Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Solid State question

2013 · Shift 1 · Q14
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Advanced
  3. /Chemistry
  4. /Solid State
  5. /2013 · Shift 1 · Q14

Solid State question

2013 · Shift 1 · Q14

JEE AdvancedChemistrySolid StateMCQ+3 / −1
The arrangement of X −-− ions around A+ ion in solid AX is given in the figure (not drawn to scale). If the radius of X −-− is 250 pm, the radius of A+ is JEE Advanced 2013 Paper 1 Offline Chemistry - Solid State Question 12 English
  1. A
    104 pm
  2. B
    125 pm
  3. C
    183 pm
  4. D
    57 pm
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: A

Step-by-step Derivation:

  1. Analyze the Given Arrangement: The figure shows a central cation A⁺ surrounded by six anions X⁻. This is a classic example of an octahedral coordination geometry, where the cation occupies an octahedral void formed by the anions.

  2. Identify the Geometric Condition: The figure depicts a situation where the anions (X⁻) are in contact with each other, and the central cation (A⁺) is just large enough to fit in the void and touch all the surrounding anions. This is the limiting condition for stable octahedral coordination.

  3. Set up the Geometric Model: Let's consider a 2D cross-section of the octahedron that passes through the center of the A⁺ ion and the centers of four coplanar X⁻ ions. In this plane:

    • The centers of the four X⁻ ions form a square.
    • The center of the A⁺ ion is at the center of this square.
    • Let rA+r_A⁺rA+​ be the radius of the cation A⁺ and rX−r_X⁻rX−​ be the radius of the anion X⁻.
  4. Relate Radii to Geometric Distances:

    • Since the adjacent anions X⁻ are touching, the distance between their centers is 2∗rX−2 * r_X⁻2∗rX−​. This distance is the side length of the square, let's call it s. So, s=2∗rX−s = 2 * r_X⁻s=2∗rX−​.
    • The cation A⁺ at the center touches the anions at the corners. The distance from the center of A⁺ to the center of any of these X⁻ ions is rA++rX−r_A⁺ + r_X⁻rA+​+rX−​.
    • In the square geometry, the distance from the center to a corner is half the length of the diagonal.
  5. Apply Pythagorean Theorem:

    • The length of the diagonal (d) of the square with side length s is given by d = s√2.
    • Substituting s=2∗rX−s = 2 * r_X⁻s=2∗rX−​, we get d=(2∗rX−)√2=2√2∗rX−d = (2 * r_X⁻)√2 = 2√2 * r_X⁻d=(2∗rX−​)√2=2√2∗rX−​.
    • The distance from the center to a corner is d/2, which is (2√2∗rX−)/2=√2∗rX−(2√2 * r_X⁻) / 2 = √2 * r_X⁻(2√2∗rX−​)/2=√2∗rX−​.
  6. Formulate and Solve the Equation:

    • We now have two expressions for the distance between the center of A⁺ and the center of X⁻:
      • From sum of radii: rA++rX−r_A⁺ + r_X⁻rA+​+rX−​
      • From geometry: √2∗rX−√2 * r_X⁻√2∗rX−​
    • Equating these two expressions: rA++rX−=2⋅rX−r_A⁺ + r_X⁻ = \sqrt{2} \cdot r_X⁻rA+​+rX−​=2​⋅rX−​
    • Solving for rA+r_A⁺rA+​: rA+=2⋅rX−−rX−r_A⁺ = \sqrt{2} \cdot r_X⁻ - r_X⁻rA+​=2​⋅rX−​−rX−​ rA+=(2−1)⋅rX−r_A⁺ = (\sqrt{2} - 1) \cdot r_X⁻rA+​=(2​−1)⋅rX−​ This equation relates the cation radius to the anion radius for the limiting case of octahedral coordination. The ratio rA+/rX−=√2−1≈0.414r_A⁺ / r_X⁻ = √2 - 1 ≈ 0.414rA+​/rX−​=√2−1≈0.414 is the minimum radius ratio for stable octahedral coordination.
  7. Calculate the Numerical Value:

    • We are given rX−=250r_X⁻ = 250rX−​=250 pm.
    • Using the value √2 ≈ 1.414: rA+=(1.414−1)×250 pmr_A⁺ = (1.414 - 1) \times 250 \text{ pm}rA+​=(1.414−1)×250 pm rA+=0.414×250 pmr_A⁺ = 0.414 \times 250 \text{ pm}rA+​=0.414×250 pm rA+=103.5 pmr_A⁺ = 103.5 \text{ pm}rA+​=103.5 pm
  8. Compare with Options:

    • The calculated value is 103.5 pm.
    • Looking at the options: A: 104 pm B: 125 pm C: 183 pm D: 57 pm
    • The closest option to our calculated value is 104 pm.

Conclusion:

Based on the geometric derivation for the limiting radius ratio in an octahedral void, the radius of the cation A⁺ is calculated to be 103.5 pm, which corresponds to option A.

PreviousNext

More from Solid State

  • A compound MpXq has cubic close packing (ccp) arrangement of X. Its unit cell structure is shown below. The empirical formula of the compound is Includes diagram2012 · MCQ
  • The number of hexagonal faces that are present in a truncated octahedron is ​.2011 · Numerical
  • The packing efficiency of the twodimensional square unit cell shown below is Includes diagram2010 · MCQ
  • The correct statement(s) regarding defects in solids is (are)2009 · Multiple correct
  • The coordination number of Al in the crystalline state of AlCl 3​ is ​.2009 · Numerical
  • In hexagonal systems of crystals, a frequently encountered arrangement of atoms is described as a hexagonal prism. Here, the top and bottom of the cell are regular hexagons and three atoms are sandwiched in between them. A space-filling…2008 · MCQ
  • In hexagonal systems of crystals, a frequently encountered arrangement of atoms is described as a hexagonal prism. Here, the top and bottom of the cell are regular hexagons and three atoms are sandwiched in between them. A space-filling…2008 · MCQ
  • In hexagonal systems of crystals, a frequently encountered arrangement of atoms is described as a hexagonal prism. Here, the top and bottom of the cell are regular hexagons and three atoms are sandwiched in between them. A space-filling…2008 · MCQ