Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Geometrical Optics question

2022 · Shift 1 · Q48
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Advanced
  3. /Physics
  4. /Geometrical Optics
  5. /2022 · Shift 1 · Q48

Geometrical Optics question

2022 · Shift 1 · Q48

JEE AdvancedPhysicsGeometrical OpticsMultiple correct+4 / −2
Three plane mirrors form an equilateral triangle with each side of length LLL. There is a small hole at a distance l>0l\gt 0l>0 from one of the corners as shown in the figure. A ray of light is passed through the hole at an angle θ\thetaθ and can only come out through the same hole. The cross section of the mirror configuration and the ray of light lie on the same plane. JEE Advanced 2022 Paper 1 Online Physics - Geometrical Optics Question 23 English Which of the following statement(s) is(are) correct?
  1. A
    The ray of light will come out for θ=30∘\theta=30^{\circ}θ=30∘, for 0<l<L0\lt l \lt L0<l<L.
  2. B
    There is an angle for l=L2l=\frac{L}{2}l=2L​ at which the ray of light will come out after two reflections.
  3. C
    The ray of light will NEVER come out for θ=60∘\theta=60^{\circ}θ=60∘, and l=L3l=\frac{L}{3}l=3L​.
  4. D
    The ray of light will come out for θ=60∘\theta=60^{\circ}θ=60∘, and 0<l<L20 \lt l \lt \frac{L}{2}0<l<2L​ after six reflections.
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: A, B

Analysis of the Conditions

The problem describes a light ray entering a system of three plane mirrors forming an equilateral triangle. The ray enters through a small hole and must exit through the same hole. This can happen in two ways:

  1. Path Retracing: The ray strikes one of the mirrors at a normal incidence (90∘90^{\circ}90∘). After this, it reflects back along its incident path and exits through the hole.
  2. Periodic Orbit: The ray follows a path that is periodic and passes through the location of the hole. When it reaches the hole, it exits.

Let's set up a coordinate system. Let the vertices of the equilateral triangle be C at (0,0)(0,0)(0,0), B at (L,0)(L,0)(L,0), and A at (L/2,L3/2)(L/2, L\sqrt{3}/2)(L/2,L3​/2). The mirrors are M1 (on segment CB), M2 (on CA), and M3 (on AB). The hole H is on mirror M1 at a distance lll from corner C, so its coordinates are (l,0)(l,0)(l,0). The question places the hole at a distance lll from 'one of the corners', and the figure shows it near corner B. Let's assume the coordinates of H are (L−l,0)(L-l, 0)(L−l,0). The ray enters at an angle heta hetaheta with respect to the mirror M1.

The mirrors M1, M2, and M3 make angles 0∘0^{\circ}0∘, 60∘60^{\circ}60∘, and 120∘120^{\circ}120∘ with the positive x-axis, respectively.

Option A: The ray of light will come out for θ=30∘\theta=30^{\circ}θ=30∘, for 0<l<L0\lt l \lt L0<l<L.

  1. The ray starts from H(L−l,0)(L-l, 0)(L−l,0) with an angle of θ=30∘\theta=30^{\circ}θ=30∘ with the x-axis. The ray's path is a line.
  2. Let's check if this ray strikes any mirror normally. The angle of the mirror M3 is 120∘120^{\circ}120∘.
  3. The angle between the incident ray and the mirror M3 is ∣120∘−30∘∣=90∘|120^{\circ} - 30^{\circ}| = 90^{\circ}∣120∘−30∘∣=90∘.
  4. This means the ray strikes mirror M3 at normal incidence. Therefore, it will retrace its path and exit through the hole H.
  5. We must verify that the ray actually hits the segment AB (mirror M3). The equation of the ray is y=tan⁡(30∘)(x−(L−l))=13(x−L+l)y = \tan(30^{\circ})(x - (L-l)) = \frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}(x - L + l)y=tan(30∘)(x−(L−l))=3​1​(x−L+l). The equation of mirror M3 (line AB) is y−0=L3/2−0L/2−L(x−L)  ⟹  y=−3(x−L)y - 0 = \frac{L\sqrt{3}/2 - 0}{L/2 - L}(x - L) \implies y = -\sqrt{3}(x-L)y−0=L/2−LL3​/2−0​(x−L)⟹y=−3​(x−L).
  6. The intersection point is found by equating the y-values: 13(x−L+l)=−3(x−L)  ⟹  x−L+l=−3x+3L  ⟹  4x=4L−l  ⟹  x=L−l/4\frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}(x - L + l) = -\sqrt{3}(x-L) \implies x-L+l = -3x+3L \implies 4x = 4L-l \implies x = L - l/43​1​(x−L+l)=−3​(x−L)⟹x−L+l=−3x+3L⟹4x=4L−l⟹x=L−l/4.
  7. For the intersection point to be on mirror M3, its x-coordinate must be between L/2L/2L/2 and LLL. Since l>0l>0l>0, x=L−l/4<Lx = L-l/4 < Lx=L−l/4<L. We also need L/2≤L−l/4  ⟹  l/4≤L/2  ⟹  l≤2LL/2 \le L-l/4 \implies l/4 \le L/2 \implies l \le 2LL/2≤L−l/4⟹l/4≤L/2⟹l≤2L. The given condition is 0<l<L0 < l < L0<l<L, which is within the valid range.
  8. Thus, for any lll in the given range, the ray hits M3 normally, retraces its path, and comes out of the hole. This happens after one reflection.
  9. Conclusion: Statement A is correct.

Option B: There is an angle for l=L2l=\frac{L}{2}l=2L​ at which the ray of light will come out after two reflections.

  1. Here, the hole H is at the midpoint of the base M1, H(L/2,0)(L/2, 0)(L/2,0).
  2. Let's test the angle θ=60∘\theta=60^{\circ}θ=60∘. The initial ray is parallel to mirror M2.
  3. The ray starts from H(L/2,0)(L/2, 0)(L/2,0), its equation is y=tan⁡(60∘)(x−L/2)=3(x−L/2)y = \tan(60^{\circ})(x - L/2) = \sqrt{3}(x-L/2)y=tan(60∘)(x−L/2)=3​(x−L/2).
  4. It first hits mirror M3 (y=−3(x−L)y = -\sqrt{3}(x-L)y=−3​(x−L)). Intersection point P: 3(x−L/2)=−3(x−L)  ⟹  x−L/2=−x+L  ⟹  2x=3L/2  ⟹  x=3L/4\sqrt{3}(x-L/2) = -\sqrt{3}(x-L) \implies x-L/2 = -x+L \implies 2x=3L/2 \implies x=3L/43​(x−L/2)=−3​(x−L)⟹x−L/2=−x+L⟹2x=3L/2⟹x=3L/4. The y-coordinate is y=3(3L/4−L/2)=L3/4y=\sqrt{3}(3L/4-L/2) = L\sqrt{3}/4y=3​(3L/4−L/2)=L3​/4. P is (3L/4,L3/4)(3L/4, L\sqrt{3}/4)(3L/4,L3​/4), which is the midpoint of M3.
  5. After reflection from M3 (angle 120∘120^{\circ}120∘), the new ray angle is α1=2×120∘−60∘=180∘\alpha_1 = 2 \times 120^{\circ} - 60^{\circ} = 180^{\circ}α1​=2×120∘−60∘=180∘. The ray travels horizontally.
  6. This horizontal ray hits mirror M2 (y=3xy=\sqrt{3}xy=3​x). Intersection point Q: L3/4=3x  ⟹  x=L/4L\sqrt{3}/4 = \sqrt{3}x \implies x=L/4L3​/4=3​x⟹x=L/4. Q is (L/4,L3/4)(L/4, L\sqrt{3}/4)(L/4,L3​/4), which is the midpoint of M2.
  7. After reflection from M2 (angle 60∘60^{\circ}60∘), the new ray angle is α2=2×60∘−180∘=−60∘\alpha_2 = 2 \times 60^{\circ} - 180^{\circ} = -60^{\circ}α2​=2×60∘−180∘=−60∘.
  8. The ray from Q travels with slope tan⁡(−60∘)=−3\tan(-60^{\circ})=-\sqrt{3}tan(−60∘)=−3​. Its equation is y−L3/4=−3(x−L/4)  ⟹  y=−3x+L3/2y - L\sqrt{3}/4 = -\sqrt{3}(x-L/4) \implies y = -\sqrt{3}x + L\sqrt{3}/2y−L3​/4=−3​(x−L/4)⟹y=−3​x+L3​/2. This ray passes through (L/2,0)(L/2, 0)(L/2,0), which is the hole H.
  9. The path is H →\to→ P →\to→ Q →\to→ H. The ray comes out of the hole after two reflections (at P and Q).
  10. Conclusion: Statement B is correct.

Option C: The ray of light will NEVER come out for θ=60∘\theta=60^{\circ}θ=60∘, and l=L3l=\frac{L}{3}l=3L​.

  1. Let's trace the path for θ=60∘\theta=60^{\circ}θ=60∘ and l=L/3l=L/3l=L/3. The hole H is at (L−L/3,0)=(2L/3,0)(L-L/3, 0) = (2L/3, 0)(L−L/3,0)=(2L/3,0).
  2. A general analysis for θ=60∘\theta=60^{\circ}θ=60∘ starting from x0=L−lx_0 = L-lx0​=L−l shows that after 3 reflections (on M3, M2, M1), the ray hits the base M1 at a new position x1=lx_1=lx1​=l. For l=L/3l=L/3l=L/3, x0=2L/3x_0 = 2L/3x0​=2L/3 and x1=L/3x_1=L/3x1​=L/3.
  3. From this new point x1=lx_1=lx1​=l, the ray reflects from M1 and starts another 3-reflection sequence. The new starting lll is l′=L−x1=L−ll' = L-x_1 = L-ll′=L−x1​=L−l. The next point it hits the base is x2=l′=L−lx_2=l'=L-lx2​=l′=L−l. For our case, x2=L−L/3=2L/3x_2 = L-L/3 = 2L/3x2​=L−L/3=2L/3, which is the original starting point H.
  4. The path is periodic, returning to the hole H. It takes 3+3=63+3=63+3=6 reflections for the ray to return to the initial state (position and direction). The ray path is H →\to→ ... →\to→ H' →\to→ ... →\to→ H.
  5. The ray reaches the hole H and exits. Therefore, the statement that it will NEVER come out is false.
  6. Conclusion: Statement C is incorrect.

Option D: The ray of light will come out for θ=60∘\theta=60^{\circ}θ=60∘, and 0<l<L20 \lt l \lt \frac{L}{2}0<l<2L​ after six reflections.

  1. As analyzed for option C, for θ=60∘\theta=60^{\circ}θ=60∘ and any lll (that doesn't cause a vertex hit), the path is periodic. Starting from H at x0=L−lx_0 = L-lx0​=L−l, it hits the base at x1=lx_1=lx1​=l after 3 reflections, and then back at x2=L−lx_2 = L-lx2​=L−l after another 3 reflections.
  2. For leqL/2l eq L/2leqL/2, x0eqx1x_0 eq x_1x0​eqx1​, so the ray does not return to the hole after 3 reflections. It returns after a total of 6 reflections (or rather, it arrives at the location of the 6th reflection point, which is H).
  3. Let's count the number of reflections before it exits. The path is: H(start) →\to→ P(M3) →\to→ Q(M2) →\to→ H'(M1) →\to→ P'(M3) →\to→ Q'(M2) →\to→ H(exit).
  4. The reflections are at P, Q, H', P', Q'. There are 5 reflections. After the 5th reflection (at Q'), the ray travels towards H and exits.
  5. So, the ray comes out after 5 reflections. The statement says it comes out after 6 reflections. This is a counting mismatch.
  6. The wording in Option B, which we found correct, implies this counting method: H →\to→ P(refl 1) →\to→ Q(refl 2) →\to→ H(exit). This is described as
PreviousNext

More from Geometrical Optics

  • List I contains four combinations of two lenses (1 and 2) whose focal lengths (in cm) are indicated in the figures. In all cases, the object is placed 20 cm from the first lens on the left, and the distance between… Includes table Includes diagram2022 · MCQ
  • Consider a configuration of n identical units, each consisting of three layers. The first layer is a column of air of height h=31​ cm, and the second and third layers are of equal thickness d=23​−1​ cm… Includes diagram2022 · Numerical
  • An object and a concave mirror of focal length f=10 cm both move along the principal axis of the mirror with constant speeds. The object moves with speed V0​=15 cm s−1 towards the mirror with respect… Includes diagram2022 · Numerical
  • An extended object is placed at point O, 10 cm in front of a convex lens L1 and a concave lens L2 is placed 10 cm behind it, as shown in the figure. The radii of curvature of all the curved surfaces in both the lenses ae 20 cm. The… Includes diagram2021 · MCQ
  • A wide slab consisting of two media of refractive indices n1 and n2 is placed in air as shown in the figure. A ray of light is incident from medium n1 to n2 at an angle θ, where sin θ is slightly larger than 1/n1. Take… Includes diagram2021 · Multiple correct
  • For a prism of prism angle θ = 60 ∘, the refractive indices of the left half and the right half are, respectively, n1 and n2 (n2 ≥ n1) as shown in the figure. The angle of incidence i is chosen such that the incident… Includes diagram2021 · Multiple correct
  • A large square container with thin transparent vertical walls and filled with water (refractive index 34​) is kept on a horizontal table. A student holds a thin straight wire vertically inside the water 12 cm from one of its… Includes diagram2020 · Numerical
  • A beaker of radius r is filled with water (refractive index 34​) up to a height H as shown in the figure on the left. The beaker is kept on a horizontal table rotating with angular speed ω. This makes the water surface… Includes diagram2020 · Multiple correct