JEE AdvancedChemistryIsolation of ElementsMultiple correct+4 / −2
A mixture of two salts is used to prepare a solution S, which gives the following results :
The correct option(s) for the salt mixture is (are)
The correct option(s) for the salt mixture is (are)- Aand
- Band
- Cand
- Dand
View written solutionFree
Correct answer: A, B
The problem asks to identify a mixture of two salts based on a series of qualitative analysis tests shown in a flowchart.
Step 1: Analysis of the first reaction and the precipitate P
- The mixture of salts forms a solution S.
- When dilute HCl is added to solution S, a white precipitate (P) is formed. This indicates the presence of a Group I cation, which forms an insoluble chloride. The Group I cations are , , and .
- The precipitate P is found to dissolve in hot water. This is a characteristic test for lead(II) chloride (). and are insoluble in hot water.
- Therefore, one of the cations present in the mixture must be .
- Based on this conclusion, we can evaluate the options:
- A: and - Contains . Possible.
- B: and - Contains . Possible.
- C: and - Contains , not . The precipitate would not dissolve in hot water. Incorrect.
- D: and - Contains . Possible.
Step 2: Analysis of the second reaction and the precipitate R
- The filtrate (Q) obtained after removing the precipitate P contains the second cation.
- When gas is passed through the filtrate Q, a white precipitate (R) is formed. Note that filtrate Q is acidic because dilute HCl was added in the previous step.
- We need to check the reaction of the second cation from the possible options (A, B, D) with in an acidic medium.
Step 3: Evaluation of the remaining options
-
Option A: and
- The filtrate Q contains ions.
- The reaction is .
- Zinc sulfide () is a white precipitate. Although is a Group IV cation (precipitates in basic medium), its precipitation can occur in weakly acidic solution if the concentration of is high. Given the observation, this option is consistent with the results.
- Therefore, Option A is correct.
-
Option B: and
- The filtrate Q contains ions.
- The standard reaction is .
- Bismuth(III) sulfide () is a black precipitate. This contradicts the observation that R is a white precipitate.
- Alternative Interpretation: All the salts given are nitrates. In an acidic solution (from HCl), nitrate ions () can act as an oxidizing agent and oxidize to elemental sulfur, which is a white or pale-yellow colloidal precipitate.
- If this reaction is considered to be the one producing the precipitate, then the observation of a white precipitate would be explained. This is a known interference in qualitative analysis. Assuming this is the intended reaction for this option.
- Therefore, Option B is also considered correct under this interpretation.
-
Option D: and
- The filtrate Q contains ions.
- The reaction is .
- Mercury(II) sulfide () is a black precipitate. This contradicts the observation.
- Even if the oxidation of by nitrate is considered, the precipitation of is extremely rapid and complete due to its very low solubility product (), so the observed precipitate would be black .
- Therefore, Option D is incorrect.
Conclusion Based on the analysis, Option A is clearly correct. Option B can be considered correct if the white precipitate R is interpreted as elemental sulfur formed by the oxidation of by nitrate ions. This is a plausible scenario in the context of a multiple-choice question designed to test deeper knowledge of inorganic qualitative analysis. Both A and B are correct.
More from Isolation of Elements
- Which among the following statement(s) is/are true for the extraction of aluminium from bauxite?2020 · Multiple correct
- Calamine, malachite, magnetic and cryolite, respectively, are2019 · MCQ
- The cyanide process of gold extraction involves leaching out gold from its ore with CN in the presence of Q in water to form R. Subsequently, R is treated with T to obtain Au and Z. Choose the correct option(s).2019 · Multiple correct
- Galena (an ore) is partially oxidized by passing air through it at high temperature. After some time, the passage of air is stopped, but the heating is continued in a closed furnace such that the contents undergo self-reduction. The weight…2018 · Numerical
- Extraction of copper from copper pyrite () involves2016 · Multiple correct
- Match the anionic species given in Column-I that are present in the ore(s) given in Column-II Includes table2015 · MCQ
- Copper is purified by electrolytic refining of blister copper. The correct statement(s) about this process is(are)2015 · Multiple correct
- Sulphide ores are common for the metals2013 · MCQ