Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Impulse and Momentum question

2007 · Shift 1 · Q55
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Advanced
  3. /Physics
  4. /Impulse and Momentum
  5. /2007 · Shift 1 · Q55

Impulse and Momentum question

2007 · Shift 1 · Q55

JEE AdvancedPhysicsImpulse and MomentumMCQ+3 / −1
Statement 1 : In an elastic collision between two bodies, the relative speed of the bodies after collision is equal to the relative speed before the collision. Statement 2 : In an elastic collision, the linear momentum of the system is conserved.
  1. A
    Statement 1 is True, Statement 2 is True, Statement 2 is a CORRECT explanation for Statement 1
  2. B
    Statement 1 is True, Statement 2 is True, Statement 2 is NOT a CORRECT explanation for Statement 1
  3. C
    Statement 1 is True, Statement 2 is False
  4. D
    Statement 1 is False, Statement 2 is True
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: D

Step-by-step Analysis

  1. Analyze Statement 2: Statement 2 says: "In an elastic collision, the linear momentum of the system is conserved." The law of conservation of linear momentum states that if the net external force on a system of particles is zero, the total linear momentum of the system remains constant. A collision is a process that occurs over a very short time interval, where the forces the colliding bodies exert on each other (internal forces) are much larger than any external forces (like gravity or air resistance). Therefore, the net external force on the two-body system can be considered negligible. As a result, the total linear momentum of the system is conserved for any type of collision (elastic, inelastic, or perfectly inelastic) in the absence of significant external forces. Hence, Statement 2 is True.

  2. Analyze Statement 1: Statement 1 says: "In an elastic collision between two bodies, the relative speed of the bodies after collision is equal to the relative speed before the collision." This property is commonly known as Newton's law of restitution for a perfectly elastic collision, where the coefficient of restitution e=1e=1e=1. It is mathematically expressed as ∣v⃗2−v⃗1∣=∣u⃗1−u⃗2∣|\vec{v}_2 - \vec{v}_1| = |\vec{u}_1 - \vec{u}_2|∣v2​−v1​∣=∣u1​−u2​∣, where u⃗1,u⃗2\vec{u}_1, \vec{u}_2u1​,u2​ are initial velocities and v⃗1,v⃗2\vec{v}_1, \vec{v}_2v1​,v2​ are final velocities.

    Let's examine the conditions under which this is derived: The derivation requires both: (a) Conservation of linear momentum: m1u⃗1+m2u⃗2=m1v⃗1+m2v⃗2m_1 \vec{u}_1 + m_2 \vec{u}_2 = m_1 \vec{v}_1 + m_2 \vec{v}_2m1​u1​+m2​u2​=m1​v1​+m2​v2​ (b) Conservation of kinetic energy: 12m1u12+12m2u22=12m1v12+12m2v22\frac{1}{2}m_1 u_1^2 + \frac{1}{2}m_2 u_2^2 = \frac{1}{2}m_1 v_1^2 + \frac{1}{2}m_2 v_2^221​m1​u12​+21​m2​u22​=21​m1​v12​+21​m2​v22​

    The crucial point lies in the interpretation of "kinetic energy" and "bodies".

    • If the "bodies" are treated as point masses (or smooth spheres colliding centrally), then the only form of kinetic energy is translational. In this simplified model, an elastic collision conserves translational kinetic energy, and Statement 1 is indeed true.
    • However, the question uses the term "bodies", which can be extended rigid objects capable of rotation. The general definition of an elastic collision is one where the total kinetic energy is conserved. The total kinetic energy is the sum of translational and rotational kinetic energy: Ktotal=Ktrans+KrotK_{total} = K_{trans} + K_{rot}Ktotal​=Ktrans​+Krot​.
    • In a collision between extended bodies (e.g., an off-center collision or a collision with friction), it is possible for some of the initial translational kinetic energy to be converted into rotational kinetic energy. For instance, two non-rotating bodies can start to rotate after colliding. Ki,trans+Ki,rot=Kf,trans+Kf,rotK_{i, trans} + K_{i, rot} = K_{f, trans} + K_{f, rot}Ki,trans​+Ki,rot​=Kf,trans​+Kf,rot​ If the bodies are not rotating initially (Ki,rot=0K_{i, rot} = 0Ki,rot​=0) but acquire rotation (Kf,rot>0K_{f, rot} > 0Kf,rot​>0), then to conserve the total energy, the final translational kinetic energy must be less than the initial translational kinetic energy (Kf,trans<Ki,transK_{f, trans} < K_{i, trans}Kf,trans​<Ki,trans​).
    • The property that relative speed is conserved (Statement 1) is a direct consequence of the conservation of translational kinetic energy. Since translational kinetic energy is not necessarily conserved in a general elastic collision of extended bodies, Statement 1 is not universally true.

    Therefore, in the general case for "bodies", Statement 1 is False.

  3. Conclusion:

    • Statement 1 is False (as it's not true for all elastic collisions involving extended bodies).
    • Statement 2 is True (linear momentum is conserved in any collision within an isolated system).

    This corresponds to option D.

Previous

More from Impulse and Momentum

  • In a scattering experiment, a particle of mass 2m collides with another particle of mass m, which is initially at rest. Assuming the collision to be perfectly elastic, the maximum angular deviation θ of the heavier particle, as shown in… Includes diagram2025 · MCQ
  • A block of mass 5 kg moves along the x-direction subject to the force F=(−20x+10)N, with the value of x in metre. At time t=0 s, it is at rest at position x=1 m. The position and…2024 · MCQ
  • A slide with a frictionless curved surface, which becomes horizontal at its lower end, is fixed on the terrace of a building of height 3h from the ground, as shown in the figure. A spherical ball of mass m is released on the slide… Includes diagram2023 · Multiple correct
  • A particle of mass M = 0.2 kg is initially at rest in the xy-plane at a point (x = − l, y = − h), where l = 10 m and h = 1 m. The particle is accelerated at time t = 0 with a constant acceleration a = 10 m/s2 along the positive…2021 · Multiple correct
  • One end of a horizontal uniform beam of weight W and length L is hinged on a vertical wall at point O and its other end is supported by a light inextensible rope. The other end of the rope is fixed at point Q, at a height L above the hinge… Includes diagram2021 · Multiple correct
  • A pendulum consists of a bob of mass m = 0.1 kg and a massless inextensible string of length L = 1.0 m. It is suspended from a fixed point at height H = 0.9 m above a frictionless horizontal floor. Initially, the bob of the pendulum is…2021 · Numerical
  • A pendulum consists of a bob of mass m = 0.1 kg and a massless inextensible string of length L = 1.0 m. It is suspended from a fixed point at height H = 0.9 m above a frictionless horizontal floor. Initially, the bob of the pendulum is…2021 · Numerical
  • A particle of mass m is projected from the ground with an initial speed u0 at an angle α with the horizontal. At the highest point of its trajectory, it makes a completely inelastic collision with another identical particle, which…2013 · MCQ