- A– =
- B–
- C–
- D–
View written solutionFree
Correct answer: B
-
Key idea: orientation of addition of HCl to an alkene
Normally, addition of to an unsymmetrical alkene follows Markovnikov's rule:
- adds first to form the more stable carbocation.
- Then attacks that carbocation.
So, to get an anti-Markovnikov product as the major product, the reaction must proceed through a pathway where the less substituted carbocation-like center is favored, or where electronic effects reverse the usual polarization.
-
General substrate form
All options are of the type:
On adding HCl, there are two possibilities:
-
Markovnikov addition: via protonation at terminal carbon giving carbocation at the carbon bearing .
-
Anti-Markovnikov addition: via protonation at the -substituted carbon giving carbocation at terminal carbon.
We must see which substituent makes the second pathway more favorable.
-
-
Effect of substituent
The stability of the carbocation formed adjacent to is crucial.
- If is electron-donating ( or ), it stabilizes a carbocation on the adjacent carbon, so Markovnikov addition is favored.
- If is strongly electron-withdrawing (), it destabilizes a carbocation on the adjacent carbon, so formation of that carbocation is disfavored. Then protonation occurs the other way, giving the anti-Markovnikov product.
-
Evaluate each option
Option A:
Chlorine has strong effect, but it can also donate by resonance () when adjacent to a double bond. The net effect is not as strongly withdrawing as . So anti-Markovnikov tendency is not strongest here.
Option B:
The group is a very strong electron-withdrawing group due to a powerful effect. It strongly destabilizes a carbocation on the adjacent carbon: Therefore, the usual Markovnikov pathway becomes unfavorable.
Instead, protonation occurs so that the positive charge develops on the terminal carbon: followed by attack of , giving: This is the anti-Markovnikov product.
Hence, B is favored.
Option C:
The group has strong electron-donating effect. It stabilizes a carbocation adjacent to oxygen: Therefore Markovnikov addition is strongly favored.
Option D:
The group is also strongly electron-donating by resonance. It stabilizes the adjacent carbocation, so Markovnikov addition is favored.
-
Conclusion
The alkene that gives majorly an anti-Markovnikov product with HCl is:
-
Comparison with stored answer
Stored correct answer: B
Our derived answer: B
So they agree.
More from Haloalkanes and Haloarenes
- The major product in the following reaction is : Includes diagram2019 · MCQ
- The major product of the following reaction is : Includes diagram2019 · MCQ
- The compounds A and B in the following reaction are, respectively : Includes diagram2019 · MCQ
- The major product of the following reaction is : Includes diagram2019 · MCQ
- Increasing rate of SN1 reaction in the following compounds is : Includes diagram2019 · MCQ
- The major product of the following reaction is : Includes diagram2019 · MCQ
- The major product 'Y' in the following reactions is : Includes diagram2019 · MCQ
- The major product obtained in the given reaction is : Includes diagram2019 · MCQ