- AA is correct but R is not correct
- BA is not correct but R is correct
- CBoth A and R are correct but R is NOT the correct explanation of A
- DBoth A and R are correct and R is the correct explanation of A
View written solutionFree
Correct answer: C
-
Analyze Assertion A
The compound is said to be isomorphous with .
- In compounds like , the formulation is better written as:
- Here, the anion is the triiodide ion, .
So, similarly, being isomorphous with means it is actually:
Therefore, thallium is present in the +1 oxidation state, not +3.
Hence, Assertion A is correct.
-
Analyze Reason R
Electronic configuration of thallium () is:
So thallium indeed has fourteen electrons.
Hence, Reason R is also correct.
-
Check whether R explains A
The real reason for the stability of over is the inert pair effect.
- In heavier p-block elements like Tl, the electrons are reluctant to participate in bonding.
- This happens due to poor shielding by inner and electrons, which increases effective nuclear attraction on the electrons.
Although the presence of electrons is true and contributes indirectly through poor shielding, the statement "Tl metal has fourteen electrons" alone is not the proper explanation of why in thallium is effectively in the +1 state.
Thus, both A and R are correct, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
-
Correct option
More from P Block Elements
- In polythionic acid, (x = 3 to 5) the oxidation state(s) of sulphur is/are :2021 · MCQ
- Match List - I with List - II : Choose the correct answer from the options given below : Includes table2021 · MCQ
- Given below are two statement : one is labelled as Assertion A and the other is labelled as Reason R. Assertion A : (g) is absorbed to a large extent than (g) on activated charcoal. Reason R : (g) has a higher critical…2021 · MCQ
- Boron and silicon of very high purity can be obtained through :2020 · MCQ
- The correct statement with respect to dinitrogen is :2020 · MCQ
- A metal (A) on heating in nitrogen gas gives compound B. B on treatment with gives a colourless gas which when passed through solution gives a dark blue-violet coloured solution. A and B respectively, are :2020 · MCQ
- The reaction of (A) with in tetrahydrofuran gives inorganic benzene (B). Further, the reaction of (A) with (C) leads to . Compounds (B) and (C) respectively, are :2020 · MCQ
- The correct statements among I to III regarding group 13 element oxides are, (I) Boron trioxide is acidic. (II) Oxides of aluminium and gallium are amphoteric. (III) Oxides of indium and thalliumare basic.2019 · MCQ