Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Heat and Thermodynamics question

2011 · Shift 2 · Q59
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Advanced
  3. /Physics
  4. /Heat and Thermodynamics
  5. /2011 · Shift 2 · Q59

Heat and Thermodynamics question

2011 · Shift 2 · Q59

JEE AdvancedPhysicsHeat and ThermodynamicsMCQ+3 / −1

One mole of a monatomic gas is taken through a cycle ABCDA as shown in the PV diagram. Column II give the characteristics involved in the cycle. Match them with each of the processes given in Column I.

IIT-JEE 2011 Paper 2 Offline Physics - Heat and Thermodynamics Question 27 English

Column I Column II
(A) Process A →\to→ B (P) Internal energy decreases.
(B) Process B →\to→ C (Q) Internal energy increase.
(C) Process C →\to→ D (R) Heat is lost.
(D) Process D →\to→ A (S) Heat is gained.
(T) Work is done on the gas.

  1. A
    (A) →\to→(P), (R), (T); (B) →\to→(P), R; (C) →\to→(Q), (S); (D) →\to→(R), (T)
  2. B
    (A) →\to→(P), (T); (B) →\to→(P), (R); (C) →\to→(Q), (S); (D) →\to→(R)
  3. C
    (A) →\to→(R), (T); (B) →\to→(P), (R); (C) →\to→(S); (D) →\to→(R), (T)
  4. D
    (A) →\to→(P), (R), (T); (B) →\to→(P), (R); (C) →\to→(Q); (D) →\to→(R), (T)
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: THE PROVIDED OPTIONS AND STORED ANSWER KEY APPEAR TO BE INCORRECT BASED ON A STANDARD ANALYSIS OF THE GIVEN PV DIAGRAM AND THE PRINCIPLES OF THERMODYNAMICS. A CORRECT MATCHING BASED ON OUR DERIVATION WOULD BE: (A) -> (Q), (S); (B) -> (P), (R); (C) -> (P), (R), (T); (D) -> (Q), (S). SINCE THIS IS NOT AN OPTION, THE QUESTION IS FLAWED.

Analysis of the Thermodynamic Cycle

This problem requires us to analyze a thermodynamic cycle for one mole of a monatomic gas as depicted in the P-V diagram and match each process with its characteristics.

First, let's establish the fundamental principles we will use:

  1. Ideal Gas Law: For one mole, PV = RT. Therefore, temperature T is proportional to the product PV.
  2. Internal Energy (U): For a monatomic gas, U = (3/2)RT. The change in internal energy ΔU is directly proportional to the change in temperature ΔT.
    • If T increases, ΔU > 0 (Q).
    • If T decreases, ΔU < 0 (P).
  3. Work Done (W): Work done by the gas is given by W = ∫ P dV.
    • If volume increases (expansion), W > 0.
    • If volume decreases (compression), W < 0. Work is done on the gas (T).
    • If volume is constant (isochoric), W = 0.
  4. First Law of Thermodynamics: ΔQ = ΔU + W, where ΔQ is the heat added to the gas and W is the work done by the gas.
    • If ΔQ > 0, heat is gained (S).
    • If ΔQ < 0, heat is lost (R).

From the given P-V diagram, we identify the states:

  • State A: (VA,PA)=(V0,2P0)(V_A, P_A) = (V₀, 2P₀)(VA​,PA​)=(V0​,2P0​)
  • State B: (VB,PB)=(3V0,P0)(V_B, P_B) = (3V₀, P₀)(VB​,PB​)=(3V0​,P0​)
  • State C is at VC=3V0V_C = 3V₀VC​=3V0​ and a pressure PC<P0P_C < P₀PC​<P0​.
  • State D is at VD=V0V_D = V₀VD​=V0​ and a pressure PD<2P0P_D < 2P₀PD​<2P0​.

The processes are A → B, B → C (isochoric), C → D, and D → A (isochoric).


Step-by-step Analysis of Each Process

(A) Process A → B

  1. Work: The volume increases from V₀ to 3V₀. This is an expansion, so work is done by the gas (W > 0). Thus, the statement (T) "Work is done on the gas" is false.
  2. Internal Energy: Let's compare the temperatures at A and B.
    • TA∝PAVA=(2P0)(V0)=2P0V0T_A ∝ P_A V_A = (2P₀)(V₀) = 2P₀V₀TA​∝PA​VA​=(2P0​)(V0​)=2P0​V0​
    • TB∝PBVB=(P0)(3V0)=3P0V0T_B ∝ P_B V_B = (P₀)(3V₀) = 3P₀V₀TB​∝PB​VB​=(P0​)(3V0​)=3P0​V0​
    • Since TB>TAT_B > T_ATB​>TA​, the temperature increases. Therefore, the internal energy increases (ΔU > 0). This corresponds to characteristic (Q).
  3. Heat: According to the first law of thermodynamics, ΔQ = ΔU + W. Since ΔU > 0 and W > 0, it follows that ΔQ > 0. Heat is gained by the gas. This corresponds to characteristic (S).
  • Conclusion for (A): The characteristics are (Q) and (S).

(B) Process B → C

  1. Work: This is an isochoric process (V is constant at 3V₀). Therefore, the work done is zero (W = 0). (T) is false.
  2. Internal Energy: In an isochoric process, temperature is proportional to pressure (T ∝ P). From the diagram, the pressure decreases from PB=P0P_B = P₀PB​=P0​ to PC<P0P_C < P₀PC​<P0​. Thus, the temperature decreases (TC<TBT_C < T_BTC​<TB​), and the internal energy decreases (ΔU < 0). This corresponds to characteristic (P).
  3. Heat: ΔQ = ΔU + W = ΔU + 0. Since ΔU < 0, ΔQ < 0. Heat is lost by the gas. This corresponds to characteristic (R).
  • Conclusion for (B): The characteristics are (P) and (R).

(C) Process C → D

  1. Work: The volume decreases from 3V₀ to V₀. This is a compression, so work is done on the gas (W < 0). Thus, characteristic (T) is true.
  2. Internal Energy: Let's compare TC∝3V0PCT_C ∝ 3V₀P_CTC​∝3V0​PC​ and TD∝V0PDT_D ∝ V₀P_DTD​∝V0​PD​. The change in temperature ΔT depends on the specific values of PCP_CPC​ and PDP_DPD​. In many such engine cycles, this compression stroke involves cooling. Assuming TD<TCT_D < T_CTD​<TC​, the internal energy decreases (ΔU < 0). This would correspond to (P).
  3. Heat: ΔQ = ΔU + W. If ΔU < 0 (P) and we know W < 0 (T), then ΔQ must be negative. Heat is lost. This corresponds to (R).
  • Conclusion for (C): The characteristics are most likely (P), (R), and (T).

(D) Process D → A

  1. Work: This is an isochoric process (V is constant at V₀). Therefore, the work done is zero (W = 0). (T) is false.
  2. Internal Energy: In this isochoric process, pressure increases from PDP_DPD​ to PA=2P0P_A = 2P₀PA​=2P0​. Since T ∝ P, the temperature increases (TA>TDT_A > T_DTA​>TD​). Thus, the internal energy increases (ΔU > 0). This corresponds to characteristic (Q).
  3. Heat: ΔQ = ΔU + W = ΔU + 0. Since ΔU > 0, ΔQ > 0. Heat is gained by the gas. This corresponds to characteristic (S).
  • Conclusion for (D): The characteristics are (Q) and (S).

Conclusion and Comparison with Options

Our analysis yields the following matching:

  • (A) Process A → B: (Q), (S)
  • (B) Process B → C: (P), (R)
  • (C) Process C → D: (P), (R), (T)
  • (D) Process D → A: (Q), (S)

The stored correct answer is A: (A) → (P), (R), (T); (B) → (P), R; (C) → (Q), (S); (D) → (R), (T). Let's compare.

  • For (A) A → B: Our result is (Q), (S). The stored answer is (P), (R), (T). This is a direct contradiction. Process A→B is an expansion (W>0), so (T) is false. Temperature increases, so (P) is false. Heat is gained, so (R) is false.
  • For (B) B → C: Our result is (P), (R). The stored answer is (P), (R). This matches.
  • For (C) C → D: Our result is (P), (R), (T). The stored answer is (Q), (S). This is a contradiction in terms of heat and internal energy change.
  • For (D) D → A: Our result is (Q), (S). The stored answer is (R), (T). This is a direct contradiction. Process D→A is isochoric (W=0), so (T) is false. It is a heating process (ΔU>0), so heat is gained (ΔQ>0), making (R) false.

Given the multiple, severe contradictions between a straightforward analysis of the P-V diagram and the provided answer key, it is concluded that the question or the provided answer key is flawed. The claims in the stored answer for processes A→B and D→A are physically impossible as per the diagram.

PreviousNext

More from Heat and Thermodynamics

  • A real gas behaves like an ideal gas if its2010 · MCQ
  • Two spherical bodies A (radius 6 cm ) and B (radius 18 cm ) are at temperature T1 and T2, respectively. The maximum intensity in the emission spectrum of A is at 500 nm and in that of B is at 1500 nm. Considering them to be black bodies,…2010 · Numerical
  • A piece of ice (heat capacity = 2100 J kg-1 oC-1 and latent heat = 3.36 × 105 J kg-1 ) of mass m grams is at - 5 oC at atmospheric pressure. It is given 420 J of heat so that the ice starts melting. Finally when the ice-water…2010 · Numerical
  • One mole of an ideal gas in initial state A undergoes a cyclic process ABCA, as shown in the figure. Its pressure at A is P0. Choose the correct option(s) from the following: Includes diagram2010 · Multiple correct
  • A diatomic ideal gas is compressed adiabatically 321​ of its initial volume. If the initial temperature of the gas is Ti (in Kelvin) and the final temperature is a Ti, the value of a is2010 · Numerical
  • CV​ and CP​ denote the molar specific heat capacities of a gas at constant volume and constant pressure, respectively. Then2009 · Multiple correct
  • The figure shows the PV plot of an ideal gas taken through a cycle ABCDA. The part ABC is a semicircle and CDA is half of an ellipse. Then, Includes diagram2009 · Multiple correct
  • Column II gives certain systems undergoing a process. Column I suggests changes in some of the parameters related to the system. Match the statements in Column I to the appropriate process(es) from Column II: Includes table2009 · MCQ