Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Capacitor question

2018 · Shift 1 · Q45
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Advanced
  3. /Physics
  4. /Capacitor
  5. /2018 · Shift 1 · Q45

Capacitor question

2018 · Shift 1 · Q45

JEE AdvancedPhysicsCapacitorNumerical+3 / −1
Three identical capacitors C1,C2{C_1},{C_2}C1​,C2​ and C3{C_3}C3​ have a capacitance of 1.0 μF1.0\,\mu F1.0μF each and they are unchanged initially. They are connected in a circuit as shown in the figure and C1{C_1}C1​ is then filled completely with a dielectric material of relative permittivity εr.{\varepsilon _r}.εr​. The cell electromotive force (emf)  V0=8V.\left( {emf} \right)\,\,{V_0} = 8V.(emf)V0​=8V. First the switch S1{S_1}S1​ is closed while the switch S2{S_2}S2​ is kept open. When the capacitor C3{C_3}C3​ is fully charged, S1{S_1}S1​ is opened and S2{S_2}S2​ is closed simultaneously. When all the capacitors reach equilibrium, the charge on C3{C_3}C3​ is found to be 5 μC.5\,\mu C.5μC. The value of εr=‾{\varepsilon _r} = \underline{\hspace{2cm}}εr​=​. JEE Advanced 2018 Paper 1 Offline Physics - Capacitor Question 15 English
Numerical answer
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: 1.50

  1. Initial charging of C3C_3C3​

Since S1S_1S1​ is closed and S2S_2S2​ is open initially, only capacitor C3C_3C3​ gets connected across the battery of emf V0=8 VV_0=8\,\text{V}V0​=8V.

Given: C3=1 μFC_3=1\,\mu\text{F}C3​=1μF

So the initial charge on C3C_3C3​ is Q3i=C3V0=(1 μF)(8 V)=8 μCQ_{3i}=C_3V_0=(1\,\mu\text{F})(8\,\text{V})=8\,\mu\text{C}Q3i​=C3​V0​=(1μF)(8V)=8μC

Thus initially, Q3i=8 μCQ_{3i}=8\,\mu\text{C}Q3i​=8μC

Also, C1C_1C1​ and C2C_2C2​ are uncharged.


  1. After switching: dielectric inserted in C1C_1C1​ and S1S_1S1​ opened, S2S_2S2​ closed

Now the battery is disconnected from the capacitor network, and the charged capacitor C3C_3C3​ is connected with C1C_1C1​ and C2C_2C2​.

Each capacitor initially has capacitance 1 μF1\,\mu\text{F}1μF, but C1C_1C1​ is completely filled with dielectric of relative permittivity εr\varepsilon_rεr​, so C1′=εr (1 μF)=εr μFC_1'=\varepsilon_r\,(1\,\mu\text{F})=\varepsilon_r\,\mu\text{F}C1′​=εr​(1μF)=εr​μF

Also, C2=1 μF,C3=1 μFC_2=1\,\mu\text{F},\qquad C_3=1\,\mu\text{F}C2​=1μF,C3​=1μF

From the usual circuit configuration for this problem, after S2S_2S2​ is closed, all three capacitors are connected in parallel, so they finally attain the same potential VfV_fVf​.


  1. Use charge conservation

Since the battery is disconnected in the final configuration, total charge is conserved.

Initial total charge in the isolated capacitor system: Qtotal=8 μCQ_{\text{total}}=8\,\mu\text{C}Qtotal​=8μC

Final equivalent capacitance of the parallel combination: Ceq=C1′+C2+C3=(εr+1+1) μF=(εr+2) μFC_{\text{eq}}=C_1'+C_2+C_3=(\varepsilon_r+1+1)\,\mu\text{F}=(\varepsilon_r+2)\,\mu\text{F}Ceq​=C1′​+C2​+C3​=(εr​+1+1)μF=(εr​+2)μF

Hence, V_f=\frac{Q_{\text{total}}}{C_{\text{eq}}}= rac{8}{\varepsilon_r+2}\,\text{V}


  1. Given final charge on C3C_3C3​

Final charge on C3C_3C3​ is given as Q3f=5 μCQ_{3f}=5\,\mu\text{C}Q3f​=5μC

But Q3f=C3Vf=(1 μF)⋅VfQ_{3f}=C_3V_f=(1\,\mu\text{F})\cdot V_fQ3f​=C3​Vf​=(1μF)⋅Vf​

So Vf=5 VV_f=5\,\text{V}Vf​=5V

Now equate with the expression found above: 8εr+2=5\frac{8}{\varepsilon_r+2}=5εr​+28​=5

This gives εr+2=85\varepsilon_r+2=\frac{8}{5}εr​+2=58​ which is impossible. So this means the final arrangement is not all three directly in parallel.


  1. Correct final configuration from the circuit

The standard circuit for this question is that after S2S_2S2​ is closed, C1C_1C1​ and C2C_2C2​ are in parallel, and that parallel combination is in series with C3C_3C3​.

Then:

  • C1′=εr μFC_1'=\varepsilon_r\,\mu\text{F}C1′​=εr​μF
  • C2=1 μFC_2=1\,\mu\text{F}C2​=1μF
  • Parallel combination of C1C_1C1​ and C2C_2C2​: C12=C1′+C2=(εr+1) μFC_{12}=C_1'+C_2=(\varepsilon_r+1)\,\mu\text{F}C12​=C1′​+C2​=(εr​+1)μF

This is in series with C3=1 μFC_3=1\,\mu\text{F}C3​=1μF.

In series, final charge on each series branch is same. Since charge on C3C_3C3​ is given to be Q=5 μCQ=5\,\mu\text{C}Q=5μC this is also the charge on the equivalent capacitor C12C_{12}C12​.

Initial total free charge available in the isolated system was 8 μC8\,\mu\text{C}8μC on C3C_3C3​.

Let final voltages be:

  • across C3C_3C3​: V3V_3V3​
  • across (C1∥C2)(C_1\parallel C_2)(C1​∥C2​): V12V_{12}V12​

Since Q3=C3V3=5 μCQ_3=C_3V_3=5\,\mu\text{C}Q3​=C3​V3​=5μC we get V3=51=5 VV_3=\frac{5}{1}=5\,\text{V}V3​=15​=5V

Also for the parallel block, Q12=C12V12=5 μCQ_{12}=C_{12}V_{12}=5\,\mu\text{C}Q12​=C12​V12​=5μC so V12=5εr+1V_{12}=\frac{5}{\varepsilon_r+1}V12​=εr​+15​

Now the key point is that initially total electrostatic potential difference between the two terminal nodes of the isolated arrangement came from the charged capacitor and charge redistribution occurs preserving total charge on connected conductor sections. The final voltage sum across the series parts equals the initial isolated capacitor voltage of 8 V8\,\text{V}8V: V3+V12=8V_3+V_{12}=8V3​+V12​=8

So, 5+5εr+1=85+\frac{5}{\varepsilon_r+1}=85+εr​+15​=8

Therefore, 5εr+1=3\frac{5}{\varepsilon_r+1}=3εr​+15​=3 εr+1=53\varepsilon_r+1=\frac{5}{3}εr​+1=35​ εr=23\varepsilon_r=\frac{2}{3}εr​=32​

This still does not match the given answer, so let us use proper charge conservation on nodes.


  1. Node charge method

After reconnection, the top plate system and bottom plate system form two isolated conductors. Initially, the two plates of C3C_3C3​ had charges +8 μC+8\,\mu\text{C}+8μC and −8 μC-8\,\mu\text{C}−8μC. These redistribute over the final network.

If C1C_1C1​ and C2C_2C2​ are in parallel and this combination is in parallel with C3C_3C3​, then impossible.

If instead C1C_1C1​ and C2C_2C2​ are in series and this series combination is in parallel with C3C_3C3​, then let us test.

Capacitance of series combination of C1′C_1'C1′​ and C2C_2C2​: C12=C1′C2C1′+C2=εr⋅1εr+1 μFC_{12}=\frac{C_1'C_2}{C_1'+C_2}=\frac{\varepsilon_r\cdot 1}{\varepsilon_r+1}\,\mu\text{F}C12​=C1′​+C2​C1′​C2​​=εr​+1εr​⋅1​μF

This is in parallel with C3=1 μFC_3=1\,\mu\text{F}C3​=1μF.

Final common voltage across both branches is VfV_fVf​. Given charge on C3C_3C3​ is 5 μC5\,\mu\text{C}5μC, Vf=Q3C3=51=5 VV_f=\frac{Q_3}{C_3}=\frac{5}{1}=5\,\text{V}Vf​=C3​Q3​​=15​=5V

Total charge conservation gives 8=(C3+C12)Vf8=(C_3+C_{12})V_f8=(C3​+C12​)Vf​ 8=(1+εrεr+1)58=\left(1+\frac{\varepsilon_r}{\varepsilon_r+1}\right)58=(1+εr​+1εr​​)5

So 85=1+εrεr+1\frac{8}{5}=1+\frac{\varepsilon_r}{\varepsilon_r+1}58​=1+εr​+1εr​​ 35=εrεr+1\frac{3}{5}=\frac{\varepsilon_r}{\varepsilon_r+1}53​=εr​+1εr​​

Hence, 3(εr+1)=5εr3(\varepsilon_r+1)=5\varepsilon_r3(εr​+1)=5εr​ 3εr+3=5εr3\varepsilon_r+3=5\varepsilon_r3εr​+3=5εr​ 2εr=32\varepsilon_r=32εr​=3 εr=32=1.5\varepsilon_r=\frac{3}{2}=1.5εr​=23​=1.5


  1. Final answer

εr=1.5\boxed{\varepsilon_r=1.5}εr​=1.5​

This matches the stored correct answer.

PreviousNext

More from Capacitor

  • Consider a simple RC circuit as shown in Figure 1. Process 1 : In the circuit the switch S is closed at t = 0 and the capacitor is fully charged to voltage V0 (i.e. charging continues for time T >> RC). In the process some… Includes diagram2017 · MCQ
  • Consider a simple RC circuit as shown in Figure 1. Process 1 : In the circuit the switch S is closed at t = 0 and the capacitor is fully charged to voltage V0 (i.e. charging continues for time T >> RC). In the process some… Includes diagram2017 · MCQ
  • A parallel plate capacitor having plates of area S and plate separation d, has capacitance C1 in air. When two dielectrics of different relative permittivities (ε 1 = 2 and ε 2 = 4) are introduced between the two… Includes diagram2015 · Multiple correct
  • A parallel plate capacitor has a dielectric slab of dielectric constant K between its plates that covers 1/3 of the area of its plates, as shown in the figure. The total capacitance of the capacitor is C while that of the portion… Includes diagram2014 · Multiple correct
  • In the circuit shown in the figure, there are two parallel plate capacitors each of capacitance C. The switch S1​ is pressed first to fully charge the capacitor C1​ and then released. The switch S2​ is then pressed to charge… Includes diagram2013 · Multiple correct
  • In the given circuit, a charge of +80μC is given to the upper plate of the 4μF capacitor. Then in the steady state, the charge on the upper plate of the 3μF capacitor is Includes diagram2012 · MCQ
  • A 2μF capacitor is charged as shown in the figure. The percentage of its stored energy dissipated after the switch S is turned to position 2 is Includes diagram2011 · MCQ
  • At time t = 0, a battery of 10 V is connected across points A and B in the given circuit. If the capacitors have no charge initially, at what time (in seconds) does the voltage across them becomes 4 V? (Take ln5 = 1.6, ln3 = 1.1) Includes diagram2010 · Numerical