Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Impulse and Momentum question

2013 · Shift 1 · Q45
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Advanced
  3. /Physics
  4. /Impulse and Momentum
  5. /2013 · Shift 1 · Q45

Impulse and Momentum question

2013 · Shift 1 · Q45

JEE AdvancedPhysicsImpulse and MomentumMCQ+2 / −0.5
A particle of mass m is projected from the ground with an initial speed u0 at an angle α\alphaα with the horizontal. At the highest point of its trajectory, it makes a completely inelastic collision with another identical particle, which was thrown vertically upward from the ground with the same initial speed u0. The angle that the composite system makes with the horizontal immediately after the collision is
  1. A
    π4{\pi \over 4}4π​
  2. B
    π4+α{\pi \over 4} + \alpha4π​+α
  3. C
    π2−α{\pi \over 2} - \alpha2π​−α
  4. D
    π2{\pi \over 2}2π​
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: NONE OF THE OPTIONS; CORRECT ANGLE IS $\DISPLAYSTYLE \FRAC{\PI}{4}-\FRAC{\ALPHA}{2}$

  1. Velocity of the first particle at the highest point

A particle is projected with speed u0u_0u0​ at angle α\alphaα.

Its horizontal and vertical components initially are: ux=u0cos⁡α,uy=u0sin⁡αu_x=u_0\cos\alpha, \qquad u_y=u_0\sin\alphaux​=u0​cosα,uy​=u0​sinα

At the highest point of projectile motion, the vertical velocity becomes zero, so the velocity of the first particle is purely horizontal: v⃗1=(u0cos⁡α) i^\vec v_1=(u_0\cos\alpha)\,\hat iv1​=(u0​cosα)i^


  1. Velocity of the second particle when it collides

The second identical particle is thrown vertically upward from the ground with speed u0u_0u0​.

We need its velocity at the instant of collision.

The collision occurs at the highest point of the first particle.

Time taken by the first particle to reach highest point: t=u0sin⁡αgt=\frac{u_0\sin\alpha}{g}t=gu0​sinα​

At this same time, the vertical velocity of the second particle is: v2=u0−gtv_2=u_0-gtv2​=u0​−gt

Substitute ttt: v2=u0−g(u0sin⁡αg)=u0(1−sin⁡α)v_2=u_0-g\left(\frac{u_0\sin\alpha}{g}\right)=u_0(1-\sin\alpha)v2​=u0​−g(gu0​sinα​)=u0​(1−sinα)

So its velocity is: v⃗2=u0(1−sin⁡α) j^\vec v_2=u_0(1-\sin\alpha)\,\hat jv2​=u0​(1−sinα)j^​


  1. Check that collision is possible

Height of highest point of first particle: H=u02sin⁡2α2gH=\frac{u_0^2\sin^2\alpha}{2g}H=2gu02​sin2α​

Height of second particle at time t=u0sin⁡αgt=\frac{u_0\sin\alpha}{g}t=gu0​sinα​: y=u0t−12gt2y=u_0 t-\frac12 gt^2y=u0​t−21​gt2 y=u0(u0sin⁡αg)−12g(u02sin⁡2αg2)y=u_0\left(\frac{u_0\sin\alpha}{g}\right)-\frac12 g\left(\frac{u_0^2\sin^2\alpha}{g^2}\right)y=u0​(gu0​sinα​)−21​g(g2u02​sin2α​) y=u02gsin⁡α−u022gsin⁡2αy=\frac{u_0^2}{g}\sin\alpha-\frac{u_0^2}{2g}\sin^2\alphay=gu02​​sinα−2gu02​​sin2α

For collision at the highest point, this must equal HHH: u02gsin⁡α−u022gsin⁡2α=u02sin⁡2α2g\frac{u_0^2}{g}\sin\alpha-\frac{u_0^2}{2g}\sin^2\alpha=\frac{u_0^2\sin^2\alpha}{2g}gu02​​sinα−2gu02​​sin2α=2gu02​sin2α​

This gives: sin⁡α=sin⁡2α\sin\alpha=\sin^2\alphasinα=sin2α sin⁡α(1−sin⁡α)=0\sin\alpha(1-\sin\alpha)=0sinα(1−sinα)=0

Thus, for a nontrivial collision, sin⁡α=1⇒α=π2\sin\alpha=1 \Rightarrow \alpha=\frac\pi2sinα=1⇒α=2π​

But in standard momentum-based JEE treatment, the intended interpretation is that at collision instant the second particle is moving vertically upward and the first is moving horizontally, and we use momentum conservation directly. Let us proceed with that intended setup.


  1. Apply conservation of momentum in completely inelastic collision

Masses are identical, each of mass mmm.

Before collision, total momentum is: p⃗=mv⃗1+mv⃗2\vec p=m\vec v_1+m\vec v_2p​=mv1​+mv2​

So, px=mu0cos⁡αp_x=m u_0\cos\alphapx​=mu0​cosα py=mu0(1−sin⁡α)p_y=m u_0(1-\sin\alpha)py​=mu0​(1−sinα)

After collision, the particles stick together, so total mass becomes 2m2m2m. Let the composite move at angle θ\thetaθ with the horizontal.

Then, tan⁡θ=pypx=u0(1−sin⁡α)u0cos⁡α\tan\theta=\frac{p_y}{p_x}=\frac{u_0(1-\sin\alpha)}{u_0\cos\alpha}tanθ=px​py​​=u0​cosαu0​(1−sinα)​ tan⁡θ=1−sin⁡αcos⁡α\tan\theta=\frac{1-\sin\alpha}{\cos\alpha}tanθ=cosα1−sinα​

Now simplify: 1−sin⁡αcos⁡α=(1−sin⁡α)(1+sin⁡α)cos⁡α(1+sin⁡α)\frac{1-\sin\alpha}{\cos\alpha}=\frac{(1-\sin\alpha)(1+\sin\alpha)}{\cos\alpha(1+\sin\alpha)}cosα1−sinα​=cosα(1+sinα)(1−sinα)(1+sinα)​ =1−sin⁡2αcos⁡α(1+sin⁡α)=\frac{1-\sin^2\alpha}{\cos\alpha(1+\sin\alpha)}=cosα(1+sinα)1−sin2α​ =cos⁡2αcos⁡α(1+sin⁡α)=\frac{\cos^2\alpha}{\cos\alpha(1+\sin\alpha)}=cosα(1+sinα)cos2α​ =cos⁡α1+sin⁡α=\frac{\cos\alpha}{1+\sin\alpha}=1+sinαcosα​

Using the identity: tan⁡(π4−α2)=1−sin⁡αcos⁡α\tan\left(\frac\pi4-\frac\alpha2\right)=\frac{1-\sin\alpha}{\cos\alpha}tan(4π​−2α​)=cosα1−sinα​

Therefore, θ=π4−α2\theta=\frac\pi4-\frac\alpha2θ=4π​−2α​

This result does not match any option.


  1. Compare with given options and stored answer

From correct momentum analysis, the angle should be: θ=π4−α2\boxed{\theta=\frac\pi4-\frac\alpha2}θ=4π​−2α​​

This is not among options A, B, C, D.

Hence the stored correct answer AAA is not consistent with the physics of the problem as stated.

PreviousNext

More from Impulse and Momentum

  • A particle of mass m is attached to one end of a mass-less spring of force constant k, lying on a frictionless horizontal plane. The other end of the spring is fixed. The particle starts moving horizontally from its equilibrium position at…2013 · Multiple correct
  • A lamina is made by removing a small disc of diameter 2R from a bigger disc of uniform mass density and radius 2R, as shown in the figure. The moment of inertia of this lamina about axes passing through O and P is IO and IP respectively.… Includes diagram2012 · Numerical
  • A ball of mass 0.2 kg rests on a vertical post of height 5 m. A bullet of mass 0.01 kg, traveling with a velocity V m/s in a horizontal direction, hits the center of the ball. After the collision, the ball and bullet travel independently.… Includes diagram2011 · MCQ
  • A point mass of 1 kg collides elastically with a stationary point mass of 5 kg. After their collision, the 1 kg mass reverses its direction and moves with a speed of 2 ms−1. Which of the following statement(s) is (are) correct for the…2010 · Multiple correct
  • Look at the drawing given in the figure below which has been drawn with ink of uniform line-thickness. The mass of ink used to draw each of the two inner circles, and each of the two line segments is m. the mass of the ink used to draw… Includes diagram2009 · MCQ
  • Two small particles of equal masses start moving in opposite directions from a point A in a horizontal circular orbit. Their tangential velocities are v and 2 v, respectively, as shown in the figure. Between collisions, the particles… Includes diagram2009 · MCQ
  • Two balls, having linear momenta p​1​=pi and p​2​=−pi, undergo a collision in free space. There is no external force acting on the balls. Let p′​1​ and p′​2​…2008 · Multiple correct
  • A small block of mass M moves on a frictionless surface of an inclined plane, as shown in figure. The angle of the incline suddenly changes from 60 ∘ to 30 ∘ at point B. The block is initially at rest at A. Assume that… Includes diagram2008 · MCQ