Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Electrostatics question

2007 · Shift 0 · Q81
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Main
  3. /Physics
  4. /Electrostatics
  5. /2007 · Shift 0 · Q81

Electrostatics question

2007 · Shift 0 · Q81

JEE MainPhysicsElectrostaticsMCQ+4 / −1
Charges are placed on the vertices of a square as shown. Let E→\overrightarrow EE be the electric field and VVV the potential at the center. If the charges on AAA and BBB are interchanged with those on DDD and CCC respectively, then AIEEE 2007 Physics - Electrostatics Question 236 English
  1. A
    E→\overrightarrow EE changes, VVV remains unchanged
  2. B
    E→\overrightarrow EE remains unchanged, VVV changes
  3. C
    both E→\overrightarrow EE and VVV change
  4. D
    E→\overrightarrow EE and VVV remain unchanged
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: A

  1. Key idea about the center of a square

    Let the square have vertices A,B,C,DA,B,C,DA,B,C,D and center OOO.

    The distance of every vertex from the center is the same. Let this distance be rrr.

    Therefore, the potential at the center is

    = \frac{k}{r}(q_A+q_B+q_C+q_D).$$ So, **potential depends only on the sum of charges**, not on how they are arranged.
  2. Effect on potential when charges are interchanged

    We are told that the charges on AAA and BBB are interchanged with those on DDD and CCC respectively.

    That means the set of charges at the four corners is the same; only their positions change.

    Hence, qA+qB+qC+qDq_A+q_B+q_C+q_DqA​+qB​+qC​+qD​ remains unchanged.

    Therefore, V remains unchanged.V \text{ remains unchanged.}V remains unchanged.

  3. Now consider the electric field at the center

    Electric field is a vector quantity, so arrangement matters.

    The field at the center due to a charge at a vertex is along the line joining that vertex to the center. Since opposite vertices correspond to opposite directions, changing which charge sits at which corner generally changes vector addition.

  4. Vector form argument

    Let the position vectors of vertices relative to the center be: r⃗A,r⃗B,r⃗C,r⃗D\vec r_A,\vec r_B,\vec r_C,\vec r_DrA​,rB​,rC​,rD​ with r⃗C=−r⃗A,r⃗D=−r⃗B.\vec r_C=-\vec r_A, \qquad \vec r_D=-\vec r_B.rC​=−rA​,rD​=−rB​.

    Since all vertices are at the same distance rrr from the center, the electric field at the center is proportional to E⃗∝−(qAr⃗A+qBr⃗B+qCr⃗C+qDr⃗D).\vec E \propto -(q_A\vec r_A+q_B\vec r_B+q_C\vec r_C+q_D\vec r_D).E∝−(qA​rA​+qB​rB​+qC​rC​+qD​rD​).

    Using opposite-vertex relations, E⃗∝−[(qA−qC)r⃗A+(qB−qD)r⃗B].\vec E \propto -\big[(q_A-q_C)\vec r_A + (q_B-q_D)\vec r_B\big].E∝−[(qA​−qC​)rA​+(qB​−qD​)rB​].

    After interchange:

    • charge at AAA becomes old charge at DDD,
    • charge at BBB becomes old charge at CCC,
    • charge at CCC becomes old charge at BBB,
    • charge at DDD becomes old charge at AAA.

    So new field is E⃗′∝−[(qD−qB)r⃗A+(qC−qA)r⃗B].\vec E' \propto -\big[(q_D-q_B)\vec r_A + (q_C-q_A)\vec r_B\big].E′∝−[(qD​−qB​)rA​+(qC​−qA​)rB​].

    In general, this is not equal to E⃗\vec EE.

    Hence, E⃗ changes.\vec E \text{ changes.}E changes.

  5. Conclusion

    • Electric potential at the center remains unchanged.
    • Electric field at the center changes.

    Therefore, the correct option is A: E⃗ changes, V remains unchanged.\boxed{\text{A: } \vec E \text{ changes, } V \text{ remains unchanged}}.A: E changes, V remains unchanged​.

PreviousNext

More from Electrostatics

  • The potential at a point x(measured in μm) due to some charges situated on the x-axis is given by V(x)=20/(x2−4) volt The electric field E at x=4μm is given by2007 · MCQ
  • An electric charge 10−3μC is placed at the origin (0,0) of X−Y co-ordinate system. Two points A and B are situated at (2​,2​) and (2,0) respectively. The potential…2007 · MCQ
  • An electric dipole is placed at an angle of 30∘ to a non-uniform electric field. The dipole will experience2006 · MCQ
  • Two spherical conductors A and B of radii 1mm and 2mm are separated by a distance of 5cm and are uniformly charged. If the spheres are connected by a conducting wire then in equilibrium condition, the ratio of the magnitude of…2006 · MCQ
  • Two insulating plates are both uniformly charged in such a way that the potential difference between them is V2​−V1​=20V.(i.e., plate 2 is at a higher potential). The plates are separated by d=0.1m and can be treated as… Includes diagram2006 · MCQ
  • Two point charges +8q and −2q are located at x=0 and x=L respectively. The location of a point on the x axis at which the net electric field due to these two point charges is zero is2005 · MCQ
  • Two thin wire rings each having a radius R are placed at a distance d apart with their axes coinciding. The charges on the two rings are +q and −q. The potential difference between the centres of the two rings is2005 · MCQ
  • A charged ball B hangs from a silk thread S, which makes angle θ with a large charged conducting sheet P, as shown in the figure. The surface charge density σ of the sheet is proportional to f Includes diagram2005 · MCQ