1)sin∣x∣ is not differentiable at t}, then the set S is equal to
  1. A
    {0, π\piπ}
  2. B
    ϕ\phiϕ (an empty set)
  3. C
    {0}
  4. D
    {π\piπ}
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: NONE OF THE GIVEN OPTIONS IS CORRECT, S = {N\PI : N \IN \MATHBB{Z},\ N \NE 0,1}

  1. Given function

We need the points where

f(x)=∣x−π∣ (e∣x∣−1)sin⁡∣x∣ f(x)=|x-\pi|\,(e^{|x|}-1)\sin |x|f(x)=∣x−π∣(e∣x∣−1)sin∣x∣

is not differentiable.

Let us simplify first.

  1. Use the identity

Since sin⁡\sinsin is odd,

sin⁡∣x∣={sin⁡x,x≥0sin⁡(−x)=−sin⁡x,x<0\sin|x|= \begin{cases} \sin x, & x\ge 0 \\ \sin(-x)=-\sin x, & x<0 \end{cases}sin∣x∣={sinx,sin(−x)=−sinx,​x≥0x<0​

But this is exactly equal to ∣sin⁡x∣|\sin x|∣sinx∣ for all real xxx. Hence

sin⁡∣x∣=∣sin⁡x∣.\sin|x|=|\sin x|.sin∣x∣=∣sinx∣.

So

f(x)=∣x−π∣(e∣x∣−1)∣sin⁡x∣.f(x)=|x-\pi|(e^{|x|}-1)|\sin x|.f(x)=∣x−π∣(e∣x∣−1)∣sinx∣.

Thus possible non-differentiability can occur only where one of the absolute value factors may create a corner/cusp, namely around:

  • x=0x=0x=0 from ∣x∣|x|∣x∣,
  • x=πx=\pix=π from ∣x−π∣|x-\pi|∣x−π∣,
  • zeros of sin⁡x\sin xsinx because of ∣sin⁡x∣|\sin x|∣sinx∣, i.e. x=nπx=n\pix=nπ.

We now check these carefully.


  1. Check differentiability at x=0x=0x=0

Near x=0x=0x=0, we have:

  • ∣x−π∣=π−x|x-\pi|=\pi-x∣x−π∣=π−x for xxx near 000,
  • e∣x∣−1∼∣x∣e^{|x|}-1 \sim |x|e∣x∣−1∼∣x∣,
  • sin⁡∣x∣∼∣x∣\sin|x| \sim |x|sin∣x∣∼∣x∣.

Therefore,

f(x)∼(π−x)∣x∣ ∣x∣=(π−x)x2.f(x)\sim (\pi-x)|x|\,|x|=(\pi-x)x^2.f(x)∼(π−x)∣x∣∣x∣=(π−x)x2.

So near 000, f(x)f(x)f(x) behaves like a smooth multiple of x2x^2x2, hence should be differentiable.

More explicitly:

For x>0x>0x>0 near 000,

f(x)=(π−x)(ex−1)sin⁡x.f(x)=(\pi-x)(e^x-1)\sin x.f(x)=(π−x)(ex−1)sinx.

For x<0x<0x<0 near 000,

f(x)=(π−x)(e−x−1)(−sin⁡x).f(x)=(\pi-x)(e^{-x}-1)(-\sin x).f(x)=(π−x)(e−x−1)(−sinx).

Now

f(0)=∣−π∣(e0−1)sin⁡0=0.f(0)=|- \pi|(e^0-1)\sin 0=0.f(0)=∣−π∣(e0−1)sin0=0.

So

f′(0)=lim⁡h→0f(h)−f(0)h=lim⁡h→0f(h)h.f'(0)=\lim_{h\to 0}\frac{f(h)-f(0)}{h}=\lim_{h\to 0}\frac{f(h)}{h}.f′(0)=h→0lim​hf(h)−f(0)​=h→0lim​hf(h)​.

Using (e∣h∣−1)∼∣h∣(e^{|h|}-1)\sim |h|(e∣h∣−1)∼∣h∣ and sin⁡∣h∣∼∣h∣\sin|h|\sim |h|sin∣h∣∼∣h∣,

f(h)∼∣h−π∣ ∣h∣ ∣h∣∼πh2.f(h)\sim |h-\pi|\,|h|\,|h|\sim \pi h^2.f(h)∼∣h−π∣∣h∣∣h∣∼πh2.

Hence

f(h)h∼πh→0.\frac{f(h)}{h}\sim \pi h\to 0.hf(h)​∼πh→0.

So fff is differentiable at 000.


  1. Check differentiability at x=πx=\pix=π

At x=πx=\pix=π,

f(π)=∣π−π∣(e∣π∣−1)sin⁡∣π∣=0.f(\pi)=|\pi-\pi|(e^{|\pi|}-1)\sin|\pi|=0.f(π)=∣π−π∣(e∣π∣−1)sin∣π∣=0.

To test differentiability,

f′(π)=lim⁡h→0f(π+h)−f(π)h=lim⁡h→0f(π+h)h.f'(\pi)=\lim_{h\to 0}\frac{f(\pi+h)-f(\pi)}{h}= \lim_{h\to 0}\frac{f(\pi+h)}{h}.f′(π)=h→0lim​hf(π+h)−f(π)​=h→0lim​hf(π+h)​.

Now near x=πx=\pix=π:

  • ∣x−π∣=∣h∣|x-\pi|=|h|∣x−π∣=∣h∣,
  • e∣x∣−1=eπ+h−1e^{|x|}-1=e^{\pi+h}-1e∣x∣−1=eπ+h−1 (since π+h>0\pi+h>0π+h>0 near π\piπ), which tends to eπ−1e^\pi-1eπ−1,
  • sin⁡∣x∣=sin⁡(π+h)∼−h\sin|x|=\sin(\pi+h)\sim -hsin∣x∣=sin(π+h)∼−h in magnitude, so actually ∣sin⁡(π+h)∣∼∣h∣|\sin(\pi+h)|\sim |h|∣sin(π+h)∣∼∣h∣.

Thus

f(π+h)∼∣h∣ (eπ−1) ∣h∣=(eπ−1)h2.f(\pi+h)\sim |h|\,(e^\pi-1)\,|h|=(e^\pi-1)h^2.f(π+h)∼∣h∣(eπ−1)∣h∣=(eπ−1)h2.

Hence

f(π+h)h∼(eπ−1)h→0.\frac{f(\pi+h)}{h}\sim (e^\pi-1)h\to 0.hf(π+h)​∼(eπ−1)h→0.

So fff is differentiable at π\piπ.


  1. Check other multiples of π\piπ

If t=nπt=n\pit=nπ with n≠0,1n\ne 0,1n=0,1, then only ∣sin⁡x∣|\sin x|∣sinx∣ may be suspicious, since ∣x−π∣|x-\pi|∣x−π∣ and e∣x∣−1e^{|x|}-1e∣x∣−1 are differentiable at such points and are finite constants there.

Near x=t=nπx=t=n\pix=t=nπ, we have

∣sin⁡x∣∼∣x−t∣.|\sin x|\sim |x-t|.∣sinx∣∼∣x−t∣.

Therefore

f(x)∼∣t−π∣ (e∣t∣−1) ∣x−t∣.f(x)\sim |t-\pi|\,(e^{|t|}-1)\,|x-t|.f(x)∼∣t−π∣(e∣t∣−1)∣x−t∣.

Since the coefficient

∣t−π∣ (e∣t∣−1)|t-\pi|\,(e^{|t|}-1)∣t−π∣(e∣t∣−1)

is nonzero for t=nπt=n\pit=nπ with n≠0,1n\ne 0,1n=0,1, this behaves like a nonzero multiple of ∣x−t∣|x-t|∣x−t∣, which is not differentiable at x=tx=tx=t.

So all such multiples of π\piπ are points of non-differentiability.

Examples:

  • at x=−πx=-\pix=−π,
  • at x=2πx=2\pix=2π,
  • at x=−2πx=-2\pix=−2π, etc.

  1. Hence the set SSS

Therefore,

S={nπ:n∈Z, n≠0,1}.S=\{n\pi: n\in \mathbb Z,\ n\ne 0,1\}.S={nπ:n∈Z, n=0,1}.

In particular, SSS is not any of the listed finite sets, and certainly not empty.


  1. Evaluate options
  • A: {0,π}\{0,\pi\}{0,π} — false, since function is differentiable at both 000 and π\piπ.
  • B: ϕ\phiϕ — false, since it is not differentiable at x=−π,2π,…x=-\pi,2\pi,\dotsx=−π,2π,….
  • C: {0}\{0\}{0} — false.
  • D: {π}\{\pi\}{π} — false.

So none of the given options is correct.


  1. Comparison with stored correct answer

Stored correct answer is B (empty set), but that is incorrect because, for example, at x=2πx=2\pix=2π,

f(x)=∣x−π∣(e∣x∣−1)∣sin⁡x∣,f(x)=|x-\pi|(e^{|x|}-1)|\sin x|,f(x)=∣x−π∣(e∣x∣−1)∣sinx∣,

and near 2π2\pi2π this is a nonzero constant times ∣x−2π∣|x-2\pi|∣x−2π∣, which is not differentiable at 2π2\pi2π.

Thus the correct set is

S={nπ:n∈Z, n≠0,1}.S=\{n\pi: n\in \mathbb Z,\ n\ne 0,1\}.S={nπ:n∈Z, n=0,1}.
PreviousNext

More from Limits Continuity and Differentiability

  • For each t ∈R, let [t] be the greatest integer less than or equal to t. Then x→0+lim​x([x1​]+[x2​]+.....+[x15​])…2018 · MCQ
  • x→3lim​ 2x−4​−2​3x​−3​ is equal to :2017 · MCQ
  • The value of k for which the function f(x)={(54​)tan5xtan4x​,k+52​,​0<x<2π​x=2π​​…2017 · MCQ
  • x→2π​lim​(π−2x)3cotx−cosx​ equals2017 · MCQ
  • If the function f(x) = {−xa+cos−1(x+b),​x<11≤x≤2​ is differentiable at x = 1, then ba​ is equal to :2016 · MCQ
  • If x→∞lim​(1+xa​−x24​)2x=e3, then 'a' is equal to :2016 · MCQ
  • Let a, b ∈ R, (a e 0). If the function f defined as f(x)=⎩⎨⎧​a2x2​,a,x32b2−4b​,​0≤x<11≤x<2​2​≤x<∞​…2016 · MCQ
  • x→0lim​2xtanx−xtan2x(1−cos2x)2​ is :2016 · MCQ