Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Capacitor question

2012 · Shift 2 · Q43
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Advanced
  3. /Physics
  4. /Capacitor
  5. /2012 · Shift 2 · Q43

Capacitor question

2012 · Shift 2 · Q43

JEE AdvancedPhysicsCapacitorMCQ+4 / −1
In the given circuit, a charge of +80μC+80\mu C+80μC is given to the upper plate of the 4μF4\mu F4μF capacitor. Then in the steady state, the charge on the upper plate of the 3μF3\mu F3μF capacitor is IIT-JEE 2012 Paper 2 Offline Physics - Capacitor Question 18 English
  1. A
    + 32 μC+ \,32\,\mu C+32μC
  2. B
    + 40 μC+ \,40\,\mu C+40μC
  3. C
    + 48 μC+ \,48\,\mu C+48μC
  4. D
    + 80 μC+ \,80\,\mu C+80μC
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: C

Step-by-step Derivations and Analysis

This problem involves finding the charge on a capacitor in a circuit in the steady state, given an initial charge on a part of the circuit. We will use the principles of charge conservation on isolated conductors and Kirchhoff's voltage law.

1. Identify Conductors and Potentials

Let's label the main nodes (conductors) in the circuit:

  • Node P: The top wire connecting the positive terminal of the battery, the upper plate of the 4μF4\mu F4μF capacitor, and the upper plate of the 2μF2\mu F2μF capacitor.
  • Node Q: The bottom wire connecting the negative terminal of the battery, the lower plate of the 4μF4\mu F4μF capacitor, and the lower plate of the 3μF3\mu F3μF capacitor.
  • Node R: The wire connecting the lower plate of the 2μF2\mu F2μF capacitor and the upper plate of the 3μF3\mu F3μF capacitor.

In the steady state, the battery maintains a constant potential difference. Let's set the potential of the negative terminal (Node Q) to be the reference potential, VQ=0VV_Q = 0VVQ​=0V. Then the potential of the positive terminal (Node P) is VP=10VV_P = 10VVP​=10V. The potential of Node R, let's call it VRV_RVR​, is unknown.

2. Apply Charge Conservation

Node R is an isolated conductor. Its total electric charge must be conserved. The problem does not state any initial charge on the capacitors before the +80μC+80\mu C+80μC is added. The standard assumption in such problems is that capacitors are initially uncharged. Therefore, the total charge on the isolated Node R is initially zero and must remain zero in the steady state.

The total charge on Node R is the sum of the charges on the plates connected to it: the lower plate of the 2μF2\mu F2μF capacitor (q2,lowerq_{2,lower}q2,lower​) and the upper plate of the 3μF3\mu F3μF capacitor (q3,upperq_{3,upper}q3,upper​). So, the charge conservation equation for Node R is: q2,lower+q3,upper=0q_{2,lower} + q_{3,upper} = 0q2,lower​+q3,upper​=0

3. Express Charges in Terms of Potentials

The charge on a capacitor plate is given by its capacitance multiplied by the potential difference between its plates (q=CΔVq = C \Delta Vq=CΔV).

  • For the 2μF2\mu F2μF capacitor, the charge on the lower plate is: q2,lower=C2(VR−VP)=2μF×(VR−10V)q_{2,lower} = C_2 (V_R - V_P) = 2\mu F \times (V_R - 10V)q2,lower​=C2​(VR​−VP​)=2μF×(VR​−10V)

  • For the 3μF3\mu F3μF capacitor, the charge on the upper plate is: q3,upper=C3(VR−VQ)=3μF×(VR−0V)=3VRq_{3,upper} = C_3 (V_R - V_Q) = 3\mu F \times (V_R - 0V) = 3V_Rq3,upper​=C3​(VR​−VQ​)=3μF×(VR​−0V)=3VR​

4. Solve for the Unknown Potential VRV_RVR​

Substitute the expressions for the charges into the charge conservation equation: 2(VR−10)+3VR=02(V_R - 10) + 3V_R = 02(VR​−10)+3VR​=0 2VR−20+3VR=02V_R - 20 + 3V_R = 02VR​−20+3VR​=0 5VR=205V_R = 205VR​=20 VR=4VV_R = 4VVR​=4V

5. Calculate the Required Charge

The question asks for the charge on the upper plate of the 3μF3\mu F3μF capacitor, which is q3,upperq_{3,upper}q3,upper​. q3,upper=3VR=(3μF)×(4V)=+12μCq_{3,upper} = 3V_R = (3\mu F) \times (4V) = +12\mu Cq3,upper​=3VR​=(3μF)×(4V)=+12μC

6. Analysis of the Initial Charge Condition

The problem states that a charge of +80μC+80\mu C+80μC is given to the upper plate of the 4μF4\mu F4μF capacitor (which is part of Node P). Let's see what this implies.

In our steady-state calculation, the final charges on the plates connected to Node P are:

  • Upper plate of 4μF4\mu F4μF: q4,upper=C4(VP−VQ)=4(10−0)=+40μCq_{4,upper} = C_4(V_P - V_Q) = 4(10 - 0) = +40\mu Cq4,upper​=C4​(VP​−VQ​)=4(10−0)=+40μC.
  • Upper plate of 2μF2\mu F2μF: q2,upper=C2(VP−VR)=2(10−4)=+12μCq_{2,upper} = C_2(V_P - V_R) = 2(10 - 4) = +12\mu Cq2,upper​=C2​(VP​−VR​)=2(10−4)=+12μC.

The total charge on Node P in the steady state is QP,final=q4,upper+q2,upper=40+12=+52μCQ_{P,final} = q_{4,upper} + q_{2,upper} = 40 + 12 = +52\mu CQP,final​=q4,upper​+q2,upper​=40+12=+52μC.

The initial charge on Node P was +80μC+80\mu C+80μC. When the battery is connected, it is not an isolated system anymore. The battery can supply or remove charge to maintain the potential at 10V10V10V. In this case, the battery has removed a charge of 80−52=28μC80 - 52 = 28\mu C80−52=28μC from Node P.

The crucial point is that the initial charge of +80μC+80\mu C+80μC on a non-isolated part of the circuit does not affect the final charge distribution, which is determined by the battery voltages and the conservation of charge on isolated parts of the circuit. The derived answer of +12μC+12\mu C+12μC is physically sound based on a standard interpretation of the problem.

7. Comparison with Options and Conclusion

Our calculated charge is +12μC+12\mu C+12μC. This is not among the given options (A: +32, B: +40, C: +48, D: +80). The stored correct answer is C: +48μC+48\mu C+48μC. For the charge on the upper plate of the 3μF3\mu F3μF capacitor to be +48μC+48\mu C+48μC, we would require: $q_{3,upper} = 48\mu C

\implies 3V_R = 48

\implies V_R=16V.ThiswouldinturnrequiretheisolatedNodeRtohaveanon−zerochargeof. This would in turn require the isolated Node R to have a non-zero charge of .ThiswouldinturnrequiretheisolatedNodeRtohaveanon−zerochargeofQ_R = 5V_R - 20 = 5(16) - 20 = 60\mu C.Thereisnoinformationintheproblemstatementtojustifyassuminganinitialchargeof. There is no information in the problem statement to justify assuming an initial charge of .Thereisnoinformationintheproblemstatementtojustifyassuminganinitialchargeof+60\mu C$ on Node R.

Therefore, the problem statement is likely flawed or inconsistent, as it's impossible to derive the answer of 48μC48\mu C48μC from the given information using standard principles of circuit analysis. The most rigorous physical analysis leads to +12μC+12\mu C+12μC. Given the discrepancy, we must conclude that the stored answer is incorrect.

PreviousNext

More from Capacitor

  • A 2μF capacitor is charged as shown in the figure. The percentage of its stored energy dissipated after the switch S is turned to position 2 is Includes diagram2011 · MCQ
  • At time t = 0, a battery of 10 V is connected across points A and B in the given circuit. If the capacitors have no charge initially, at what time (in seconds) does the voltage across them becomes 4 V? (Take ln5 = 1.6, ln3 = 1.1) Includes diagram2010 · Numerical
  • A circuit is connected as shown in the figure with the switch S open. When the switch is closed, the total amount of charge that flows from Y to X is Includes diagram2007 · MCQ
  • Column I gives certain situations in which a straight metallic wire of resistance R is used and Column II gives some resulting effects. Match the statements in Column I with the statements in Column II and indicate your answer by darkening… Includes table2007 · MCQ
  • Four identical thin, square metal sheets, S1​,S2​,S3​ and S4​, each of side a are kept parallel to each other with equal distance d(≪a) between them, as shown in the figure. Let C0​=dε0​a2​,… Includes table Includes diagram2024 · MCQ
  • In a circuit shown in the figure, the capacitor C is initially uncharged and the key K is open. In this condition, a current of 1 A flows through the 1Ω resistor. The key is closed at time t=t0​. Which of the… Includes diagram2023 · Multiple correct
  • A container has a base of 50 cm×5 cm and height 50 cm, as shown in the figure. It has two parallel electrically conducting walls each of area 50 cm×50 cm. The remaining… Includes diagram2023 · MCQ
  • A medium having dielectric constant K>1 fills the space between the plates of a parallel plate capacitor. The plates have large area, and the distance between them is d. The capacitor is connected to a battery of voltage V, as… Includes diagram2022 · Multiple correct