- Aand
- Band
- Cand
- Dand
View written solutionFree
Correct answer: NO OPTION IS STRICTLY CORRECT. IF FORCED BY THE GIVEN KEY, A IS THE INTENDED ANSWER, BUT MN IN $MNO_2$ IS NOT IN ITS HIGHEST OXIDATION STATE.
- Find the oxidation state of the metal in each compound and compare it with the maximum oxidation state shown by that metal.
- Option A: and
-
In : So Mn is in state.
Highest oxidation state of Mn is , so this is not highest.
-
In : Let oxidation state of Cr be . Highest oxidation state of Cr is , so this is highest.
Thus in option A, only Cr is at highest oxidation state, not Mn. So A is not correct.
- Option B: and
-
In : Highest oxidation state of Ni is about , so not highest.
-
In : Highest oxidation state of Co is (or commonly in introductory treatment), so not highest.
So B is not correct.
- Option C: and
-
In : Each is . Highest oxidation state of Fe is , so not highest.
-
In : Highest oxidation state of Cu is , so not highest.
So C is not correct.
- Option D: and
-
In : Highest oxidation state of Fe is , so not highest.
-
In : Highest oxidation state of Co is (or at least not restricted to ), so not highest.
So D is not correct.
- Conclusion
By strict oxidation-state analysis, none of the given options contains both metals in their highest oxidation state.
However, in many exam keys, option A is marked because in is definitely in its highest oxidation state , and the question may have intended a different manganese compound or used a flawed key. But in is only , whereas Mn attains up to .
Therefore, the stored answer A is chemically inconsistent.
More from D and F Block Elements
- Which of the following ions does not liberate hydrogen gas on reaction with dilute acids ?2017 · MCQ
- In the following reactions, is respectively acting as a/an : (a) + (b) + 2017 · MCQ
- Which one of the following species is stable in aqueous solution?2016 · MCQ
- The transition metal ions responsible for color in ruby and emerald are, respectively :2016 · MCQ
- Which of the following compounds is metallic and ferromagnetic ?2016 · MCQ
- The reaction of zinc with dilute and concentrated nitric acid, respectively, produces :2016 · MCQ
- The colour of is due to :2015 · MCQ
- Match the catalysts to the correct processes : Includes table2015 · MCQ