- ABoth and are true but is NOT the correct explanation of
- Bis false but is true
- Cis true but is false
- DBoth and are true and is the correct explanation of
View written solutionFree
Correct answer: NO VALID OPTION AMONG A, B, C, D. PHYSICALLY, BOTH ASSERTION A AND REASON R ARE FALSE.
- Formula for radius of curvature in a magnetic field
When a charged particle enters a uniform magnetic field perpendicular to it, the magnetic force provides the centripetal force:
So,
where is the linear momentum.
Thus, for particles entering with equal momentum in the same magnetic field,
The curvature is inversely proportional to radius, so smaller radius means greater curvature.
- Check Assertion A
Assertion A: If and enter normal to the magnetic field with equal momentum, then the path of ion has a smaller curvature than that of .
For :
For :
Using
with equal and same ,
Hence,
So has smaller radius, therefore greater curvature, not smaller curvature.
Hence, Assertion A is false.
- Check Reason R
Reason R: A proton with same linear momentum as an electron will form a path of smaller radius of curvature on entering a uniform magnetic field perpendicularly.
For proton and electron with same momentum in same magnetic field:
- proton charge magnitude
- electron charge magnitude
Therefore,
for both.
So both have same radius of curvature (though they bend in opposite directions because charges are opposite).
Thus the statement that proton forms a path of smaller radius is false.
Hence, Reason R is false.
- Conclusion
- Assertion A: False
- Reason R: False
So the correct logical outcome should be: Both A and R are false.
But none of the given options states this.
- Comparison with stored answer
Stored correct answer: C
Option C says: A is true but R is false.
This does not match the physics result. Assertion A is false, not true.
Therefore, I disagree with the stored answer.
More from Magnetics
- If an optical medium possesses a relative permeability of and relative permittivity of , then the velocity of light is greater in vacuum than that in this medium by times. …2025 · Numerical
- A particle of charge , mass and kinetic energy enters in magnetic field perpendicular to its velocity and undergoes a circular arc of radius (r). Which of the following curves represents the variation of with ?2025 · MCQ
- Uniform magnetic fields of different strengths and , both normal to the plane of the paper exist as shown in the figure. A charged particle of mass and charge , at the interface at an instant,… Includes diagram2025 · MCQ
- Figure shows a current carrying square loop ABCD of edge length is ‘a’ lying in a plane. If the resistance of the ABC part is r and that of ADC part is 2r, then the magnitude of the resultant magnetic field at centre of the square loop is Includes diagram2025 · MCQ
- An electron projected perpendicular to a uniform magnetic field B moves in a circle. If Bohr's quantization is applicable, then the radius of the electronic orbit in the first excited state is :2025 · MCQ
- A proton is moving undeflected in a region of crossed electric and magnetic fields at a constant speed of . When the electric field is switched off, the proton moves along a circular path of radius 2 cm .…2025 · Numerical
- Two long parallel wires and , separated by a distance of 6 cm , carry currents of 5 A and 4A, respectively, in opposite directions as shown in the figure. Magnitude of the resultant magnetic field at point P at a distance of 4 cm… Includes diagram2025 · Numerical
- A current of 5 A exists in a square loop of side . Then the magnitude of the magnetic field at the centre of the square loop will be . where, value of p is …2025 · Numerical