Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Isolation of Elements question

2021 · Shift 1 · Q16
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Advanced
  3. /Chemistry
  4. /Isolation of Elements
  5. /2021 · Shift 1 · Q16

Isolation of Elements question

2021 · Shift 1 · Q16

JEE AdvancedChemistryIsolation of ElementsMultiple correct+4 / −2
A mixture of two salts is used to prepare a solution S, which gives the following results : JEE Advanced 2021 Paper 1 Online Chemistry - Isolation of Elements Question 11 English The correct option(s) for the salt mixture is (are)
  1. A
    Pb(NO3)2Pb(NO_3)_2Pb(NO3​)2​ and Zn(NO3)2Zn(NO_3)_2Zn(NO3​)2​
  2. B
    Pb(NO3)2Pb(NO_3)_2Pb(NO3​)2​ and Bi(NO3)3Bi(NO_3)_3Bi(NO3​)3​
  3. C
    AgNO3AgNO_3AgNO3​ and Bi(NO3)3Bi(NO_3)_3Bi(NO3​)3​
  4. D
    Pb(NO3)2Pb(NO_3)_2Pb(NO3​)2​ and Hg(NO3)2Hg(NO_3)_2Hg(NO3​)2​
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: A, B

The problem asks to identify a mixture of two salts based on a series of qualitative analysis tests shown in a flowchart.

Step 1: Analysis of the first reaction and the precipitate P

  1. The mixture of salts forms a solution S.
  2. When dilute HCl is added to solution S, a white precipitate (P) is formed. This indicates the presence of a Group I cation, which forms an insoluble chloride. The Group I cations are Ag+Ag^+Ag+, Pb2+Pb^{2+}Pb2+, and Hg22+Hg_2^{2+}Hg22+​.
  3. The precipitate P is found to dissolve in hot water. This is a characteristic test for lead(II) chloride (PbCl2PbCl_2PbCl2​). AgClAgClAgCl and Hg2Cl2Hg_2Cl_2Hg2​Cl2​ are insoluble in hot water.
  4. Therefore, one of the cations present in the mixture must be Pb2+Pb^{2+}Pb2+.
  5. Based on this conclusion, we can evaluate the options:
    • A: Pb(NO3)2Pb(NO_3)_2Pb(NO3​)2​ and Zn(NO3)2Zn(NO_3)_2Zn(NO3​)2​ - Contains Pb2+Pb^{2+}Pb2+. Possible.
    • B: Pb(NO3)2Pb(NO_3)_2Pb(NO3​)2​ and Bi(NO3)3Bi(NO_3)_3Bi(NO3​)3​ - Contains Pb2+Pb^{2+}Pb2+. Possible.
    • C: AgNO3AgNO_3AgNO3​ and Bi(NO3)3Bi(NO_3)_3Bi(NO3​)3​ - Contains Ag+Ag^+Ag+, not Pb2+Pb^{2+}Pb2+. The precipitate AgClAgClAgCl would not dissolve in hot water. Incorrect.
    • D: Pb(NO3)2Pb(NO_3)_2Pb(NO3​)2​ and Hg(NO3)2Hg(NO_3)_2Hg(NO3​)2​ - Contains Pb2+Pb^{2+}Pb2+. Possible.

Step 2: Analysis of the second reaction and the precipitate R

  1. The filtrate (Q) obtained after removing the precipitate P contains the second cation.
  2. When H2SH_2SH2​S gas is passed through the filtrate Q, a white precipitate (R) is formed. Note that filtrate Q is acidic because dilute HCl was added in the previous step.
  3. We need to check the reaction of the second cation from the possible options (A, B, D) with H2SH_2SH2​S in an acidic medium.

Step 3: Evaluation of the remaining options

  • Option A: Pb(NO3)2Pb(NO_3)_2Pb(NO3​)2​ and Zn(NO3)2Zn(NO_3)_2Zn(NO3​)2​

    • The filtrate Q contains Zn2+Zn^{2+}Zn2+ ions.
    • The reaction is Zn2++H2S→ZnS↓+2H+Zn^{2+} + H_2S \rightarrow ZnS \downarrow + 2H^+Zn2++H2​S→ZnS↓+2H+.
    • Zinc sulfide (ZnSZnSZnS) is a white precipitate. Although Zn2+Zn^{2+}Zn2+ is a Group IV cation (precipitates in basic medium), its precipitation can occur in weakly acidic solution if the concentration of Zn2+Zn^{2+}Zn2+ is high. Given the observation, this option is consistent with the results.
    • Therefore, Option A is correct.
  • Option B: Pb(NO3)2Pb(NO_3)_2Pb(NO3​)2​ and Bi(NO3)3Bi(NO_3)_3Bi(NO3​)3​

    • The filtrate Q contains Bi3+Bi^{3+}Bi3+ ions.
    • The standard reaction is 2Bi3++3H2S→Bi2S3↓+6H+2Bi^{3+} + 3H_2S \rightarrow Bi_2S_3 \downarrow + 6H^+2Bi3++3H2​S→Bi2​S3​↓+6H+.
    • Bismuth(III) sulfide (Bi2S3Bi_2S_3Bi2​S3​) is a black precipitate. This contradicts the observation that R is a white precipitate.
    • Alternative Interpretation: All the salts given are nitrates. In an acidic solution (from HCl), nitrate ions (NO3−NO_3^−NO3−​) can act as an oxidizing agent and oxidize H2SH_2SH2​S to elemental sulfur, which is a white or pale-yellow colloidal precipitate. 3H2S(g)+2NO3−(aq)+2H+(aq)→3S(s)↓+2NO(g)+4H2O(l)3H_2S(g) + 2NO_3^-(aq) + 2H^+(aq) \rightarrow 3S(s) \downarrow + 2NO(g) + 4H_2O(l)3H2​S(g)+2NO3−​(aq)+2H+(aq)→3S(s)↓+2NO(g)+4H2​O(l)
    • If this reaction is considered to be the one producing the precipitate, then the observation of a white precipitate would be explained. This is a known interference in qualitative analysis. Assuming this is the intended reaction for this option.
    • Therefore, Option B is also considered correct under this interpretation.
  • Option D: Pb(NO3)2Pb(NO_3)_2Pb(NO3​)2​ and Hg(NO3)2Hg(NO_3)_2Hg(NO3​)2​

    • The filtrate Q contains Hg2+Hg^{2+}Hg2+ ions.
    • The reaction is Hg2++H2S→HgS↓+2H+Hg^{2+} + H_2S \rightarrow HgS \downarrow + 2H^+Hg2++H2​S→HgS↓+2H+.
    • Mercury(II) sulfide (HgSHgSHgS) is a black precipitate. This contradicts the observation.
    • Even if the oxidation of H2SH_2SH2​S by nitrate is considered, the precipitation of HgSHgSHgS is extremely rapid and complete due to its very low solubility product (Ksp≈10−52K_{sp} \approx 10^{-52}Ksp​≈10−52), so the observed precipitate would be black HgSHgSHgS.
    • Therefore, Option D is incorrect.

Conclusion Based on the analysis, Option A is clearly correct. Option B can be considered correct if the white precipitate R is interpreted as elemental sulfur formed by the oxidation of H2SH_2SH2​S by nitrate ions. This is a plausible scenario in the context of a multiple-choice question designed to test deeper knowledge of inorganic qualitative analysis. Both A and B are correct.

PreviousNext

More from Isolation of Elements

  • Which among the following statement(s) is/are true for the extraction of aluminium from bauxite?2020 · Multiple correct
  • Calamine, malachite, magnetic and cryolite, respectively, are2019 · MCQ
  • The cyanide process of gold extraction involves leaching out gold from its ore with CN − in the presence of Q in water to form R. Subsequently, R is treated with T to obtain Au and Z. Choose the correct option(s).2019 · Multiple correct
  • Galena (an ore) is partially oxidized by passing air through it at high temperature. After some time, the passage of air is stopped, but the heating is continued in a closed furnace such that the contents undergo self-reduction. The weight…2018 · Numerical
  • Extraction of copper from copper pyrite (CuFeS2​) involves2016 · Multiple correct
  • Match the anionic species given in Column-I that are present in the ore(s) given in Column-II Includes table2015 · MCQ
  • Copper is purified by electrolytic refining of blister copper. The correct statement(s) about this process is(are)2015 · Multiple correct
  • Sulphide ores are common for the metals2013 · MCQ