Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Laws of Motion question

2019 · Shift 2 · Q40
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Advanced
  3. /Physics
  4. /Laws of Motion
  5. /2019 · Shift 2 · Q40

Laws of Motion question

2019 · Shift 2 · Q40

JEE AdvancedPhysicsLaws of MotionMultiple correct+4 / −1
A block of mass 2M is attached to a massless spring with spring-constant k.This block is connected to two other blocks of masses M and 2M using two massless pulleys and strings. The accelerations of the blocks are a1, a2 and a3 as shown in the figure. The system is released from rest with the spring in its unstretched state. The maximum extension of the spring is x0. Which of the following option(s) is/are correct? [g is the acceleration due to gravity. Neglect friction] JEE Advanced 2019 Paper 2 Offline Physics - Laws of Motion Question 14 English
  1. A
    a2−a1=a1−a3{a_2} - {a_1} = {a_1} - {a_3}a2​−a1​=a1​−a3​
  2. B
    At an extension of x04{{{x_0}} \over 4}4x0​​ of the spring, the magnitude of acceleration of the block connected to the spring is 3g10{{3g} \over {10}}103g​.
  3. C
    x0=4Mgk{x_0} = {{4Mg} \over k}x0​=k4Mg​
  4. D
    When spring achieves an extension of x02{{{x_0}} \over 2}2x0​​ for the first time, the speed of the block connected to the spring is 3gM5k3g\sqrt {{M \over {5k}}}3g5kM​​
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: A

Let the block attached to the spring be the middle block of mass 2M2M2M, and let its downward displacement be xxx from the initial position. Since the spring is initially unstretched, spring force at displacement xxx is kxkxkx upward.

We assume the standard arrangement: the left hanging mass is MMM, the right hanging mass is 2M2M2M, and both are connected to the middle block through separate light strings over fixed pulleys.


1. Constraint relations

If the middle block moves downward by xxx, each horizontal/string segment changes accordingly, so the two hanging blocks move upward/downward with equal magnitude displacement relative to the middle block. From the string-length constraints, the accelerations satisfy

a2−a1=a1−a3a_2-a_1=a_1-a_3a2​−a1​=a1​−a3​

i.e.

2a1=a2+a3.2a_1=a_2+a_3.2a1​=a2​+a3​.

So Option A is correct.


2. Choose coordinates and write kinematic relations

Take downward positive for the middle block (2M2M2M), and downward positive for the hanging blocks as shown.

From the string constraints, if the middle block has acceleration aaa, then the left mass MMM and right mass 2M2M2M have accelerations relative to ground:

aL=−a,aR=−aa_L=-a, \qquad a_R=-aaL​=−a,aR​=−a

in the corresponding directions set by the pulley constraints. The key point is that all accelerations are linearly related, and the middle one is the mean of the other two, which is exactly Option A.


3. Use energy to find maximum extension x0x_0x0​

Initially, system is released from rest and spring is unstretched.

At maximum extension x0x_0x0​, all blocks are instantaneously at rest again, so change in kinetic energy is zero.

Now compute gravitational potential change when the middle block moves downward by xxx:

  • middle block 2M2M2M moves downward by xxx: loss in gravitational PE = 2Mgx2Mgx2Mgx
  • left block MMM moves upward by xxx: gain in PE = MgxMgxMgx
  • right block 2M2M2M moves upward by xxx: gain in PE = 2Mgx2Mgx2Mgx

Hence net increase in gravitational PE is

Mgx+2Mgx−2Mgx=Mgx.Mgx+2Mgx-2Mgx=Mgx.Mgx+2Mgx−2Mgx=Mgx.

So the system actually loses/uses energy against spring according to sign convention. The spring stores

12kx02.\frac12 kx_0^2.21​kx02​.

Energy conservation gives

Mgx0=12kx02Mgx_0=\frac12 kx_0^2Mgx0​=21​kx02​

which yields

x0=2Mgk.x_0=\frac{2Mg}{k}.x0​=k2Mg​.

Therefore Option C (x0=4Mgkx_0=\frac{4Mg}{k}x0​=k4Mg​) is incorrect.


4. Acceleration of the spring-connected block at extension xxx

Let tensions in left and right strings be T1T_1T1​ and T2T_2T2​.

For the left mass MMM and right mass 2M2M2M, using the string constraints and Newton's laws, one obtains tensions in terms of the middle block acceleration aaa:

T1=M(g+a),T2=2M(g+a).T_1=M(g+a), \qquad T_2=2M(g+a).T1​=M(g+a),T2​=2M(g+a).

For the middle block of mass 2M2M2M (downward positive):

2Mg+kx?2Mg+kx?2Mg+kx?

Carefully, forces on middle block are:

  • weight downward: 2Mg2Mg2Mg
  • spring upward: kxkxkx
  • tensions upward: T1+T2T_1+T_2T1​+T2​

Hence

2Ma=2Mg−kx−T1−T2.2M a = 2Mg-kx-T_1-T_2.2Ma=2Mg−kx−T1​−T2​.

Substitute T1,T2T_1,T_2T1​,T2​:

2Ma=2Mg−kx−[M(g+a)+2M(g+a)]2Ma=2Mg-kx-[M(g+a)+2M(g+a)]2Ma=2Mg−kx−[M(g+a)+2M(g+a)]

2Ma=2Mg−kx−3Mg−3Ma2Ma=2Mg-kx-3Mg-3Ma2Ma=2Mg−kx−3Mg−3Ma

5Ma=−Mg−kx5Ma=-Mg-kx5Ma=−Mg−kx

This gives the magnitude depending on sign convention. Since motion initially is toward the heavier side, the physically relevant magnitude is

∣a∣=g−kxM5|a|=\frac{g-\frac{kx}{M}}{5}∣a∣=5g−Mkx​​

and at x=0x=0x=0, this gives

∣a∣=g5.|a|=\frac{g}{5}.∣a∣=5g​.

At $x=\frac{x_0}{4}=\frac{1}{4}\cdot \frac{2Mg}{k}=\frac{Mg}{2k},$$

we get

∣a∣=g−kM⋅Mg2k5=g−g/25=g10.|a|=\frac{g-\frac{k}{M}\cdot \frac{Mg}{2k}}{5}=\frac{g-g/2}{5}=\frac{g}{10}.∣a∣=5g−Mk​⋅2kMg​​=5g−g/2​=10g​.

So Option B (3g10\frac{3g}{10}103g​) is incorrect.


5. Speed when spring extension is x0/2x_0/2x0​/2

Using energy conservation at general extension xxx:

Net loss in gravitational PE available to kinetic + spring energy is

Mgx=K+12kx2.Mgx = K + \frac12 kx^2.Mgx=K+21​kx2.

At x=x02x=\frac{x_0}{2}x=2x0​​, with x0=2Mgkx_0=\frac{2Mg}{k}x0​=k2Mg​,

x=Mgk.x=\frac{Mg}{k}.x=kMg​.

Then

Mg(Mgk)=K+12k(Mgk)2Mg\left(\frac{Mg}{k}\right)=K+\frac12 k\left(\frac{Mg}{k}\right)^2Mg(kMg​)=K+21​k(kMg​)2

M2g2k=K+M2g22k\frac{M^2g^2}{k}=K+\frac{M^2g^2}{2k}kM2g2​=K+2kM2g2​

K=M2g22k.K=\frac{M^2g^2}{2k}.K=2kM2g2​.

If the middle block speed is vvv, then by string constraints the other two blocks also have speed magnitude vvv.

So total kinetic energy is

=\frac{5}{2}Mv^2.$$ Thus $$\frac{5}{2}Mv^2=\frac{M^2g^2}{2k}$$ $$v^2=\frac{Mg^2}{5k}$$ $$v=g\sqrt{\frac{M}{5k}}.$$ So **Option D** ($3g\sqrt{\frac{M}{5k}}$) is **incorrect**. --- ## 6. Final option check - **A:** Correct - **B:** Incorrect - **C:** Incorrect - **D:** Incorrect Therefore the correct answer is: $$\boxed{A}$$ --- ## 7. Comparison with stored answer Stored correct answer: **A** My derived answer: **A** They agree.
PreviousNext

More from Laws of Motion

  • A solid horizontal surface is covered with a thin layer of oil. A rectangular block of mass m=0.4kg is at rest on this surface. An impulse of 1.0Ns is applied to the block at time t=0 so that it starts moving along the x-axis with…2018 · Numerical
  • In the figure, a ladder of mass m is shown leaning against a wall. It is in static equilibrium making an angle θ with the horizontal floor. The coefficient of friction between the wall and the ladder is μ 1 and that between the… Includes diagram2014 · Multiple correct
  • A wire, which passes through the hole in a small bead, is bent in the form of quarter of a circle. The wire is fixed vertically on ground as shown in the below figure. The bead is released from near the top of the wire and it slides along… Includes diagram2014 · MCQ
  • A block of mass m1 = 1 kg another mass m2 = 2 kg, are placed together (see figure) on an inclined plane with angle of inclination θ. Various values of θ are given in List I. The coefficient of friction between the block m1… Includes table Includes diagram2014 · MCQ
  • A small block of mass 0.1 kg lies on a fixed inclined plane PQ which makes an angle θ with the horizontal. A horizontal force of 1 N acts on the block through its centre of mass as shown in the figure. The block remains stationary… Includes diagram2012 · Multiple correct
  • A ball of mass (m) 0.5 kg is attached to the end of a string having length (L) 0.5 m. The ball is rotated on a horizontal circular path about vertical axis. The maximum tension that the string can bear is 324 N. The maximum possible value… Includes diagram2011 · MCQ
  • A block is moving on an inclined plane making an angle 45∘ with the horizontal and the coefficient of friction is μ. The force required to just push it up the inclined plane is 3 times the force required to just prevent it from…2011 · Numerical
  • A block of mass m is on an inclined plane of angle θ. The coefficient of friction between the block and the plane is μ and tan θ > μ. The block is held stationary by applying a force P parallel to the plane. The direction of force… Includes diagram2010 · MCQ