Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

D and F Block Elements question

2017 · 8 Apr · Shift 1 · Q18
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Main
  3. /Chemistry
  4. /D and F Block Elements
  5. /2017 · 8 Apr · Shift 1 · Q18

D and F Block Elements question

2017 · 8 Apr · Shift 1 · Q18

JEE MainChemistryD and F Block ElementsMCQ+4 / −1
The pair of compounds having metals in their highest oxidation state is :
  1. A
    MnO2MnO_2MnO2​ and CrO2Cl2CrO_2Cl_2CrO2​Cl2​
  2. B
    [NiCl4]2−[NiCl_4]^{2-}[NiCl4​]2− and [CoCl4]2−[CoCl_4]^{2-}[CoCl4​]2−
  3. C
    [Fe(CN)6]3−[Fe(CN)_6]^{3-}[Fe(CN)6​]3− and [Cu(CN)4]2−[Cu(CN)_4]^{2-}[Cu(CN)4​]2−
  4. D
    [FeCl4]−[FeCl_4]^-[FeCl4​]− and Co2O3Co_2O_3Co2​O3​
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: NO OPTION IS STRICTLY CORRECT. IF FORCED BY THE GIVEN KEY, A IS THE INTENDED ANSWER, BUT MN IN $MNO_2$ IS NOT IN ITS HIGHEST OXIDATION STATE.

  1. Find the oxidation state of the metal in each compound and compare it with the maximum oxidation state shown by that metal.

  1. Option A: MnO2MnO_2MnO2​ and CrO2Cl2CrO_2Cl_2CrO2​Cl2​
  • In MnO2MnO_2MnO2​: x+2(−2)=0x + 2(-2) = 0x+2(−2)=0 x−4=0 ⇒ x=+4x - 4 = 0 \,\Rightarrow\, x = +4x−4=0⇒x=+4 So Mn is in +4+4+4 state.

    Highest oxidation state of Mn is +7+7+7, so this is not highest.

  • In CrO2Cl2CrO_2Cl_2CrO2​Cl2​: Let oxidation state of Cr be xxx. x+2(−2)+2(−1)=0x + 2(-2) + 2(-1) = 0x+2(−2)+2(−1)=0 x−4−2=0⇒x=+6x - 4 - 2 = 0 \Rightarrow x = +6x−4−2=0⇒x=+6 Highest oxidation state of Cr is +6+6+6, so this is highest.

Thus in option A, only Cr is at highest oxidation state, not Mn. So A is not correct.


  1. Option B: [NiCl4]2−[NiCl_4]^{2-}[NiCl4​]2− and [CoCl4]2−[CoCl_4]^{2-}[CoCl4​]2−
  • In [NiCl4]2−[NiCl_4]^{2-}[NiCl4​]2−: x+4(−1)=−2x + 4(-1) = -2x+4(−1)=−2 x−4=−2⇒x=+2x - 4 = -2 \Rightarrow x = +2x−4=−2⇒x=+2 Highest oxidation state of Ni is about +4+4+4, so not highest.

  • In [CoCl4]2−[CoCl_4]^{2-}[CoCl4​]2−: x+4(−1)=−2x + 4(-1) = -2x+4(−1)=−2 x−4=−2⇒x=+2x - 4 = -2 \Rightarrow x = +2x−4=−2⇒x=+2 Highest oxidation state of Co is +5+5+5 (or commonly +3+3+3 in introductory treatment), so not highest.

So B is not correct.


  1. Option C: [Fe(CN)6]3−[Fe(CN)_6]^{3-}[Fe(CN)6​]3− and [Cu(CN)4]2−[Cu(CN)_4]^{2-}[Cu(CN)4​]2−
  • In [Fe(CN)6]3−[Fe(CN)_6]^{3-}[Fe(CN)6​]3−: Each CN−CN^-CN− is −1-1−1. x+6(−1)=−3x + 6(-1) = -3x+6(−1)=−3 x−6=−3⇒x=+3x - 6 = -3 \Rightarrow x = +3x−6=−3⇒x=+3 Highest oxidation state of Fe is +6+6+6, so not highest.

  • In [Cu(CN)4]2−[Cu(CN)_4]^{2-}[Cu(CN)4​]2−: x+4(−1)=−2x + 4(-1) = -2x+4(−1)=−2 x−4=−2⇒x=+2x - 4 = -2 \Rightarrow x = +2x−4=−2⇒x=+2 Highest oxidation state of Cu is +3+3+3, so not highest.

So C is not correct.


  1. Option D: [FeCl4]−[FeCl_4]^-[FeCl4​]− and Co2O3Co_2O_3Co2​O3​
  • In [FeCl4]−[FeCl_4]^-[FeCl4​]−: x+4(−1)=−1x + 4(-1) = -1x+4(−1)=−1 x−4=−1⇒x=+3x - 4 = -1 \Rightarrow x = +3x−4=−1⇒x=+3 Highest oxidation state of Fe is +6+6+6, so not highest.

  • In Co2O3Co_2O_3Co2​O3​: 2x+3(−2)=02x + 3(-2) = 02x+3(−2)=0 2x−6=0⇒x=+32x - 6 = 0 \Rightarrow x = +32x−6=0⇒x=+3 Highest oxidation state of Co is +5+5+5 (or at least not restricted to +3+3+3), so not highest.

So D is not correct.


  1. Conclusion

By strict oxidation-state analysis, none of the given options contains both metals in their highest oxidation state.

However, in many exam keys, option A is marked because CrCrCr in CrO2Cl2CrO_2Cl_2CrO2​Cl2​ is definitely in its highest oxidation state +6+6+6, and the question may have intended a different manganese compound or used a flawed key. But MnMnMn in MnO2MnO_2MnO2​ is only +4+4+4, whereas Mn attains up to +7+7+7.

Therefore, the stored answer A is chemically inconsistent.

PreviousNext

More from D and F Block Elements

  • Which of the following ions does not liberate hydrogen gas on reaction with dilute acids ?2017 · MCQ
  • In the following reactions, ZnO is respectively acting as a/an : (a) ZnO + Na2​O → Na2​ZnO2​ (b) ZnO + CO2​ → ZnCO3​2017 · MCQ
  • Which one of the following species is stable in aqueous solution?2016 · MCQ
  • The transition metal ions responsible for color in ruby and emerald are, respectively :2016 · MCQ
  • Which of the following compounds is metallic and ferromagnetic ?2016 · MCQ
  • The reaction of zinc with dilute and concentrated nitric acid, respectively, produces :2016 · MCQ
  • The colour of KMnO4​ is due to :2015 · MCQ
  • Match the catalysts to the correct processes : Includes table2015 · MCQ