Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Electrostatics question

2022 · Shift 2 · Q48
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Advanced
  3. /Physics
  4. /Electrostatics
  5. /2022 · Shift 2 · Q48

Electrostatics question

2022 · Shift 2 · Q48

JEE AdvancedPhysicsElectrostaticsMultiple correct+4 / −2
A disk of radius R\mathrm{R}R with uniform positive charge density σ\sigmaσ is placed on the xyx yxy plane with its center at the origin. The Coulomb potential along the zzz-axis is V(z)=σ2ϵ0(R2+z2−z).V(z)=\frac{\sigma}{2 \epsilon_{0}}\left(\sqrt{R^{2}+z^{2}}-z\right) .V(z)=2ϵ0​σ​(R2+z2​−z). A particle of positive charge qqq is placed initially at rest at a point on the zzz axis with z=z0z=z_{0}z=z0​ and z0>0z_{0}\gt 0z0​>0. In addition to the Coulomb force, the particle experiences a vertical force F⃗=−ck^\vec{F}=-c \hat{k}F=−ck^ with c>0c\gt 0c>0. Let β=2cϵ0qσ\beta=\frac{2 c \epsilon_{0}}{q \sigma}β=qσ2cϵ0​​. Which of the following statement(s) is(are) correct?
  1. A
    For β=14\beta=\frac{1}{4}β=41​ and z0=257Rz_{0}=\frac{25}{7} Rz0​=725​R, the particle reaches the origin.
  2. B
    For β=14\beta=\frac{1}{4}β=41​ and z0=37Rz_{0}=\frac{3}{7} Rz0​=73​R, the particle reaches the origin.
  3. C
    For β=14\beta=\frac{1}{4}β=41​ and z0=R3z_{0}=\frac{R}{\sqrt{3}}z0​=3​R​, the particle returns back to z=z0z=z_{0}z=z0​.
  4. D
    For β>1\beta\gt 1β>1 and z0>0z_{0}\gt 0z0​>0, the particle always reaches the origin.
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: A, C, D

Step 1: Define the Total Potential Energy

The total potential energy U(z) of the particle of charge q at a height z on the z-axis is the sum of its electrostatic potential energy Ue(z)U_e(z)Ue​(z) and the potential energy UF(z)U_F(z)UF​(z) associated with the additional force F⃗=−ck^\vec{F} = -c \hat{k}F=−ck^.

  1. Electrostatic Potential Energy: Ue(z)=qV(z)=qσ2ϵ0(R2+z2−z)U_e(z) = qV(z) = q \frac{\sigma}{2 \epsilon_{0}}\left(\sqrt{R^{2}+z^{2}}-z\right)Ue​(z)=qV(z)=q2ϵ0​σ​(R2+z2​−z)

  2. Potential Energy from the constant force: The force is F⃗=−ck^\vec{F} = -c \hat{k}F=−ck^. The potential energy change from the origin to a point z is ΔU=−W=−∫0zF⃗⋅dl⃗\Delta U = -W = -\int_0^z \vec{F} \cdot d\vec{l}ΔU=−W=−∫0z​F⋅dl. With dl⃗=dz′k^d\vec{l} = dz' \hat{k}dl=dz′k^, we have: UF(z)−UF(0)=−∫0z(−ck^)⋅(dz′k^)=∫0zcdz′=czU_F(z) - U_F(0) = -\int_0^z (-c \hat{k}) \cdot (dz' \hat{k}) = \int_0^z c dz' = czUF​(z)−UF​(0)=−∫0z​(−ck^)⋅(dz′k^)=∫0z​cdz′=cz Assuming UF(0)=0U_F(0) = 0UF​(0)=0, we get UF(z)=czU_F(z) = czUF​(z)=cz.

  3. Total Potential Energy: U(z)=Ue(z)+UF(z)=qσ2ϵ0(R2+z2−z)+czU(z) = U_e(z) + U_F(z) = q \frac{\sigma}{2 \epsilon_{0}}\left(\sqrt{R^{2}+z^{2}}-z\right) + czU(z)=Ue​(z)+UF​(z)=q2ϵ0​σ​(R2+z2​−z)+cz U(z)=qσ2ϵ0R2+z2+(c−qσ2ϵ0)zU(z) = \frac{q\sigma}{2\epsilon_0} \sqrt{R^2+z^2} + \left(c - \frac{q\sigma}{2\epsilon_0}\right)zU(z)=2ϵ0​qσ​R2+z2​+(c−2ϵ0​qσ​)z

Step 2: Express Potential Energy in terms of β\betaβ

The problem defines β=2cϵ0qσ\beta=\frac{2 c \epsilon_{0}}{q \sigma}β=qσ2cϵ0​​. We can express c as c=βqσ2ϵ0c = \frac{\beta q \sigma}{2 \epsilon_0}c=2ϵ0​βqσ​. Substituting this into the expression for U(z): c−qσ2ϵ0=βqσ2ϵ0−qσ2ϵ0=qσ2ϵ0(β−1)c - \frac{q\sigma}{2\epsilon_0} = \frac{\beta q \sigma}{2 \epsilon_0} - \frac{q\sigma}{2\epsilon_0} = \frac{q\sigma}{2\epsilon_0}(\beta-1)c−2ϵ0​qσ​=2ϵ0​βqσ​−2ϵ0​qσ​=2ϵ0​qσ​(β−1) Let's define a positive constant U0=qσ2ϵ0U_0 = \frac{q\sigma}{2\epsilon_0}U0​=2ϵ0​qσ​. The total potential energy becomes: U(z)=U0[R2+z2+(β−1)z]U(z) = U_0 \left[ \sqrt{R^2+z^2} + (\beta-1)z \right]U(z)=U0​[R2+z2​+(β−1)z] for z≥0z \ge 0z≥0.

Step 3: Analyze the Motion based on β\betaβ

The force on the particle is Fz=−dUdzF_z = -\frac{dU}{dz}Fz​=−dzdU​. dUdz=U0[zR2+z2+(β−1)]\frac{dU}{dz} = U_0 \left[ \frac{z}{\sqrt{R^2+z^2}} + (\beta-1) \right]dzdU​=U0​[R2+z2​z​+(β−1)] Equilibrium points zez_eze​ occur where Fz=0F_z = 0Fz​=0, which means dUdz=0\frac{dU}{dz} = 0dzdU​=0: zeR2+ze2=1−β\frac{z_e}{\sqrt{R^2+z_e^2}} = 1-\betaR2+ze2​​ze​​=1−β

Case 1: β≥1\beta \ge 1β≥1 If β≥1\beta \ge 1β≥1, then 1−β≤01-\beta \le 01−β≤0. Since zeR2+ze2\frac{z_e}{\sqrt{R^2+z_e^2}}R2+ze2​​ze​​ must be non-negative for ze≥0z_e \ge 0ze​≥0, an equilibrium point can only exist at ze=0z_e=0ze​=0 if β=1\beta=1β=1. For β>1\beta > 1β>1, there is no equilibrium point for z≥0z \ge 0z≥0. For z > 0, dUdz=U0[zR2+z2+(β−1)]>0\frac{dU}{dz} = U_0 \left[ \frac{z}{\sqrt{R^2+z^2}} + (\beta-1) \right] > 0dzdU​=U0​[R2+z2​z​+(β−1)]>0 since both terms in the bracket are positive. Thus, U(z) is a monotonically increasing function for z>0. The force Fz=−dUdzF_z = -\frac{dU}{dz}Fz​=−dzdU​ is always negative (directed towards the origin). Any particle released from rest at z0>0z_0 > 0z0​>0 will accelerate towards the origin and will always reach it.

Case 2: 0<β<10 < \beta < 10<β<1 In this case, 0<1−β<10 < 1-\beta < 10<1−β<1. There exists a unique equilibrium point ze>0z_e > 0ze​>0 which is a minimum of the potential energy (since d2Udz2=U0R2(R2+z2)3/2>0\frac{d^2U}{dz^2} = U_0 \frac{R^2}{(R^2+z^2)^{3/2}} > 0dz2d2U​=U0​(R2+z2)3/2R2​>0, the potential is convex). This forms a potential well.

  • If a particle is released at z0z_0z0​ such that 0<z0<ze0 < z_0 < z_e0<z0​<ze​, the force Fz(z0)F_z(z_0)Fz​(z0​) will be positive (away from the origin), so it will never reach the origin.
  • If a particle is released at z0>zez_0 > z_ez0​>ze​, the force is initially towards the origin. The particle will oscillate. It can reach the origin z=0 only if its total energy E=U(z0)E = U(z_0)E=U(z0​) is greater than or equal to the potential at the origin, U(0). The condition is U(z0)≥U(0)U(z_0) \ge U(0)U(z0​)≥U(0). U0[R2+z02+(β−1)z0]≥U0RU_0 \left[ \sqrt{R^2+z_0^2} + (\beta-1)z_0 \right] \ge U_0 RU0​[R2+z02​​+(β−1)z0​]≥U0​R R2+z02≥R−(β−1)z0=R+(1−β)z0\sqrt{R^2+z_0^2} \ge R - (\beta-1)z_0 = R+(1-\beta)z_0R2+z02​​≥R−(β−1)z0​=R+(1−β)z0​ Squaring both sides (which are positive): R2+z02≥R2+2R(1−β)z0+(1−β)2z02R^2+z_0^2 \ge R^2 + 2R(1-\beta)z_0 + (1-\beta)^2 z_0^2R2+z02​≥R2+2R(1−β)z0​+(1−β)2z02​ z0≥2R(1−β)+(1−β)2z0z_0 \ge 2R(1-\beta) + (1-\beta)^2 z_0z0​≥2R(1−β)+(1−β)2z0​ z0(1−(1−β)2)≥2R(1−β)z_0(1 - (1-\beta)^2) \ge 2R(1-\beta)z0​(1−(1−β)2)≥2R(1−β) z0(2β−β2)≥2R(1−β)z_0(2\beta-\beta^2) \ge 2R(1-\beta)z0​(2β−β2)≥2R(1−β) z0≥2R(1−β)β(2−β)z_0 \ge \frac{2R(1-\beta)}{\beta(2-\beta)}z0​≥β(2−β)2R(1−β)​ This critical value of z0z_0z0​ can be shown to be greater than zez_eze​. So, this is the sole condition for reaching the origin when 0<β<10 < \beta < 10<β<1.

Step 4: Evaluate the Options

A: For β=14\beta=\frac{1}{4}β=41​ and z0=257Rz_{0}=\frac{25}{7} Rz0​=725​R, the particle reaches the origin. This is Case 2. We check the condition z0≥2R(1−β)β(2−β)z_0 \ge \frac{2R(1-\beta)}{\beta(2-\beta)}z0​≥β(2−β)2R(1−β)​. 1−β=1−1/4=3/41-\beta = 1 - 1/4 = 3/41−β=1−1/4=3/4 2−β=2−1/4=7/42-\beta = 2 - 1/4 = 7/42−β=2−1/4=7/4 β(2−β)=(1/4)(7/4)=7/16\beta(2-\beta) = (1/4)(7/4) = 7/16β(2−β)=(1/4)(7/4)=7/16 The critical distance is zc=2R(3/4)7/16=3R/27/16=3R2×167=24R7z_c = \frac{2R(3/4)}{7/16} = \frac{3R/2}{7/16} = \frac{3R}{2} \times \frac{16}{7} = \frac{24R}{7}zc​=7/162R(3/4)​=7/163R/2​=23R​×716​=724R​. The condition is z0≥24R7z_0 \ge \frac{24R}{7}z0​≥724R​. Given z0=25R7z_0 = \frac{25R}{7}z0​=725R​, which satisfies the condition. So, statement A is correct.

B: For β=14\beta=\frac{1}{4}β=41​ and z0=37Rz_{0}=\frac{3}{7} Rz0​=73​R, the particle reaches the origin. The critical distance is zc=24R7z_c = \frac{24R}{7}zc​=724R​. Given z0=3R7z_0 = \frac{3R}{7}z0​=73R​. This does not satisfy z0≥zcz_0 \ge z_cz0​≥zc​. So, statement B is incorrect.

C: For β=14\beta=\frac{1}{4}β=41​ and z0=R3z_{0}=\frac{R}{\sqrt{3}}z0​=3​R​, the particle returns back to z=z0z=z_{0}z=z0​. For β=1/4\beta = 1/4β=1/4, we are in Case 2, where the potential U(z) has a minimum, forming a potential well. The particle is released from rest at z0z_0z0​. This point z0z_0z0​ is a turning point of its motion. Since the motion is conservative and bounded (U(z)→∞U(z) \to \inftyU(z)→∞ as z→∞z \to \inftyz→∞), the particle will oscillate within the potential well and will periodically return to its starting point z0z_0z0​. We should check if z0z_0z0​ is the equilibrium point itself. The equilibrium ze=R1−ββ(2−β)=R3/47/16=3R7z_e = R \frac{1-\beta}{\sqrt{\beta(2-\beta)}} = R \frac{3/4}{\sqrt{7/16}} = \frac{3R}{\sqrt{7}}ze​=Rβ(2−β)​1−β​=R7/16​3/4​=7​3R​. Since z0=R/3≠zez_0 = R/\sqrt{3} \ne z_ez0​=R/3​=ze​, the particle will not remain at rest, it will oscillate. So, statement C is correct.

D: For β>1\beta> 1β>1 and z0>0z_{0}> 0z0​>0, the particle always reaches the origin. This corresponds to our analysis of Case 1. The force on the particle is always directed towards the origin. Therefore, if released from rest at any z0>0z_0 > 0z0​>0, it will accelerate towards and reach the origin. So, statement D is correct.

PreviousNext

More from Electrostatics

  • Two point charges − Q and +Q/3​ are placed in the xy-plane at the origin (0, 0) and a point (2, 0), respectively, as shown in the figure. This results in an equipotential circle of radius R and potential V = 0 in the xy-plane with… Includes diagram2021 · Numerical
  • Two point charges − Q and +Q/3​ are placed in the xy-plane at the origin (0, 0) and a point (2, 0), respectively, as shown in the figure. This results in an equipotential circle of radius R and potential V = 0 in the xy-plane with… Includes diagram2021 · Numerical
  • A circular disc of radius R carries surface charge density σ(r)=σ0​(1−Rr​), where σ 0 is a constant and r is the distance from the center of the disc. Electric flux through a…2020 · Numerical
  • One end of a spring of negligible unstretched length and spring constant k is fixed at the origin (0, 0). A point particle of mass m carrying a positive charge q is attached at its other end. The entire system is kept on a smooth… Includes diagram2020 · Numerical
  • A uniform electric field, E=−4003​y​ NC−1 is applied in a region. A charged particle of mass m carrying positive charge q is projected in this region with an initial speed of 2 10​× 106… Includes diagram2020 · Multiple correct
  • Two large circular discs separated by a distance of 0.01 m are connected to a battery via a switch as shown in the figure. Charged oil drops of density 900 kg m−3 are released through a tiny hole at the center of the top disc. Once some… Includes diagram2020 · Numerical
  • A point charge q of mass m is suspended vertically by a string of length l. A point dipole of dipole moment p​ is now brought towards q from infinity so that the charge moves away. The final equilibrium position of the… Includes diagram2020 · Numerical
  • Two identical non-conducting solid spheres of same mass and charge are suspended in air from a common point by two non-conducting, massless strings of same length. At equilibrium, the angle between the strings is α. The spheres are…2020 · Multiple correct