Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Atoms and Nuclei question

2020 · 6 Sep · Shift 2 · Q53
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Main
  3. /Physics
  4. /Atoms and Nuclei
  5. /2020 · 6 Sep · Shift 2 · Q53

Atoms and Nuclei question

2020 · 6 Sep · Shift 2 · Q53

JEE MainPhysicsAtoms and NucleiMCQ+4 / −1
Given the masses of various atomic particles mp = 1.0072 u, mn = 1.0087 u, me = 0.000548 u, mv‾{m_{\overline v }}mv​= 0, md = 2.0141 u, where p ≡\equiv≡ proton, n ≡\equiv≡ neutron, e ≡\equiv≡ electron, v‾≡\overline v \equivv≡ antineutrino and d ≡\equiv≡ deuteron. Which of the following process is allowed by momentum and energy conservation?
  1. A
    n + n →\to→ deuterium atom (electron bound to the nucleus)
  2. B
    n + p →\to→ d + γ\gammaγ
  3. C
    p →\to→ n + e+ + v‾\overline vv
  4. D
    e+ + e- →γ\to \gamma→γ
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: B

  1. We check each option using conservation of charge, energy, and momentum.
    A process is allowed only if all conserved quantities can be satisfied simultaneously.

Given masses: mp=1.0072 u,mn=1.0087 u,me=0.000548 u,mνˉ=0,md=2.0141 um_p=1.0072\,u,\quad m_n=1.0087\,u,\quad m_e=0.000548\,u,\quad m_{\bar\nu}=0,\quad m_d=2.0141\,ump​=1.0072u,mn​=1.0087u,me​=0.000548u,mνˉ​=0,md​=2.0141u

Also, the mass of a deuterium atom is m(deuterium atom)=md+me=2.0141+0.000548=2.014648 um(\text{deuterium atom})=m_d+m_e=2.0141+0.000548=2.014648\,um(deuterium atom)=md​+me​=2.0141+0.000548=2.014648u


  1. Option A: n+n→n+n \ton+n→ deuterium atom

Reaction: n+n→d+e−n+n \to d+e^-n+n→d+e− (since deuterium atom means deuteron + bound electron)

(i) Charge conservation

Initial charge: 0+0=00+0=00+0=0 Final charge: +1+(−1)=0+1+(-1)=0+1+(−1)=0 So charge is okay.

(ii) Energy conservation

Initial mass: 2mn=2(1.0087)=2.0174 u2m_n=2(1.0087)=2.0174\,u2mn​=2(1.0087)=2.0174u Final mass: md+me=2.0141+0.000548=2.014648 um_d+m_e=2.0141+0.000548=2.014648\,umd​+me​=2.0141+0.000548=2.014648u Mass difference: Δm=2.0174−2.014648=0.002752 u>0\Delta m=2.0174-2.014648=0.002752\,u>0Δm=2.0174−2.014648=0.002752u>0 So energy could in principle be released.

(iii) Momentum conservation

This is a two-body initial to one composite final object process if treated as just forming a deuterium atom. In the center-of-mass frame, initial total momentum can be zero, but then the final single particle must also have zero momentum. That would force its total energy to be just its rest energy, while initial energy is larger. The excess energy has nowhere to go.

So with only one final object, simultaneous energy and momentum conservation is impossible unless initial total energy exactly equals final rest mass, which it does not.

Hence A is not allowed.


  1. Option B: n+p→d+γn+p \to d+\gamman+p→d+γ

This is radiative capture.

(i) Charge conservation

Initial charge: 0+(+1)=+10+(+1)=+10+(+1)=+1 Final charge: d has charge +1,γ has 0d\text{ has charge }+1,\quad \gamma\text{ has }0d has charge +1,γ has 0 So charge is conserved.

(ii) Energy check

Initial mass: mn+mp=1.0087+1.0072=2.0159 um_n+m_p=1.0087+1.0072=2.0159\,umn​+mp​=1.0087+1.0072=2.0159u Final rest mass (excluding photon energy): md=2.0141 um_d=2.0141\,umd​=2.0141u Mass difference: Δm=2.0159−2.0141=0.0018 u>0\Delta m=2.0159-2.0141=0.0018\,u>0Δm=2.0159−2.0141=0.0018u>0 So the released energy can be carried away by the photon.

(iii) Momentum conservation

Because there are two final particles (ddd and γ\gammaγ), momentum can be conserved: in the center-of-mass frame, the deuteron and photon recoil with equal and opposite momenta.

Therefore B is allowed.


  1. Option C: p→n+e++νˉp \to n+e^++\bar\nup→n+e++νˉ

(i) Charge conservation

Initial charge: +1+1+1 Final charge: 0+(+1)+0=+10+(+1)+0=+10+(+1)+0=+1 Charge is conserved.

(ii) Energy conservation

Initial mass: mp=1.0072 um_p=1.0072\,ump​=1.0072u Final minimum mass: mn+me+mνˉ=1.0087+0.000548+0=1.009248 um_n+m_e+m_{\bar\nu}=1.0087+0.000548+0=1.009248\,umn​+me​+mνˉ​=1.0087+0.000548+0=1.009248u Since 1.009248 u>1.0072 u1.009248\,u > 1.0072\,u1.009248u>1.0072u we need extra mass-energy, but none is available for a free proton decay.

Thus energy conservation fails.

Hence C is not allowed.


  1. Option D: e++e−→γe^++e^- \to \gammae++e−→γ

(i) Charge conservation

Initial charge: +1+(−1)=0+1+(-1)=0+1+(−1)=0 Final charge: 000 Charge is fine.

(ii) Momentum and energy conservation

A single photon has energy-momentum relation Eγ=pγcE_\gamma = p_\gamma cEγ​=pγ​c In the center-of-mass frame of e+e^+e+ and e−e^-e−, initial total momentum can be zero. If only one photon is produced, final momentum would be nonzero for any real photon, which is impossible. A photon cannot have zero momentum unless it has zero energy, so one-photon annihilation in free space is forbidden.

Therefore D is not allowed.

(That is why free e+e−e^+e^-e+e− annihilation normally produces two photons.)


  1. Conclusion Only option B satisfies both energy and momentum conservation.

B\boxed{\text{B}}B​

PreviousNext

More from Atoms and Nuclei

  • The time period of revolution of electron in its ground state orbit in a hydrogen atom is 1.6 × 10-16 s. The frequency of revolution of the electron in its first excited state (in s-1) is :2020 · MCQ
  • The graph which depicts the results of Rutherford gold foil experiment with α-particales is : θ: Scattering angle Y : Number of scattered α-particles detected (Plots are schematic and not to scale)2020 · MCQ
  • The first member of the Balmer series of hydrogen atom has a wavelength of 6561 Å. The wavelength of the second member of the Balmer series (in nm) is:2020 · Numerical
  • The energy required to ionise a hydrogen like ion in its ground state is 9 Rydbergs. What is the wavelength of the radiation emitted when the electron in this ion jumps from the second excited state to the ground state ?2020 · MCQ
  • Radiation coming from transitions n = 2 to n = 1 of hydrogen atoms fall on He+ ions in n = 1 and n = 2 states. The possible transition of helium ions as they absorb energy from the radiation is :2019 · MCQ
  • The ratio of mass densities of nuclei of 40Ca and 16O is close to :-2019 · MCQ
  • Taking the wavelength of first Balmer line in hydrogen spectrum (n = 3 to n = 2) as 660 nm, the wavelength of the 2nd Balmer line (n = 4 to n = 2) will be :2019 · MCQ
  • A He+ ion is in its first excited state. Its ionization energy is :-2019 · MCQ