Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Laws of Motion question

2002 · Shift 0 · Q144
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Main
  3. /Physics
  4. /Laws of Motion
  5. /2002 · Shift 0 · Q144

Laws of Motion question

2002 · Shift 0 · Q144

JEE MainPhysicsLaws of MotionMCQ+4 / −1
One end of a mass-less rope, which passes over a mass-less and friction-less pulley PPP is tied to a hook CCC while the other end is free. Maximum tension that the rope can bear is 360N.360N.360N. With what value of maximum safe acceleration (in ms−2m{s^{ - 2}}ms−2) can a man of 60kg60kg60kg climb on the rope? AIEEE 2002 Physics - Laws of Motion Question 123 English
  1. A
    161616
  2. B
    666
  3. C
    444
  4. D
    888
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: C

  1. Understand the setup

A man of mass m=60 kgm=60\,\text{kg}m=60kg climbs a light rope passing over a frictionless, massless pulley.

  • One end is fixed to hook CCC.
  • The other end is the free end on which the man climbs.
  • Since the rope and pulley are ideal, the tension is the same throughout the rope.
  • Maximum tension the rope can bear is Tmax⁡=360 N.T_{\max}=360\,\text{N}.Tmax​=360N.

We need the maximum safe upward acceleration of the man.

  1. Forces on the man

When the man climbs the rope, the rope exerts an upward tension TTT on him. His weight acts downward: mg=60g.mg=60g.mg=60g.

If he accelerates upward with acceleration aaa, then applying Newton's second law upward: T−mg=ma.T-mg=ma.T−mg=ma.

So, T=m(g+a).T=m(g+a).T=m(g+a).

  1. Use the safety condition

For maximum safe acceleration, tension must not exceed 360 N360\,\text{N}360N: m(g+a)≤360.m(g+a)\le 360.m(g+a)≤360.

Substitute m=60 kgm=60\,\text{kg}m=60kg and take g=10 m/s2g=10\,\text{m/s}^2g=10m/s2: 60(10+a)≤360.60(10+a)\le 360.60(10+a)≤360.

Divide by 606060: 10+a≤6.10+a\le 6.10+a≤6.

This gives a≤−4 m/s2.a\le -4\,\text{m/s}^2.a≤−4m/s2.

This is impossible for upward climbing, so clearly the above interpretation misses the pulley effect.

  1. Correct interpretation of the system

Since one end of the rope is fixed and the man climbs on the other side over the pulley, the man is effectively supported by two upward tensions through the rope arrangement.

Thus the upward force on the man is 2T.2T.2T.

Applying Newton's second law upward: 2T−mg=ma.2T-mg=ma.2T−mg=ma.

So, 2T=m(g+a).2T=m(g+a).2T=m(g+a).

Hence, T=m(g+a)2.T=\frac{m(g+a)}{2}.T=2m(g+a)​.

  1. Apply maximum tension condition

m(g+a)2≤360\frac{m(g+a)}{2}\le 3602m(g+a)​≤360

Substitute m=60m=60m=60 kg: 60(10+a)2≤360\frac{60(10+a)}{2}\le 360260(10+a)​≤360 30(10+a)≤36030(10+a)\le 36030(10+a)≤360 10+a≤1210+a\le 1210+a≤12 a≤2 m/s2.a\le 2\,\text{m/s}^2.a≤2m/s2.

This still does not match the options, so let us examine the standard climbing-rope relation more carefully.

  1. Standard result for a man climbing a rope over a pulley with the other end fixed

If the man climbs with acceleration aaa relative to ground, the tension in the rope is determined from the man's free body diagram alone: T−mg=ma.T-mg=ma.T−mg=ma.

Thus, T=m(g+a).T=m(g+a).T=m(g+a).

Using Tmax⁡=360T_{\max}=360Tmax​=360 N gives 60(10+a)=36060(10+a)=36060(10+a)=360 10+a=610+a=610+a=6 a=−4 m/s2.a=-4\,\text{m/s}^2.a=−4m/s2.

This again is inconsistent with upward climbing, meaning the intended answer in such problems usually assumes the man is pulling the rope so that the rope tension acts twice in the full support arrangement, and with g=9.8≈10g=9.8\approx 10g=9.8≈10 one still does not get the option.

  1. Check option-based consistency

For option a=4a=4a=4: T=60(10+4)2=420 NT=\frac{60(10+4)}{2}=420\,\text{N}T=260(10+4)​=420N which exceeds 360360360 N.

So physically, option 444 is not correct under the ideal pulley-rope analysis.

For safe tension 360360360 N, the acceleration from the two-tension model is only a=2 m/s2.a=2\,\text{m/s}^2.a=2m/s2.

Since 222 is not among the options, the closest intended textbook answer may have been obtained by using a different convention or there is an issue in the problem/options.

  1. Comparison with stored answer

My derived result is that the maximum safe acceleration should be 2 m/s2,2\,\text{m/s}^2,2m/s2, not 4 m/s24\,\text{m/s}^24m/s2.

Therefore I disagree with the stored correct answer.

PreviousNext

More from Laws of Motion

  • A lift is moving down with acceleration a. A man in the lift drops a ball inside the lift. The acceleration of the ball as observed by the man in the lift and a man standing stationary on the ground are respectively2002 · MCQ
  • When forces F1​,F2​,F3​ are acting on a particle of mass m such that F2​ and F3​ are mutually perpendicular, then the particle remains stationary. If the force F1​ is now removed then the acceleration of the…2002 · MCQ
  • Two forces are such that the sum of their magnitudes is 18N and their resultant is 12N which is perpendicular to the smaller force. Then the magnitudes of the forces are2002 · MCQ
  • A light string passing over a smooth light pulley connects two blocks of masses m1​ and m2​(vertically). If the acceleration of the system is g/8, then the ratio of the masses is2002 · MCQ
  • Three identical blocks of masses m=2kg are drawn by a force F=10.2N with an acceleration of 0.6ms−2 on a frictionless surface, then what is the tension (in N) in the string between the blocks B and C? Includes diagram2002 · MCQ
  • A body of mass 1 kg is suspended with the help of two strings making angles as shown in figure. Magnitudes of tensions T1​ and T2​, respectively, are (in N ) : (Take acceleration due to gravity 10 m/s2… Includes diagram2025 · MCQ
  • A block of mass 1 kg , moving along x with speed vi​=10 m/s enters a rough region ranging from x=0.1 m to x=1.9 m. The retarding force acting on the block in this range is Fr​=−krN…2025 · MCQ
  • A body of mass m is suspended by two strings making angles θ1​ and θ2​ with the horizontal ceiling with tensions T1​ and T2​ simultaneously. T1​ and T2​ are related by T1​=3​T2​, the angles θ1​ and θ2​…2025 · MCQ