Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Geometrical Optics question

2021 · Shift 1 · Q50
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Advanced
  3. /Physics
  4. /Geometrical Optics
  5. /2021 · Shift 1 · Q50

Geometrical Optics question

2021 · Shift 1 · Q50

JEE AdvancedPhysicsGeometrical OpticsMultiple correct+4 / −2
A wide slab consisting of two media of refractive indices n1 and n2 is placed in air as shown in the figure. A ray of light is incident from medium n1 to n2 at an angle θ\thetaθ, where sin θ\thetaθ is slightly larger than 1/n1. Take refractive index of air as 1. Which of the following statement(s) is(are) correct? JEE Advanced 2021 Paper 1 Online Physics - Geometrical Optics Question 41 English
  1. A
    The light ray enters air if n2 = n1
  2. B
    The light ray is finally reflected back into the medium of refractive index n1 if n2 < n1
  3. C
    The light ray is finally reflected back into the medium of refractive index n1 if n2 > n1
  4. D
    The light ray is reflected back into the medium of refractive index n1 if n2 = 1
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: B, C, D

Step-by-step Derivations

1. Analyze the given condition and its implication for the final interface.

The problem states that a ray of light is incident from medium n1n_1n1​ to n2n_2n2​ at an angle θ, and sin⁡θ\sin{\theta}sinθ is slightly larger than 1/n11/n_11/n1​. We can write this as: sin⁡θ>1n1  ⟹  n1sin⁡θ>1\sin{\theta} > \frac{1}{n_1} \implies n_1 \sin{\theta} > 1sinθ>n1​1​⟹n1​sinθ>1

Let's analyze the path of the light ray. The ray first travels from medium n1n_1n1​ to n2n_2n2​, and then from n2n_2n2​ to air (refractive index = 1). Let the angle of refraction at the n1n_1n1​-n2n_2n2​ interface be r. According to Snell's law: n1sin⁡θ=n2sin⁡rn_1 \sin{\theta} = n_2 \sin{r}n1​sinθ=n2​sinr

The ray then strikes the n2n_2n2​-air interface. Since the interfaces of the slab are parallel, the angle of incidence at this second interface is also r. Let's assume the ray emerges into the air at an angle e. Applying Snell's law at the n2n_2n2​-air interface: n2sin⁡r=1⋅sin⁡en_2 \sin{r} = 1 \cdot \sin{e}n2​sinr=1⋅sine

Combining the two Snell's law equations, we get: n1sin⁡θ=sin⁡en_1 \sin{\theta} = \sin{e}n1​sinθ=sine

Using the given condition n1sin⁡θ>1n_1 \sin{\theta} > 1n1​sinθ>1, we find: sin⁡e>1\sin{e} > 1sine>1 This is physically impossible for a real angle e. This crucial result implies that the light ray can never emerge into the air from the n2n_2n2​ medium. It must undergo Total Internal Reflection (TIR) at the n2n_2n2​-air interface, provided it reaches that interface.

After TIR at the n2n_2n2​-air interface, the ray is reflected back into medium n2n_2n2​ and travels towards the n2n_2n2​-n1n_1n1​ interface. By the principle of reversibility, it will re-enter medium n1n_1n1​. Therefore, if the ray enters medium n2n_2n2​, it is ultimately reflected back into medium n1n_1n1​.

Now we must also consider the possibility of TIR at the first interface (n1n_1n1​ to n2n_2n2​). This can only happen if n1>n2n_1 > n_2n1​>n2​.

2. Evaluate each option based on the analysis.

  • A: The light ray enters air if n_2 = n_1 If n2=n1n_2 = n_1n2​=n1​, the slab is effectively a single medium of refractive index n1n_1n1​. The light ray travels undeviated to the n1n_1n1​-air interface. The angle of incidence at this interface is θ. The critical angle for the n1n_1n1​-air interface, θc\theta_cθc​, is given by sin⁡θc=1/n1\sin{\theta_c} = 1/n_1sinθc​=1/n1​. The problem states sin⁡θ>1/n1\sin{\theta} > 1/n_1sinθ>1/n1​, which means θ>θc\theta > \theta_cθ>θc​. Therefore, TIR occurs at the n1n_1n1​-air interface, and the ray is reflected back into medium n1n_1n1​. It does not enter the air. Thus, statement A is incorrect.

  • B: The light ray is finally reflected back into the medium of refractive index n_1 if n_2 < n_1 In this case, the ray travels from a denser medium (n1n_1n1​) to a rarer medium (n2n_2n2​). The critical angle for this interface is θc12\theta_{c12}θc12​, where sin⁡θc12=n2/n1\sin{\theta_{c12}} = n_2/n_1sinθc12​=n2​/n1​.

    • Case 1: If sin⁡θ>n2/n1\sin{\theta} > n_2/n_1sinθ>n2​/n1​ (i.e., θ>θc12\theta > \theta_{c12}θ>θc12​), TIR occurs at the first (n1n_1n1​-n2n_2n2​) interface. The ray is immediately reflected back into medium n1n_1n1​.
    • Case 2: If sin⁡θ≤n2/n1\sin{\theta} \le n_2/n_1sinθ≤n2​/n1​, the ray refracts into medium n2n_2n2​. As established in our initial analysis, this ray will then undergo TIR at the n2n_2n2​-air interface and subsequently re-enter medium n1n_1n1​. In both possible scenarios, the ray is finally reflected back into medium n1n_1n1​. Thus, statement B is correct.
  • C: The light ray is finally reflected back into the medium of refractive index n_1 if n_2 > n_1 In this case, the ray travels from a rarer medium (n1n_1n1​) to a denser medium (n2n_2n2​). TIR cannot occur at the first interface, so the ray will always enter medium n2n_2n2​. As established in our initial analysis, the ray will then undergo TIR at the n2n_2n2​-air interface and be reflected back, eventually re-entering medium n1n_1n1​. Thus, statement C is correct.

  • D: The light ray is reflected back into the medium of refractive index n_1 if n_2 = 1 This is a special case of option B where n2<n1n_2 < n_1n2​<n1​ (assuming n1>1n_1 > 1n1​>1, which is necessary for the condition sin⁡θ>1/n1\sin{\theta} > 1/n_1sinθ>1/n1​ to be possible). The first interface is between medium n1n_1n1​ and air (n2=1n_2 = 1n2​=1). The critical angle θc\theta_cθc​ is given by sin⁡θc=n2/n1=1/n1\sin{\theta_c} = n_2/n_1 = 1/n_1sinθc​=n2​/n1​=1/n1​. The given condition is sin⁡θ>1/n1\sin{\theta} > 1/n_1sinθ>1/n1​, which means θ>θc\theta > \theta_cθ>θc​. Therefore, TIR occurs at the very first interface, and the ray is reflected back into medium n1n_1n1​. Thus, statement D is correct.

Conclusion

Based on the step-by-step analysis, options B, C, and D are correct.

PreviousNext

More from Geometrical Optics

  • For a prism of prism angle θ = 60 ∘, the refractive indices of the left half and the right half are, respectively, n1 and n2 (n2 ≥ n1) as shown in the figure. The angle of incidence i is chosen such that the incident… Includes diagram2021 · Multiple correct
  • A large square container with thin transparent vertical walls and filled with water (refractive index 34​) is kept on a horizontal table. A student holds a thin straight wire vertically inside the water 12 cm from one of its… Includes diagram2020 · Numerical
  • A beaker of radius r is filled with water (refractive index 34​) up to a height H as shown in the figure on the left. The beaker is kept on a horizontal table rotating with angular speed ω. This makes the water surface… Includes diagram2020 · Multiple correct
  • A thin convex lens is made of two materials with refractive indices n1 and n2, as shown in the figure. The radius of curvature of the left and right spherical surfaces are equal. f is the focal length of the lens when n1 = n2 = n. The… Includes diagram2019 · Multiple correct
  • A planar structure of length L and width W is made of two different optical media of refractive indices n1 = 1.5 and n2 = 1.44 as shown in figure. If L >> W, a ray entering from end AB will emerge from end CD. CD only if the total… Includes diagram2019 · Numerical
  • Three glass cylinders of equal height H = 30 cm and same refractive index n = 1.5 are placed on a horizontal surface as shown in figure. Cylinder I has a flat top, cylinder II has a convex top and cylinder III has a concave top. The radii… Includes diagram2019 · Multiple correct
  • A monochromatic light is incident from air on a refracting surface of a prism of angle 75 ∘ and refractive index n0​=3​. The other refracting surface of the prism is coated by a thin film of material of refractive index n… Includes diagram2019 · Numerical
  • Sunlight of intensity 1.3kWm−2 is incident normally on a thin convex lens of focal length 20 cm. Ignore the energy loss of light due to the lens and assume that the lens aperture size is much smaller than its focal length. The…2018 · Numerical