Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Atoms and Nuclei question

2015 · Shift 2 · Q55
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Advanced
  3. /Physics
  4. /Atoms and Nuclei
  5. /2015 · Shift 2 · Q55

Atoms and Nuclei question

2015 · Shift 2 · Q55

JEE AdvancedPhysicsAtoms and NucleiMultiple correct+4 / −2
A fission reaction is given by 92236U→54140Xe+3894Sr+x+y_{92}^{236}U \to _{54}^{140}Xe + _{38}^{94}Sr + x + y92236​U→54140​Xe+3894​Sr+x+y, where x and y are two particles. Considering 92236U_{92}^{236}U92236​U to be at rest, the kinetic energies of the products are denoted by KXe,KSr,Kx(2MeV){K_{Xe}},{K_{Sr}},{K_x}(2MeV)KXe​,KSr​,Kx​(2MeV)  and Ky(2MeV)\text { and } \mathrm{K}_{\mathrm{y}}(2 \mathrm{MeV}) and Ky​(2MeV), respectively. Let the binding energies per nucleon of 92236U_{92}^{236}U92236​U, 54140Xe_{54}^{140}Xe54140​Xe and 3894Sr_{38}^{94}Sr3894​Sr be 7.5 MeV, 8.5 MeV and 8.5 MeV, respectively. Considering different conservation laws, the correct options is/are
  1. A
    x = n, y = n, Ksr = 129 MeV, KXe = 86 MeV
  2. B
    x = p, y = e −-−, Ksr = 129 MeV, KXe = 86 MeV
  3. C
    x = p, y = n, Ksr = 129 MeV, KXe = 86 MeV
  4. D
    x = n, y = n, Ksr = 86 MeV, KXe = 129 MeV
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: A

  1. Identify the particles using conservation laws

Given: 92236U→ 54140Xe+ 3894Sr+x+y^{236}_{92}U \to \, ^{140}_{54}Xe + \, ^{94}_{38}Sr + x + y92236​U→54140​Xe+3894​Sr+x+y

We apply:

(a) Mass number conservation

Initial mass number: 236236236 Final from Xe and Sr: 140+94=234140+94=234140+94=234 So, Ax+Ay=236−234=2A_x + A_y = 236-234 = 2Ax​+Ay​=236−234=2

Thus the two emitted particles together must contribute mass number 2.

(b) Atomic number conservation

Initial atomic number: 929292 Final from Xe and Sr: 54+38=9254+38=9254+38=92 So, Zx+Zy=0Z_x + Z_y = 0Zx​+Zy​=0

Now check options:

  • Two neutrons: n+nn+nn+n gives A=1+1=2A=1+1=2A=1+1=2, Z=0+0=0Z=0+0=0Z=0+0=0 ✅
  • p+e−p+e^-p+e− gives A=1+0=1A=1+0=1A=1+0=1 ❌
  • p+np+np+n gives A=2A=2A=2, but Z=1+0=1Z=1+0=1Z=1+0=1 ❌

Hence, x=n,y=nx=n,\quad y=nx=n,y=n

So only A and D remain for kinetic energy checking.


  1. Find the total energy released (Q-value)

Binding energy of nucleus = (binding energy per nucleon)×mass number\text{(binding energy per nucleon)}\times \text{mass number}(binding energy per nucleon)×mass number

Initial nucleus: 236U^{236}U236U

BEi=236×7.5=1770 MeVBE_i = 236\times 7.5 = 1770\,\text{MeV}BEi​=236×7.5=1770MeV

Final nuclei:

For 140Xe^{140}Xe140Xe, BEXe=140×8.5=1190 MeVBE_{Xe} = 140\times 8.5 = 1190\,\text{MeV}BEXe​=140×8.5=1190MeV

For 94Sr^{94}Sr94Sr, BESr=94×8.5=799 MeVBE_{Sr} = 94\times 8.5 = 799\,\text{MeV}BESr​=94×8.5=799MeV

Total final binding energy: BEf=1190+799=1989 MeVBE_f = 1190+799 = 1989\,\text{MeV}BEf​=1190+799=1989MeV

Therefore energy released is Q=BEf−BEi=1989−1770=219 MeVQ = BE_f - BE_i = 1989-1770 = 219\,\text{MeV}Q=BEf​−BEi​=1989−1770=219MeV


  1. Use energy conservation

The uranium nucleus is initially at rest, so this released energy appears as kinetic energy of products.

Given: Kx=2 MeV,Ky=2 MeVK_x = 2\,\text{MeV}, \qquad K_y = 2\,\text{MeV}Kx​=2MeV,Ky​=2MeV

Hence, KXe+KSr+2+2=219K_{Xe}+K_{Sr}+2+2 = 219KXe​+KSr​+2+2=219 KXe+KSr=215 MeVK_{Xe}+K_{Sr} = 215\,\text{MeV}KXe​+KSr​=215MeV

Both A and D satisfy: 129+86=215129+86=215129+86=215

So energy conservation alone cannot distinguish A and D.


  1. Use momentum conservation

Since the initial uranium nucleus is at rest, p⃗Xe+p⃗Sr+p⃗x+p⃗y=0\vec p_{Xe}+\vec p_{Sr}+\vec p_x+\vec p_y=0p​Xe​+p​Sr​+p​x​+p​y​=0

The neutrons have very small kinetic energies only 2 MeV2\,\text{MeV}2MeV each, while the heavy fragments carry most of the energy. In fission, the two heavy fragments recoil nearly oppositely with approximately equal magnitudes of momentum.

So we use pXe≈pSrp_{Xe} \approx p_{Sr}pXe​≈pSr​

For non-relativistic heavy nuclei, K=p22MK=\frac{p^2}{2M}K=2Mp2​

If momenta are equal, then kinetic energy is inversely proportional to mass: K∝1MK \propto \frac{1}{M}K∝M1​

Thus the lighter fragment gets larger kinetic energy.

Masses are proportional to mass numbers:

  • Xe: A=140A=140A=140
  • Sr: A=94A=94A=94

Since 94Sr^{94}Sr94Sr is lighter, it must have larger kinetic energy.

So, KSr>KXeK_{Sr} > K_{Xe}KSr​>KXe​

Among A and D, only A satisfies this: KSr=129 MeV,KXe=86 MeVK_{Sr}=129\,\text{MeV},\quad K_{Xe}=86\,\text{MeV}KSr​=129MeV,KXe​=86MeV

Check ratio: KSrKXe≈14094≈1.49\frac{K_{Sr}}{K_{Xe}} \approx \frac{140}{94} \approx 1.49KXe​KSr​​≈94140​≈1.49 And 12986=1.50\frac{129}{86} = 1.5086129​=1.50 which matches very well.


  1. Evaluate each option
  • A: x=n,y=nx=n, y=nx=n,y=n, KSr=129 MeV,KXe=86 MeVK_{Sr}=129\,\text{MeV}, K_{Xe}=86\,\text{MeV}KSr​=129MeV,KXe​=86MeV ✅
  • B: violates mass number conservation ❌
  • C: violates charge conservation ❌
  • D: neutrons are correct, but heavier Xe cannot have more kinetic energy than lighter Sr under momentum conservation ❌

  1. Final answer

The correct option is: A\boxed{A}A​

PreviousNext

More from Atoms and Nuclei

  • If λ Cu is the wavelength of K α X-ray line of copper (atomic number 29) and λ Mo is the wavelength of the K α X-ray line of molybdenum (atomic number 42), then the ratio λ Cu/λ Mo is close to2014 · MCQ
  • A freshly prepared sample of a radioisotope of half-life 1386 s has activity 103 disintegrations per second. Given that ln2 = 0.693, the fraction of the initial number of nuclei (expressed in nearest integer percentage) that will decay in…2013 · Numerical
  • The radius of the orbit of an electron in a hydrogen-like atom is 4.5a0, where a0 is the Bohr radius. Its orbital angular momentum is 2π3h​. It is given that h is Planck constant and R is Rydberg constant. The possible…2013 · Multiple correct
  • The mass of a nucleus ZA​X is less than the sum of the masses of (A-Z) number of neutrons and Z number of protons in the nucleus. The energy equivalent to the corresponding mass difference is known as the binding energy of the nucleus.… Includes table2013 · MCQ
  • The mass of a nucleus ZA​X is less than the sum of the masses of (A-Z) number of neutrons and Z number of protons in the nucleus. The energy equivalent to the corresponding mass difference is known as the binding energy of the nucleus.… Includes table2013 · MCQ
  • Match List I of the nuclear processes with List II containing parent nucleus and one of the end products of each process and then select the correct answer using the codes given below the lists : Includes table2013 · MCQ
  • The β-decay process, discovered in around 1900, is basically the decay of a neutron (n). In the laboratory, a proton (p) and an electron (e −) are observed as the decay products of the neutron. Therefore, considering the decay of a…2012 · MCQ
  • The β-decay process, discovered in around 1900, is basically the decay of a neutron (n). In the laboratory, a proton (p) and an electron (e −) are observed as the decay products of the neutron. Therefore, considering the decay of a…2012 · MCQ