Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Heat and Thermodynamics question

2020 · Shift 2 · Q41
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Advanced
  3. /Physics
  4. /Heat and Thermodynamics
  5. /2020 · Shift 2 · Q41

Heat and Thermodynamics question

2020 · Shift 2 · Q41

JEE AdvancedPhysicsHeat and ThermodynamicsNumerical+3 / −1
A thermally isolated cylindrical closed vessel of height 8 m is kept vertically. It is divided into two equal parts by a diathermic (perfect thermal conductor) frictionless partition of mass 8.3 kg. Thus the partition is held initially at a distance of 4 m from the top, as shown in the schematic figure below. Each of the two parts of the vessel contains 0.1 mole of an ideal gas at temperature 300 K. The partition is now released and moves without any gas leaking from one part of the vessel to the other. When equilibrium is reached, the distance of the partition from the top (in m) will be ‾\underline{\hspace{2cm}}​. (take the acceleration due to gravity = 10 ms−2 and the universal gas constant = 8.3 J mol−1K−1). JEE Advanced 2020 Paper 2 Offline Physics - Heat and Thermodynamics Question 49 English
Numerical answer
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: 6

Step-by-step Solution

1. Define the Initial and Final States

  • Initial State: The cylindrical vessel of total height H=8H = 8H=8 m is divided into two equal parts by a partition.

    • Height of the upper part, h1=4h_1 = 4h1​=4 m.
    • Height of the lower part, h2=4h_2 = 4h2​=4 m.
    • Number of moles of ideal gas in each part, n1=n2=n=0.1n_1 = n_2 = n = 0.1n1​=n2​=n=0.1 mole.
    • Initial temperature of the gas in both parts, Ti=300T_i = 300Ti​=300 K.
    • The partition has mass m=8.3m = 8.3m=8.3 kg.
  • Final State (at Equilibrium): The partition is released and settles at a new equilibrium position.

    • Let the final distance of the partition from the top be xxx.
    • Height of the upper part, h1′=xh'_1 = xh1′​=x.
    • Height of the lower part, h2′=H−x=8−xh'_2 = H - x = 8 - xh2′​=H−x=8−x.
    • Since the partition is diathermic (a perfect thermal conductor), the final temperature in both parts will be the same. Let this be TfT_fTf​.
    • Let the final pressures be P1′P'_1P1′​ and P2′P'_2P2′​.

2. Mechanical Equilibrium Condition

At equilibrium, the forces acting on the partition must balance. The forces are:

  • Force from the upper gas pressure: P1′AP'_1 AP1′​A (downwards)
  • Weight of the partition: mgmgmg (downwards)
  • Force from the lower gas pressure: P2′AP'_2 AP2′​A (upwards)

where AAA is the cross-sectional area of the cylinder.

The force balance equation is: P2′A=P1′A+mgP'_2 A = P'_1 A + mgP2′​A=P1′​A+mg P2′−P1′=mgAP'_2 - P'_1 = \frac{mg}{A}P2′​−P1′​=Amg​

Using the ideal gas law, PV=nRTPV = nRTPV=nRT, we can express the pressures as: P1′=nRTfV1′=nRTfAxP'_1 = \frac{nRT_f}{V'_1} = \frac{nRT_f}{Ax}P1′​=V1′​nRTf​​=AxnRTf​​ P2′=nRTfV2′=nRTfA(8−x)P'_2 = \frac{nRT_f}{V'_2} = \frac{nRT_f}{A(8-x)}P2′​=V2′​nRTf​​=A(8−x)nRTf​​

Substituting these into the equilibrium equation: nRTfA(8−x)−nRTfAx=mgA\frac{nRT_f}{A(8-x)} - \frac{nRT_f}{Ax} = \frac{mg}{A}A(8−x)nRTf​​−AxnRTf​​=Amg​ Multiplying by AAA, we get: nRTf(18−x−1x)=mgnRT_f \left( \frac{1}{8-x} - \frac{1}{x} \right) = mgnRTf​(8−x1​−x1​)=mg nRTf(x−(8−x)x(8−x))=mgnRT_f \left( \frac{x - (8-x)}{x(8-x)} \right) = mgnRTf​(x(8−x)x−(8−x)​)=mg nRTf(2x−8x(8−x))=mg(∗) nRT_f \left( \frac{2x - 8}{x(8-x)} \right) = mg \quad (*)nRTf​(x(8−x)2x−8​)=mg(∗)

3. Energy Conservation and the Isothermal Assumption

The vessel is thermally isolated, so the total energy of the system (gas in both parts + partition) is conserved. The decrease in the partition's potential energy is converted into internal energy of the gas, causing the temperature to rise (Tf>TiT_f > T_iTf​>Ti​). The exact value of TfT_fTf​ would depend on the specific heat (and thus degrees of freedom, fff) of the ideal gas, which is not provided.

However, in problems of this type where a key parameter (fff) is missing and an integer answer is expected, it often implies a simplifying assumption. The standard simplification is to assume the process is isothermal, i.e., the temperature of the gas does not change. So we assume Tf=Ti=300T_f = T_i = 300Tf​=Ti​=300 K.

4. Calculation with the Isothermal Assumption

Setting Tf=Ti=300T_f = T_i = 300Tf​=Ti​=300 K in equation (*): nRTi(2x−8x(8−x))=mgnRT_i \left( \frac{2x - 8}{x(8-x)} \right) = mgnRTi​(x(8−x)2x−8​)=mg

Now, we substitute the given values:

  • n=0.1n = 0.1n=0.1 mol
  • R=8.3R = 8.3R=8.3 J mol⁻¹K⁻¹
  • Ti=300T_i = 300Ti​=300 K
  • m=8.3m = 8.3m=8.3 kg
  • g=10g = 10g=10 ms⁻²

(0.1 mol)(8.3 J mol−1K−1)(300 K)(2(x−4)x(8−x))=(8.3 kg)(10 ms−2)(0.1 \text{ mol}) (8.3 \text{ J mol}^{-1}\text{K}^{-1}) (300 \text{ K}) \left( \frac{2(x-4)}{x(8-x)} \right) = (8.3 \text{ kg})(10 \text{ ms}^{-2})(0.1 mol)(8.3 J mol−1K−1)(300 K)(x(8−x)2(x−4)​)=(8.3 kg)(10 ms−2) 249(2(x−4)x(8−x))=83249 \left( \frac{2(x-4)}{x(8-x)} \right) = 83249(x(8−x)2(x−4)​)=83

Divide both sides by 83: 3(2(x−4)x(8−x))=13 \left( \frac{2(x-4)}{x(8-x)} \right) = 13(x(8−x)2(x−4)​)=1 6(x−4)=x(8−x)6(x-4) = x(8-x)6(x−4)=x(8−x) 6x−24=8x−x26x - 24 = 8x - x^26x−24=8x−x2

Rearranging into a standard quadratic form: x2−2x−24=0x^2 - 2x - 24 = 0x2−2x−24=0

Factoring the quadratic equation: (x−6)(x+4)=0(x-6)(x+4) = 0(x−6)(x+4)=0

This gives two possible solutions for xxx: x=6x=6x=6 or x=−4x=-4x=−4.

5. Final Answer

Since xxx represents the distance from the top of the vessel, it must be a positive value. Therefore, the physically meaningful solution is: x=6 mx = 6 \text{ m}x=6 m

When equilibrium is reached, the distance of the partition from the top will be 6 m.

PreviousNext

More from Heat and Thermodynamics

  • A spherical bubble inside water has radius R. Take the pressure inside the bubble and the water pressure to be p0. The bubble now gets compressed radially in an adiabatic manner so that its radius becomes (R − a). For a << R the…2020 · Numerical
  • A container with 1 kg of water in it is kept in sunlight, which causes the water to get warmer than the surroundings. The average energy per unit time per unit area received due to the sunlight is 700 Wm − 2 and it is absorbed by the…2020 · Numerical
  • One mole of a monatomic ideal gas goes through a thermodynamic cycle, as shown in the volume versus temperature (V-T) diagram. The correct statement(s) is/are [R is the gas constant] Includes diagram2019 · Multiple correct
  • A mixture of ideal gas containing 5 moles of monatomic gas and 1 mole of rigid diatomic gas is initially at pressure P0, volume V0, and temperature T0. If the gas mixture is adiabatically compressed to a volume 4V0​​, then…2019 · Multiple correct
  • In a thermodynamic process on an ideal monatomic gas, the infinitesimal heat absorbed by the gas is given by T Δ X where T is temperature of the system and Δ X is the infinitesimal change in a thermodynamic quantity X of the… Includes diagram2019 · MCQ
  • In a thermodynamic process on an ideal monatomic gas, the infinitesimal heat absorbed by the gas is given by T Δ X where T is temperature of the system and Δ X is the infinitesimal change in a thermodynamic quantity X of the… Includes diagram2019 · MCQ
  • One mole of a monatomic ideal gas undergoes a cyclic process as shown in the figure (where V is the volume and T is the temperature). Which of the statements below is (are) true? Includes diagram2018 · Multiple correct
  • One mole of a monatomic ideal gas undergoes an adiabatic expansion in which its volume becomes eight times its initial value. If the initial temperature of the gas is 100K and the universal gas constant $R=8.0J\,mo{l^{ - 1}}{K^{ -…2018 · Numerical