Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Simple Harmonic Motion question

2018 · 16 Apr · Shift 1 · Q63
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Main
  3. /Physics
  4. /Simple Harmonic Motion
  5. /2018 · 16 Apr · Shift 1 · Q63

Simple Harmonic Motion question

2018 · 16 Apr · Shift 1 · Q63

JEE MainPhysicsSimple Harmonic MotionMCQ+4 / −1
An oscillator of mass M is at rest in its equilibrium position in a potential V = 12{1 \over 2}21​ k(x −-− X)2. A particle of mass m comes from right with speed u and collides completely inelastically with M and sticks to it. This process repeats every time the oscillator crosses its equilibrium position. The amplitude of oscillations after 13 collisions is : (M = 10, m = 5, u = 1, k = 1)
  1. A
    13{1 \over {\sqrt 3 }}3​1​
  2. B
    12{1 \over 2}21​
  3. C
    23{2 \over 3}32​
  4. D
    35{3 \over {\sqrt 5 }}5​3​
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: 0

  1. Set up the situation

The oscillator of mass MMM moves in the potential V=12k(x−X)2,V=\frac12 k(x-X)^2,V=21​k(x−X)2, so its equilibrium position is at x=Xx=Xx=X.

Each time it crosses equilibrium, a particle of mass mmm comes from the right with speed uuu and sticks to it completely inelastically.

Given: M=10,m=5,u=1,k=1.M=10,\quad m=5,\quad u=1,\quad k=1.M=10,m=5,u=1,k=1.

Initially, the oscillator is at rest at equilibrium.


  1. First collision

Initially, mass MMM is at rest. A particle of mass mmm with velocity −u-u−u (coming from the right toward the left) collides and sticks.

By conservation of momentum: m(−u)+M(0)=(M+m)v1m(-u)+M(0)=(M+m)v_1m(−u)+M(0)=(M+m)v1​ v1=−muM+m=−5⋅110+5=−13.v_1=-\frac{mu}{M+m}=-\frac{5\cdot 1}{10+5}=-\frac13.v1​=−M+mmu​=−10+55⋅1​=−31​.

So just after the first collision, the combined mass is M1=M+m=15,M_1=M+m=15,M1​=M+m=15, and it is at equilibrium with speed magnitude 13\frac1331​.

For SHM, if a particle starts from equilibrium with speed vvv, then amplitude is A=vω,ω=kM1.A=\frac{v}{\omega},\qquad \omega=\sqrt{\frac{k}{M_1}}.A=ωv​,ω=M1​k​​.

Thus A1=1/31/15=153=53.A_1=\frac{1/3}{\sqrt{1/15}}=\frac{\sqrt{15}}{3}=\sqrt{\frac53}.A1​=1/15​1/3​=315​​=35​​.

This is not yet one of the options, so clearly the process of repeated collisions matters.


  1. Velocity when it returns to equilibrium

After half a cycle, the mass 151515 returns to equilibrium from the left toward the right with the same speed magnitude: v=+13.v=+\frac13.v=+31​.

At that instant, another particle of mass m=5m=5m=5 comes from the right with velocity −1-1−1 and sticks.


  1. Recurrence relation for velocity after each collision

Let Mn=M+nmM_n=M+n mMn​=M+nm be the total mass after the nnn-th collision, and let vnv_nvn​ be the velocity just after the nnn-th collision.

Before the (n+1)(n+1)(n+1)-th collision, the oscillator crosses equilibrium with velocity −vn-v_n−vn​ or +vn+v_n+vn​ depending on phase. Since the incoming particle always comes from the right, the sign alternates. It is more convenient to track the speed magnitude.

Let sn=∣vn∣s_n=|v_n|sn​=∣vn​∣.

At each equilibrium crossing, just before the next collision the oscillator speed magnitude is still sns_nsn​.

Now momentum conservation at the next collision gives: Mn(±sn)+m(−u)=Mn+1vn+1.M_n(\pm s_n)+m(-u)=M_{n+1}v_{n+1}.Mn​(±sn​)+m(−u)=Mn+1​vn+1​.

Because the direction alternates, one finds that after every collision the motion continues toward the left/right alternately, but the speed magnitude satisfies the simple relation sn+1=∣Mnsn−muMn+m∣.s_{n+1}=\left|\frac{M_n s_n-mu}{M_n+m}\right|.sn+1​=​Mn​+mMn​sn​−mu​​.

Let us compute explicitly from the actual sequence.


  1. Compute successive collisions

After 1st collision

M1=15,v1=−13.M_1=15,\qquad v_1=-\frac13.M1​=15,v1​=−31​.

Just before 2nd collision

At equilibrium again, v=+13.v=+\frac13.v=+31​.

Second collision: 15(13)+5(−1)=20v215\left(\frac13\right)+5(-1)=20v_215(31​)+5(−1)=20v2​ 5−5=20v25-5=20v_25−5=20v2​ v2=0.v_2=0.v2​=0.

This is the key point: after the second collision, the system comes to rest exactly at equilibrium.

Therefore amplitude after the second collision is A2=0.A_2=0.A2​=0.


  1. What happens afterwards?

Since after the second collision the oscillator is at rest at equilibrium, it will not move again.

Hence it will never cross the equilibrium position again on its own, so no further collisions can occur dynamically.

Thus the amplitude remains A=0.A=0.A=0.

So after 13 collisions, the physical outcome implied by the given data is still A=0.A=0.A=0.


  1. Check against options

The computed amplitude is 0,0,0, which is not present among the options.

Therefore the stored answer A=13\text{A} = \frac{1}{\sqrt3}A=3​1​ does not agree with the mechanics of the stated problem.

It appears there is likely an error in the question/options or in the stored answer.

PreviousNext

More from Simple Harmonic Motion

  • A silver atom in a solid oscillates in simple harmonic motion in some direction with a frequency of 1012/sec. What is the force constant of the bonds connecting one atom with the other? (Mole wt. of silver = 108 and Avogadro number = 6.02…2018 · MCQ
  • The ratio of maximum acceleration to maximum velocity in a simple harmonic motion is 10 s−1 . At, t = 0 the displacement is 5 m. What is the maximum acceleration ? The initial phase is 4π​.2017 · MCQ
  • A 1 kg block attached to a spring vibrates with a frequency of 1 Hz on a frictionless horizontal table. Two springs identical to the original spring are attached in parallel to an 8 kg block placed on the same table. So, the frequency of…2017 · MCQ
  • A particle is executing simple harmonic motion with a time period T. At time t = 0, it is at its position of equilibrium. The kinetic energy – time graph of the particle will look like:2017 · MCQ
  • Two particles are performing simple harmonic motion in a straight line about the same equilibrium point. The amplitude and time period for both particles are same and equal to A and I, respectively. At time t = 0 one particle has…2016 · MCQ
  • In an engine the piston undergoes vertical simple harmonic motion with amplitude 7 cm. A washer rests on top of the piston and moves with it. The motor speed is slowly increased. The frequency of the piston at which the washer no longer…2016 · MCQ
  • A particle performs simple harmonic motion with amplitude A. Its speed is trebled at the instant that it is at a distance 32A​ from equilibrium position. The new amplitude of the motion is:2016 · MCQ
  • For a simple pendulum, a graph is plotted between its kinetic energy (KE) and potential energy (PE) against its displacement d. Which one of the following represents these correctly? (graphsareschematicandnotdrawntoscale)2015 · MCQ