Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Atoms and Nuclei question

2012 · Shift 2 · Q56
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Advanced
  3. /Physics
  4. /Atoms and Nuclei
  5. /2012 · Shift 2 · Q56

Atoms and Nuclei question

2012 · Shift 2 · Q56

JEE AdvancedPhysicsAtoms and NucleiMCQ+3 / −1
The β\betaβ-decay process, discovered in around 1900, is basically the decay of a neutron (n). In the laboratory, a proton (p) and an electron (e −-−) are observed as the decay products of the neutron. Therefore, considering the decay of a neutron as a two-body decay process, it was predicted theoretically that the kinetic energy of the electron should be a constant. But experimentally, it was observed that the electron kinetic energy has continuous spectrum. Considering a three-body decay process, that is, n →\to→ p + e −-−+v‾e{\overline v _e}ve​, around 1930, Pauli explained the observed electron energy spectrum. Assuming the anti-neutrino (v‾e{\overline v _e}ve​) to be massless and possessing negligible energy, and the neutron to be at rest, momentum and energy conservation principles are applied. From this calculation, the maximum kinetic energy of the electron is 0.8 ×\times× 106 eV. The kinetic energy carried by the proton is only the recoil energy.If the anti-neutrino had a mass of 3 eV/c2 (where c is the speed of light) instead of zero mass, what should be the range of the kinetic energy, K, of the electron?
  1. A
    0 ≤\le≤ K ≤\le≤ 0.8 ×\times× 106 eV
  2. B
    3.0 eV ≤\le≤ K ≤\le≤ 0.8 ×\times× 106 eV
  3. C
    3.0 eV ≤\le≤ K 6 eV
  4. D
    0 ≤\le≤ K 6 eV
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: A

  1. Key idea

In the decay n→p+e−+νˉe,n \to p + e^- + \bar\nu_e,n→p+e−+νˉe​, the electron gets a continuous range of kinetic energies because the available decay energy is shared among three particles.

The question asks: if the anti-neutrino has rest mass mνc2=3 eV,m_\nu c^2 = 3\ \text{eV},mν​c2=3 eV, what is the possible range of electron kinetic energy KKK?


  1. Given information

For a massless anti-neutrino, the maximum electron kinetic energy is given as Kmax⁡=0.8×106 eV.K_{\max} = 0.8\times 10^6\ \text{eV}.Kmax​=0.8×106 eV. This corresponds to the situation where the anti-neutrino carries negligible energy, and the proton only takes tiny recoil energy.

So the total energy available for electron kinetic energy plus neutrino energy is about Q≈0.8×106 eV.Q \approx 0.8\times 10^6\ \text{eV}.Q≈0.8×106 eV.


  1. Effect of neutrino mass on maximum electron kinetic energy

If the anti-neutrino has mass, then at minimum it must carry its rest energy: Eν,min⁡=mνc2=3 eV.E_{\nu,\min} = m_\nu c^2 = 3\ \text{eV}.Eν,min​=mν​c2=3 eV.

Hence the electron can no longer take the full QQQ value. The new maximum electron kinetic energy becomes approximately Kmax⁡′=Q−mνc2=0.8×106−3 eV.K_{\max}' = Q - m_\nu c^2 = 0.8\times 10^6 - 3\ \text{eV}.Kmax′​=Q−mν​c2=0.8×106−3 eV.

Since 3 eV≪0.8×106 eV,3\ \text{eV} \ll 0.8\times 10^6\ \text{eV},3 eV≪0.8×106 eV, this is practically still Kmax⁡′≈0.8×106 eV.K_{\max}' \approx 0.8\times 10^6\ \text{eV}.Kmax′​≈0.8×106 eV.

So the upper limit remains essentially unchanged at the level of the options.


  1. Minimum electron kinetic energy

Can the electron have zero kinetic energy? Yes.

The available decay energy can be shared so that the electron is produced with arbitrarily small kinetic energy, while the proton and anti-neutrino carry the rest (subject to conservation laws).

The neutrino rest mass does not force the electron to have at least 3 eV3\ \text{eV}3 eV kinetic energy. The 3 eV3\ \text{eV}3 eV is simply the neutrino's rest energy requirement, not a lower bound on electron kinetic energy.

Therefore, Kmin⁡=0.K_{\min} = 0.Kmin​=0.


  1. Range of electron kinetic energy

Thus the electron kinetic energy range is 0≤K≲0.8×106 eV,0 \le K \lesssim 0.8\times 10^6\ \text{eV},0≤K≲0.8×106 eV, which matches the option written as 0≤K≤0.8×106 eV.0 \le K \le 0.8\times 10^6\ \text{eV}.0≤K≤0.8×106 eV.

So the correct option is A.


  1. Check options
  • A: 0≤K≤0.8×106 eV0 \le K \le 0.8\times 10^6\ \text{eV}0≤K≤0.8×106 eV

    • Correct in the sense of the given options; strictly the upper limit is smaller by 3 eV3\ \text{eV}3 eV, but that is negligible compared to 0.8×106 eV0.8\times 10^6\ \text{eV}0.8×106 eV.
  • B: 3 eV≤K≤0.8×106 eV3\ \text{eV} \le K \le 0.8\times 10^6\ \text{eV}3 eV≤K≤0.8×106 eV

    • Incorrect. Electron kinetic energy need not be at least 3 eV3\ \text{eV}3 eV.
  • C: 3 eV≤K≤6 eV3\ \text{eV} \le K \le 6\ \text{eV}3 eV≤K≤6 eV

    • Clearly incorrect.
  • D: 0≤K≤6 eV0 \le K \le 6\ \text{eV}0≤K≤6 eV

    • Incorrect. The upper limit remains of order 0.8×106 eV0.8\times 10^6\ \text{eV}0.8×106 eV, not 6 eV6\ \text{eV}6 eV.

  1. Conclusion

The physically correct range is 0≤K≤0.8×106 eV (approximately)\boxed{0 \le K \le 0.8\times 10^6\ \text{eV} \text{ (approximately)}}0≤K≤0.8×106 eV (approximately)​ so the correct option should be A, not D.

PreviousNext

More from Atoms and Nuclei

  • The wavelength of the first spectral line in the Balmer series of hydrogen atom is 6561 Ao​. The wavelength of the second spectral line in the Balmer series of singly-ionized helium atom is2011 · MCQ
  • To determine the half-life of a radioactive element, a student plots a graph of ln​dtdN(t)​​ versus t. Here, dtdN(t)​ is the rate of radioactive decay at time t. If the number of radioactive… Includes diagram2010 · Numerical
  • The key feature of Bohr's theory of spectrum of hydrogen atom is the quantization of angular momentum when an electron is revolving around a proton. We will extend this to a general rotational motion to find quantized rotational energy of…2010 · MCQ
  • The key feature of Bohr's theory of spectrum of hydrogen atom is the quantization of angular momentum when an electron is revolving around a proton. We will extend this to a general rotational motion to find quantized rotational energy of…2010 · MCQ
  • The key feature of Bohr's theory of spectrum of hydrogen atom is the quantization of angular momentum when an electron is revolving around a proton. We will extend this to a general rotational motion to find quantized rotational energy of…2010 · MCQ
  • When a particle is restricted to move along x-axis between x = 0 and x = a, where a is of nanometer dimension, its energy can take only certain specific values. The allowed energies of the particle moving in such a restricted region,…2009 · MCQ
  • Scientists are working hard to develop nuclear fusion reactor. Nuclei of heavy hydrogen, 12​ H, known as deuteron and denoted by D, can be thought of as a candidate for fusion reactor. The D-D reaction is 12​ H + 12​ H →23​…2009 · MCQ
  • Scientists are working hard to develop nuclear fusion reactor. Nuclei of heavy hydrogen, 12​ H, known as deuteron and denoted by D, can be thought of as a candidate for fusion reactor. The D-D reaction is 12​ H + 12​ H →23​…2009 · MCQ