Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Center of Mass question

2019 · 11 Jan · Shift 1 · Q50
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Main
  3. /Physics
  4. /Center of Mass
  5. /2019 · 11 Jan · Shift 1 · Q50

Center of Mass question

2019 · 11 Jan · Shift 1 · Q50

JEE MainPhysicsCenter of MassMCQ+4 / −1
A body of mass 1 kg falls freely from a height of 100 m, on a platform mass 3 kg which is mounted on a spring having spring constant k = 1.25 ×\times× 106 N/m. The body sticks to the platform and the spring's maximum compression is found to be x. Given that g = 10 ms–2 , the value of x will be close to :
  1. A
    8 cm
  2. B
    4 cm
  3. C
    40 cm
  4. D
    80 cm
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: APPROXIMATELY 2 CM (NOT AMONG THE GIVEN OPTIONS).

  1. Speed of the falling mass just before collision

The 1 kg1\,\text{kg}1kg body falls freely through height h=100 mh=100\,\text{m}h=100m.

Using v=2gh=2⋅10⋅100=2000=205 m/sv=\sqrt{2gh}=\sqrt{2\cdot 10\cdot 100}=\sqrt{2000}=20\sqrt{5}\,\text{m/s}v=2gh​=2⋅10⋅100​=2000​=205​m/s

  1. Velocity just after collision

The body sticks to the platform of mass 3 kg3\,\text{kg}3kg, so this is a perfectly inelastic collision.

Conserving momentum during collision: 1⋅(205)=(1+3)V1\cdot (20\sqrt{5})=(1+3)V1⋅(205​)=(1+3)V V=2054=55 m/sV=\frac{20\sqrt{5}}{4}=5\sqrt{5}\,\text{m/s}V=4205​​=55​m/s

So just after collision, the combined mass 4 kg4\,\text{kg}4kg moves downward with speed V=55 m/sV=5\sqrt{5}\,\text{m/s}V=55​m/s

  1. Compression of spring after collision

Now the 4 kg4\,\text{kg}4kg system compresses the spring further until momentarily coming to rest.

Let the additional maximum compression be xxx.

At the instant just after collision, kinetic energy is KE=12(4)(55)2=2⋅125=250 JKE=\frac12 (4)(5\sqrt{5})^2=2\cdot 125=250\,\text{J}KE=21​(4)(55​)2=2⋅125=250J

During downward motion by xxx, gravity does positive work: Wg=Mgx=4⋅10⋅x=40xW_g=Mgx=4\cdot 10\cdot x=40xWg​=Mgx=4⋅10⋅x=40x

At maximum compression, all this energy is stored in the spring: 12kx2=12(1.25×106)x2=6.25×105x2\frac12 kx^2=\frac12 (1.25\times 10^6)x^2=6.25\times 10^5 x^221​kx2=21​(1.25×106)x2=6.25×105x2

Hence, 6.25×105x2=250+40x6.25\times 10^5 x^2 = 250 + 40x6.25×105x2=250+40x

Since xxx is small, let us solve: 625000x2−40x−250=0625000x^2-40x-250=0625000x2−40x−250=0

Divide by 555: 125000x2−8x−50=0125000x^2-8x-50=0125000x2−8x−50=0

Using quadratic formula, x=8+64+4⋅125000⋅502⋅125000x=\frac{8+\sqrt{64+4\cdot 125000\cdot 50}}{2\cdot 125000}x=2⋅1250008+64+4⋅125000⋅50​​ x=8+25000064250000x=\frac{8+\sqrt{25000064}}{250000}x=2500008+25000064​​

Since 25000064≈5000\sqrt{25000064}\approx 500025000064​≈5000

we get x≈5008250000=0.020 m=2 cmx\approx \frac{5008}{250000}=0.020\,\text{m}=2\,\text{cm}x≈2500005008​=0.020m=2cm

This does not match any option, so we must interpret the spring compression carefully.

  1. Correct interpretation: spring already compressed by platform weight

Initially, the 3 kg3\,\text{kg}3kg platform is resting on the spring, so the spring is already compressed by x0=3gk=301.25×106=2.4×10−5 mx_0=\frac{3g}{k}=\frac{30}{1.25\times 10^6}=2.4\times 10^{-5}\,\text{m}x0​=k3g​=1.25×10630​=2.4×10−5m which is negligible.

After sticking, the new equilibrium compression for 4 kg4\,\text{kg}4kg is xe=4gk=401.25×106=3.2×10−5 mx_e=\frac{4g}{k}=\frac{40}{1.25\times 10^6}=3.2\times 10^{-5}\,\text{m}xe​=k4g​=1.25×10640​=3.2×10−5m also negligible.

So gravity has negligible effect compared to the very stiff spring, and the main compression comes from converting post-collision kinetic energy to spring energy: 12(4)V2≈12kx2\frac12 (4)V^2\approx \frac12 kx^221​(4)V2≈21​kx2 250=12(1.25×106)x2250=\frac12 (1.25\times 10^6)x^2250=21​(1.25×106)x2 x2=5001.25×106=4×10−4x^2=\frac{500}{1.25\times 10^6}=4\times 10^{-4}x2=1.25×106500​=4×10−4 x=2×10−2 m=2 cmx=2\times 10^{-2}\,\text{m}=2\,\text{cm}x=2×10−2m=2cm

This still does not match the options.

  1. Check if total energy from top is directly used after sticking

Before collision, the falling mass has energy mgh=1⋅10⋅100=1000 Jmgh=1\cdot 10\cdot 100=1000\,\text{J}mgh=1⋅10⋅100=1000J

But because the collision is perfectly inelastic, a large part is lost during collision. Only 250 J250\,\text{J}250J remains as kinetic energy afterward. Therefore using 1000 J1000\,\text{J}1000J would be incorrect.

If one incorrectly used 1000 J1000\,\text{J}1000J: 12kx2=1000\frac12 kx^2=100021​kx2=1000 x=0.04 m=4 cmx=0.04\,\text{m}=4\,\text{cm}x=0.04m=4cm which gives option B.

  1. Conclusion

By proper mechanics including inelastic collision, the compression comes out close to 2 cm2\,\text{cm}2cm, which is not among the options. The stored answer 4 cm4\,\text{cm}4cm corresponds to ignoring energy loss in the sticking collision.

Therefore, the stored answer appears inconsistent with the stated condition that the body sticks to the platform.

PreviousNext

More from Center of Mass

  • A particle of mass m is moving in a straight line with momentum p. Starting at time t = 0, a force F = kt acts in the same direction on the moving particle during time interval T so that its momentum changes from p to 3p. Here k is a…2019 · MCQ
  • A man (mass = 50 kg) and his son (mass = 20 kg) are standing on a frictionless surface facing each other. The man pushes his son so that he starts moving at a speed of 0.70 ms–1 with respect to the man. The speed of the man with respect to…2019 · MCQ
  • Three particles of masses 50 g, 100 g and 150 g are placed at the vertices of an equilateral triangle of side 1 m (as shown in the figure). The (x, y) coordinates of the centre of mass will be : Includes diagram2019 · MCQ
  • A simple pendulum, made of a string of length ℓ and a bob of mass m, is released from a small angle θ0​. It strikes a block of mass M, kept on a horizontal surface at its lowest point of oscillations, elastically. It…2019 · MCQ
  • The position vector of the centre of mass rcm​ of an asymmetric uniform bar of negligible area of crosssection as shown in figure is : Includes diagram2019 · MCQ
  • An alpha-particle of mass m suffers 1-dimensional elastic collision with a nucleus at rest of unknown mass. It is scattered directly backwards losing, 64% of its initial kinetic energy. The mass of the nucleus is2019 · MCQ
  • A proton of mass m collides elastically with a particle of unknown mass at rest. After the collision, the proton and the unknown particle are seen moving at an angle of 90o with respect to each other. The mass of unknown particle is :2018 · MCQ
  • The mass of a hydrogen molecule is 3.32 × 10-27 kg. If 1023 hydrogen molecules strike, per second, a fixed wall of area 2 cm2 at an angle of 45o to the normal, and rebound elastically with a speed of 103 m/s, then the pressure on…2018 · MCQ