Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Geometrical Optics question

2020 · Shift 2 · Q43
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Advanced
  3. /Physics
  4. /Geometrical Optics
  5. /2020 · Shift 2 · Q43

Geometrical Optics question

2020 · Shift 2 · Q43

JEE AdvancedPhysicsGeometrical OpticsMultiple correct+4 / −2
A beaker of radius r is filled with water (refractive index 43{4 \over 3}34​) up to a height H as shown in the figure on the left. The beaker is kept on a horizontal table rotating with angular speed ω\omegaω. This makes the water surface curved so that the difference in the height of water level at the center and at the circumference of the beaker is h (h << H, h << r), as shown in the figure on the right. Take this surface to be approximately spherical with a radius of curvature R. Which of the following is/are correct? (g is the acceleration due to gravity) JEE Advanced 2020 Paper 2 Offline Physics - Geometrical Optics Question 47 English
  1. A
    R=h2+r22hR = {{{h^2} + {r^2}} \over {2h}}R=2hh2+r2​
  2. B
    R=3r22hR = {{3{r^2}} \over {2h}}R=2h3r2​
  3. C
    Apparent depth of the bottom of the beaker is close to 3H2(1+ω2H2g)−1{{3H} \over 2}\left( {1 + {{{\omega ^2}H} \over {2g}}} \right)^{-1}23H​(1+2gω2H​)−1
  4. D
    Apparent depth of the bottom of the beaker is close to 3H4(1+ω2H4g)−1{{3H} \over 4}{\left( {1 + {{{\omega ^2}H} \over {4g}}} \right)^{ - 1}}43H​(1+4gω2H​)−1
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: A, D

Part 1: Analysis of the water surface and radius of curvature (Options A and B)

  1. Equation of the Surface: When the beaker rotates with angular speed ω\omegaω, a fluid particle of mass mmm on the surface at a radial distance xxx from the center experiences a downward gravitational force mgmgmg and a horizontal centrifugal force mω2xm\omega^2xmω2x. The surface of the water aligns itself perpendicular to the effective force. The slope of the surface is given by: tan⁡θ=dydx=mω2xmg=ω2xg\tan \theta = {{dy} \over {dx}} = {{m{\omega ^2}x} \over {mg}} = {{{{\omega ^2}x} \over g}}tanθ=dxdy​=mgmω2x​=gω2x​ Integrating this equation, we get the shape of the surface: ∫dy=∫ω2xgdx⇒y=ω2x22g+C\int {dy} = \int {{{{\omega ^2}x} \over g}dx} \Rightarrow y = {{{\omega ^2}{x^2}} \over {2g}} + C∫dy=∫gω2x​dx⇒y=2gω2x2​+C Taking the lowest point of the surface at the center (x=0x=0x=0) as the origin for the vertical displacement (y=0y=0y=0), we get C=0C=0C=0. So, the surface is a parabola described by y=ω2x22gy = {{{{\omega ^2}{x^2}} \over {2g}}}y=2gω2x2​.

  2. Relating h and r: The problem states that the height difference between the center (x=0x=0x=0) and the circumference (x=rx=rx=r) is hhh. h=y(r)−y(0)=ω2r22g⇒ω2g=2hr2h = y(r) - y(0) = {{{{\omega ^2}{r^2}} \over {2g}}} \Rightarrow {{{\omega ^2}} \over g} = {{2h} \over {{r^2}}}h=y(r)−y(0)=2gω2r2​⇒gω2​=r22h​

  3. Radius of Curvature (R): The radius of curvature of a curve y=f(x)y=f(x)y=f(x) is given by the formula R = {{{{\left[ {1 + {{\left( {{{dy} \over {dx}}} \right)}^2}} \right]}^{3/2}}} \over {\left| {{{{d^2}y} \over {d{x^2}}}} \right|}}}. We have y′=dydx=ω2xgy' = {{dy} \over {dx}} = {{{{\omega ^2}x} \over g}}y′=dxdy​=gω2x​ and y′′=d2ydx2=ω2gy'' = {{{{d^2}y} \over {d{x^2}}}} = {{{{\omega ^2}} \over g}}y′′=dx2d2y​=gω2​. For optical calculations near the center (paraxial approximation), we need the radius of curvature at the vertex (x=0x=0x=0). R=[1+0]3/2ω2g=gω2R = {{{{\left[ {1 + 0} \right]}^{3/2}}} \over {{{{\omega ^2}} \over g}}} = {g \over {{\omega ^2}}}R=gω2​[1+0]3/2​=ω2g​ Substituting the expression for ω2g{{{\omega ^2}} \over g}gω2​ from step 2: R=12hr2=r22hR = {1 \over {{{2h} \over {{r^2}}}}} = {{{r^2}} \over {2h}}R=r22h​1​=2hr2​

  4. Evaluating Options A and B:

    • Option B is R=3r22hR = {{3{r^2}} \over {2h}}R=2h3r2​, which is incorrect.
    • Option A is R = {{{h^2} + {r^2}} \over {2h}}}. This formula is the exact radius of a spherical cap with base radius rrr and height (sagitta) hhh. In many optics problems, parabolic surfaces are approximated as spherical. If we assume h≪rh \ll rh≪r, then h2h^2h2 is negligible, and Option A simplifies to R≈r22hR \approx {{{r^2}} \over {2h}}R≈2hr2​, which matches our result for the vertex curvature. Given that this is a common approximation in geometrical optics, we can consider Option A to be the intended correct model for the radius of curvature.

Part 2: Apparent Depth (Options C and D)

  1. Setup: We use the formula for refraction at a single spherical surface: μ2v−μ1u=μ2−μ1R{{{\mu _2}} \over v} - {{{\mu _1}} \over u} = {{{{\mu _2} - {\mu _1}} \over R}}vμ2​​−uμ1​​=Rμ2​−μ1​​

    • Light travels from water (medium 1) to air (medium 2). So, μ1=μ=43{\mu _1} = \mu = {4 \over 3}μ1​=μ=34​ and μ2=1{\mu _2} = 1μ2​=1.
    • The object is at the bottom of the beaker. We need to find its distance (uuu) from the vertex of the curved surface. The initial water height (flat surface) is HHH. By conservation of volume, the initial volume V=πr2HV = \pi r^2 HV=πr2H must equal the final volume under rotation. The volume of a paraboloid of revolution is 12(base area)×(height){1 \over 2}(\text{base area}) \times (\text{height})21​(base area)×(height). V=πr2Hmin+12πr2hV = \pi r^2 H_{min} + {1 \over 2}\pi r^2 hV=πr2Hmin​+21​πr2h, where HminH_{min}Hmin​ is the height at the center. πr2H=πr2(Hmin+h/2)\pi r^2 H = \pi r^2 (H_{min} + h/2)πr2H=πr2(Hmin​+h/2), which gives Hmin=H−h/2H_{min} = H - h/2Hmin​=H−h/2.
    • The object distance from the vertex is u=−Hmin=−(H−h/2)u = - H_{min} = -(H - h/2)u=−Hmin​=−(H−h/2). The negative sign is per standard sign convention (origin at vertex, light traveling in +ve direction).
    • For light rays coming from the bottom, the water surface is convex. Therefore, its radius of curvature is positive: R=+r22h=+gω2R = + {{{r^2}} \over {2h}} = + {g \over {{\omega ^2}}}R=+2hr2​=+ω2g​.
  2. Calculation: 1v−4/3−(H−h/2)=1−4/3+r2/(2h){1 \over v} - {{{4/3}} \over { - (H - h/2)}} = {{1 - 4/3} \over { + {r^2}/(2h)}}v1​−−(H−h/2)4/3​=+r2/(2h)1−4/3​ 1v+43(H−h/2)=−1/3r2/(2h)=−2h3r2{1 \over v} + {4 \over {3(H - h/2)}} = {{ - 1/3} \over {{r^2}/(2h)}} = - {{2h} \over {3{r^2}}}v1​+3(H−h/2)4​=r2/(2h)−1/3​=−3r22h​ Using ω2g=2hr2{{{{\omega ^2}} \over g} = {{2h} \over {{r^2}}}}gω2​=r22h​: 1v=−ω23g−43(H−h/2){1 \over v} = - {{{\omega ^2}} \over {3g}} - {4 \over {3(H - h/2)}}v1​=−3gω2​−3(H−h/2)4​ The image position vvv is negative, indicating a virtual image, as expected. The apparent depth dappd_{app}dapp​ is ∣v∣|v|∣v∣. dapp=∣v∣=1ω23g+43(H−h/2)=3ω2g+4H−h/2d_{app} = |v| = {1 \over {{{{\omega ^2}} \over {3g}} + {4 \over {3(H - h/2)}}}} = {3 \over {{{{\omega ^2}} \over g} + {4 \over {H - h/2}}}}dapp​=∣v∣=3gω2​+3(H−h/2)4​1​=gω2​+H−h/24​3​ dapp=3(H−h/2)ω2g(H−h/2)+4d_{app} = {{3(H - h/2)} \over {{{{\omega ^2}} \over g}(H - h/2) + 4}}dapp​=gω2​(H−h/2)+43(H−h/2)​

  3. Approximation and Evaluation of Options C and D: The options are given as

PreviousNext

More from Geometrical Optics

  • A thin convex lens is made of two materials with refractive indices n1 and n2, as shown in the figure. The radius of curvature of the left and right spherical surfaces are equal. f is the focal length of the lens when n1 = n2 = n. The… Includes diagram2019 · Multiple correct
  • A planar structure of length L and width W is made of two different optical media of refractive indices n1 = 1.5 and n2 = 1.44 as shown in figure. If L >> W, a ray entering from end AB will emerge from end CD. CD only if the total… Includes diagram2019 · Numerical
  • Three glass cylinders of equal height H = 30 cm and same refractive index n = 1.5 are placed on a horizontal surface as shown in figure. Cylinder I has a flat top, cylinder II has a convex top and cylinder III has a concave top. The radii… Includes diagram2019 · Multiple correct
  • A monochromatic light is incident from air on a refracting surface of a prism of angle 75 ∘ and refractive index n0​=3​. The other refracting surface of the prism is coated by a thin film of material of refractive index n… Includes diagram2019 · Numerical
  • Sunlight of intensity 1.3kWm−2 is incident normally on a thin convex lens of focal length 20 cm. Ignore the energy loss of light due to the lens and assume that the lens aperture size is much smaller than its focal length. The…2018 · Numerical
  • A wire is bent in the shape of a right angled triangle and is placed in front of a concave mirror of focal length f, as shown in the figure. Which of the figures shown in the four options qualitatively represent(s) the shape of the image… Includes diagram2018 · Multiple correct
  • For an isosceles prism of angle A and refractive index μ, it is found that the angle of minimum deviation δm​=A. Which of the following options is/are correct?2017 · Multiple correct
  • A monochromatic light is travelling in a medium of refractive index n=1.6. It enters a stack of glass layers from the bottom side at an angle θ=30∘. The interfaces of the glass layers are parallel to each other. The… Includes diagram2017 · Numerical