Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Laws of Motion question

2020 · Shift 1 · Q43
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Advanced
  3. /Physics
  4. /Laws of Motion
  5. /2020 · Shift 1 · Q43

Laws of Motion question

2020 · Shift 1 · Q43

JEE AdvancedPhysicsLaws of MotionNumerical+4 / −1
Put a uniform meter scale horizontally on your extended index fingers with the left one at 0.00 cm and the right one at 90.00 cm. When you attempt to move both the fingers slowly towards the center, initially only the left finger slips with respect to the scale and the right finger does not. After some distance, the left finger stops and the right one starts slipping. Then the right finger stops at a distance xR from the center (50.00 cm) of the scale and the left one starts slipping again. This happens because of the difference in the frictional forces on the two fingers. If the coefficients of static and dynamic friction between the fingers and the scale are 0.40 and 0.32, respectively, the value of xR (in cm) is ‾\underline{\hspace{2cm}}​.
Numerical answer
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: 25.60

  1. Setup and idea

A uniform meter scale has its center of mass at 50 cm50\ \text{cm}50 cm.

Initially:

  • Left finger at xL=0x_L=0xL​=0
  • Right finger at xR=90x_R=90xR​=90

When both fingers are pushed inward slowly, the finger with smaller normal reaction slips first because the maximum static friction fsmax⁡=μsNf_s^{\max}=\mu_s Nfsmax​=μs​N is smaller there.

Also, when one finger slips, friction on that finger is kinetic: fk=μkNf_k=\mu_k Nfk​=μk​N while the other finger remains stuck (static friction adjusts as needed).

The switching occurs when the slipping finger can no longer sustain the required friction and the other one begins to slip.


  1. Normal reactions when fingers are at positions xLx_LxL​ and xRx_RxR​

Let the weight of the scale be WWW acting at 50 cm50\ \text{cm}50 cm.

From vertical equilibrium: NL+NR=WN_L+N_R=WNL​+NR​=W

Taking moments about the left finger: NR(xR−xL)=W(50−xL)N_R(x_R-x_L)=W(50-x_L)NR​(xR​−xL​)=W(50−xL​) ⇒NR=W(50−xL)xR−xL\Rightarrow N_R=\frac{W(50-x_L)}{x_R-x_L}⇒NR​=xR​−xL​W(50−xL​)​

Similarly, NL=W(xR−50)xR−xLN_L=\frac{W(x_R-50)}{x_R-x_L}NL​=xR​−xL​W(xR​−50)​


  1. Why the left finger slips first

Initially, xL=0,xR=90x_L=0, x_R=90xL​=0,xR​=90.

So, NL=W(90−50)90−0=40W90=4W9N_L=\frac{W(90-50)}{90-0}=\frac{40W}{90}=\frac{4W}{9}NL​=90−0W(90−50)​=9040W​=94W​ NR=W(50−0)90=5W9N_R=\frac{W(50-0)}{90}=\frac{5W}{9}NR​=90W(50−0)​=95W​

Since NL<NRN_L<N_RNL​<NR​, the left finger has smaller frictional capacity and slips first.

This matches the statement in the question.


  1. Condition for switching from left slipping to right slipping

While the left finger slips and the right finger is stuck:

  • Left friction is kinetic: fL=μkNLf_L=\mu_k N_LfL​=μk​NL​
  • Right friction is static and equals the same horizontal force needed for equilibrium, so at the switching point: μkNL=μsNR\mu_k N_L=\mu_s N_Rμk​NL​=μs​NR​

At this instant, the right finger is just about to slip.

During this phase, the right finger stays fixed at xR=90x_R=90xR​=90, and the left finger moves to some position xLx_LxL​.

Using the reaction formulas: NL=W(90−50)90−xL=40W90−xLN_L=\frac{W(90-50)}{90-x_L}=\frac{40W}{90-x_L}NL​=90−xL​W(90−50)​=90−xL​40W​ NR=W(50−xL)90−xLN_R=\frac{W(50-x_L)}{90-x_L}NR​=90−xL​W(50−xL​)​

Now apply switching condition: μkNL=μsNR\mu_k N_L=\mu_s N_Rμk​NL​=μs​NR​ 0.32⋅40W90−xL=0.40⋅W(50−xL)90−xL0.32\cdot \frac{40W}{90-x_L}=0.40\cdot \frac{W(50-x_L)}{90-x_L}0.32⋅90−xL​40W​=0.40⋅90−xL​W(50−xL​)​

Cancel WWW and (90−xL)(90-x_L)(90−xL​): 0.32⋅40=0.40(50−xL)0.32\cdot 40=0.40(50-x_L)0.32⋅40=0.40(50−xL​) 12.8=20−0.4xL12.8=20-0.4x_L12.8=20−0.4xL​ 0.4xL=7.20.4x_L=7.20.4xL​=7.2 xL=18 cmx_L=18\ \text{cm}xL​=18 cm

So the left finger stops at 18 cm18\ \text{cm}18 cm, and then the right finger begins to slip.


  1. Second phase: right finger slips, left finger fixed at 181818 cm

Now:

  • Left finger remains fixed at xL=18x_L=18xL​=18
  • Right finger moves inward to some position xRx_RxR​

At the next switching point, the right finger stops and the left finger starts slipping again.

So at that instant:

  • Right finger friction is kinetic: fR=μkNRf_R=\mu_k N_RfR​=μk​NR​
  • Left finger is at limiting static friction: fL=μsNLf_L=\mu_s N_LfL​=μs​NL​

Thus, μkNR=μsNL\mu_k N_R=\mu_s N_Lμk​NR​=μs​NL​

With xL=18x_L=18xL​=18, the reactions are NR=W(50−18)xR−18=32WxR−18N_R=\frac{W(50-18)}{x_R-18}=\frac{32W}{x_R-18}NR​=xR​−18W(50−18)​=xR​−1832W​ NL=W(xR−50)xR−18N_L=\frac{W(x_R-50)}{x_R-18}NL​=xR​−18W(xR​−50)​

Apply the condition: 0.32⋅32WxR−18=0.40⋅W(xR−50)xR−180.32\cdot \frac{32W}{x_R-18}=0.40\cdot \frac{W(x_R-50)}{x_R-18}0.32⋅xR​−1832W​=0.40⋅xR​−18W(xR​−50)​

Cancel WWW and (xR−18)(x_R-18)(xR​−18): 0.32⋅32=0.40(xR−50)0.32\cdot 32=0.40(x_R-50)0.32⋅32=0.40(xR​−50) 10.24=0.40(xR−50)10.24=0.40(x_R-50)10.24=0.40(xR​−50) xR−50=25.6x_R-50=25.6xR​−50=25.6 xR=75.6 cmx_R=75.6\ \text{cm}xR​=75.6 cm

The question asks for the distance from the center 50 cm50\ \text{cm}50 cm: xR=75.6−50=25.6 cmx_R=75.6-50=25.6\ \text{cm}xR​=75.6−50=25.6 cm


  1. Final answer

25.60\boxed{25.60}25.60​

This matches the stored correct answer.

PreviousNext

More from Laws of Motion

  • A block of mass 2M is attached to a massless spring with spring-constant k.This block is connected to two other blocks of masses M and 2M using two massless pulleys and strings. The accelerations of the blocks are a1, a2 and a3 as shown in… Includes diagram2019 · Multiple correct
  • A solid horizontal surface is covered with a thin layer of oil. A rectangular block of mass m=0.4kg is at rest on this surface. An impulse of 1.0Ns is applied to the block at time t=0 so that it starts moving along the x-axis with…2018 · Numerical
  • In the figure, a ladder of mass m is shown leaning against a wall. It is in static equilibrium making an angle θ with the horizontal floor. The coefficient of friction between the wall and the ladder is μ 1 and that between the… Includes diagram2014 · Multiple correct
  • A wire, which passes through the hole in a small bead, is bent in the form of quarter of a circle. The wire is fixed vertically on ground as shown in the below figure. The bead is released from near the top of the wire and it slides along… Includes diagram2014 · MCQ
  • A block of mass m1 = 1 kg another mass m2 = 2 kg, are placed together (see figure) on an inclined plane with angle of inclination θ. Various values of θ are given in List I. The coefficient of friction between the block m1… Includes table Includes diagram2014 · MCQ
  • A small block of mass 0.1 kg lies on a fixed inclined plane PQ which makes an angle θ with the horizontal. A horizontal force of 1 N acts on the block through its centre of mass as shown in the figure. The block remains stationary… Includes diagram2012 · Multiple correct
  • A ball of mass (m) 0.5 kg is attached to the end of a string having length (L) 0.5 m. The ball is rotated on a horizontal circular path about vertical axis. The maximum tension that the string can bear is 324 N. The maximum possible value… Includes diagram2011 · MCQ
  • A block is moving on an inclined plane making an angle 45∘ with the horizontal and the coefficient of friction is μ. The force required to just push it up the inclined plane is 3 times the force required to just prevent it from…2011 · Numerical