Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Electrostatics question

2021 · 25 Jul · Shift 1 · Q68
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Main
  3. /Physics
  4. /Electrostatics
  5. /2021 · 25 Jul · Shift 1 · Q68

Electrostatics question

2021 · 25 Jul · Shift 1 · Q68

JEE MainPhysicsElectrostaticsNumerical+4 / −1
A particle of mass 1 mg and charge q is lying at the mid-point of two stationary particles kept at a distance '2 m' when each is carrying same charge 'q'. If the free charged particle is displaced from its equilibrium position through distance 'x' (x < < 1 m). The particle executes SHM. Its angular frequency of oscillation will be ‾×\underline{\hspace{2cm}}\times​× 105 rad/s if q2 = 10 C2.
Numerical answer
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: 6000

  1. Set up the configuration

Two fixed particles, each carrying charge qqq, are placed symmetrically at distance 2 m2\,\text{m}2m apart. So the midpoint is 1 m1\,\text{m}1m from each fixed charge.

A third particle of mass m=1 mgm=1\,\text{mg}m=1mg and charge qqq is placed at the midpoint.

Given: m=1 mg=10−6 kg,q2=10 C2m=1\,\text{mg}=10^{-6}\,\text{kg}, \qquad q^2=10\,\text{C}^2m=1mg=10−6kg,q2=10C2

Let the middle particle be displaced by a small distance xxx along the line joining the two fixed charges, where x≪1 mx\ll 1\,\text{m}x≪1m.


  1. Write the electrostatic forces

After displacement, its distances from the two fixed charges become: 1−xand1+x1-x \quad \text{and} \quad 1+x1−xand1+x

Since all charges are same, the forces are repulsive.

  • Force due to left charge (towards right): F1=kq2(1−x)2F_1 = k\frac{q^2}{(1-x)^2}F1​=k(1−x)2q2​

  • Force due to right charge (towards left): F2=kq2(1+x)2F_2 = k\frac{q^2}{(1+x)^2}F2​=k(1+x)2q2​

Net force on the particle: F=kq2[1(1−x)2−1(1+x)2]F = kq^2\left[\frac{1}{(1-x)^2}-\frac{1}{(1+x)^2}\right]F=kq2[(1−x)21​−(1+x)21​] But this force is away from the midpoint for same-sign charges, so equilibrium is unstable along the line. For SHM, the intended small oscillation must be for displacement perpendicular to the line joining the charges. So we now analyze the physically correct SHM direction.


  1. Displacement perpendicular to the line joining charges

Let the particle be displaced by a small distance xxx perpendicular to the line of centers.

Distance from each fixed charge becomes: r=1+x2r=\sqrt{1+x^2}r=1+x2​

Force due to each charge: F0=kq2r2=kq21+x2F_0 = k\frac{q^2}{r^2}=k\frac{q^2}{1+x^2}F0​=kr2q2​=k1+x2q2​

Its vertical component is: F0y=F0xr=kq2x(1+x2)3/2F_{0y}=F_0\frac{x}{r}=k\frac{q^2 x}{(1+x^2)^{3/2}}F0y​=F0​rx​=k(1+x2)3/2q2x​

Both charges contribute equally, so total force is: Fy=2kq2x(1+x2)3/2F_y = 2k\frac{q^2 x}{(1+x^2)^{3/2}}Fy​=2k(1+x2)3/2q2x​ This is directed away from the midpoint for same-sign charges, again unstable.

Thus, for SHM to occur, the middle charge must be of opposite sign to the fixed charges (standard intended interpretation), giving restoring force: Fy=−2kq2x(1+x2)3/2F_y = -2k\frac{q^2 x}{(1+x^2)^{3/2}}Fy​=−2k(1+x2)3/2q2x​

For small xxx, (1+x2)−3/2≈1(1+x^2)^{-3/2} \approx 1(1+x2)−3/2≈1 So, Fy≈−2kq2xF_y \approx -2kq^2 xFy​≈−2kq2x

Comparing with SHM form: F=−mω2xF=-m\omega^2 xF=−mω2x we get mω2=2kq2m\omega^2 = 2kq^2mω2=2kq2

Hence, ω=2kq2m\omega = \sqrt{\frac{2kq^2}{m}}ω=m2kq2​​


  1. Substitute values

Using: k=9×109 N m2/C2,q2=10−10 C2,m=10−6 kgk=9\times 10^9\,\text{N m}^2/\text{C}^2, \quad q^2=10^{-10}\,\text{C}^2, \quad m=10^{-6}\,\text{kg}k=9×109N m2/C2,q2=10−10C2,m=10−6kg

Then, ω=2×9×109×10−1010−6\omega = \sqrt{\frac{2\times 9\times 10^9\times 10^{-10}}{10^{-6}}}ω=10−62×9×109×10−10​​

ω=18×10−110−6\omega = \sqrt{\frac{18\times 10^{-1}}{10^{-6}}}ω=10−618×10−1​​

ω=1.8×106\omega = \sqrt{1.8\times 10^6}ω=1.8×106​

ω≈1.34×103 rad/s\omega \approx 1.34\times 10^3\,\text{rad/s}ω≈1.34×103rad/s

This does not match the answer format unless the printed quantity is interpreted as: q2=10−8 C2q^2=10^{-8}\,\text{C}^2q2=10−8C2

Then, ω=2×9×109×10−810−6\omega = \sqrt{\frac{2\times 9\times 10^9\times 10^{-8}}{10^{-6}}}ω=10−62×9×109×10−8​​ = \sqrt{18\times 10^7} \approx 4.24\times 10^4,\text{rad/s}$$

Still not matching.

If instead the intended motion is along the line and opposite-sign charges are assumed, then F=kq2[1(1+x)2−1(1−x)2]F = kq^2\left[\frac{1}{(1+x)^2}-\frac{1}{(1-x)^2}\right]F=kq2[(1+x)21​−(1−x)21​] For small xxx, 1(1+x)2≈1−2x,1(1−x)2≈1+2x\frac{1}{(1+x)^2}\approx 1-2x, \qquad \frac{1}{(1-x)^2}\approx 1+2x(1+x)21​≈1−2x,(1−x)21​≈1+2x

So, F≈kq2[(1−2x)−(1+2x)]=−4kq2xF \approx kq^2[(1-2x)-(1+2x)] = -4kq^2xF≈kq2[(1−2x)−(1+2x)]=−4kq2x

Thus, mω2=4kq2m\omega^2 = 4kq^2mω2=4kq2 ω=4kq2m\omega = \sqrt{\frac{4kq^2}{m}}ω=m4kq2​​

Now using the likely intended value q2=10−10 C2q^2=10^{-10}\,\text{C}^2q2=10−10C2, ω=4×9×109×10−1010−6\omega = \sqrt{\frac{4\times 9\times 10^9\times 10^{-10}}{10^{-6}}}ω=10−64×9×109×10−10​​ = \sqrt{3.6\times 10^6} \approx 1.9\times 10^3,\text{rad/s}$$

Again not matching 6000.


  1. Conclusion

The given statement has an internal inconsistency:

  • with all three charges same sign, midpoint equilibrium is not stable in the oscillation directions considered,
  • the provided numerical data/answer do not fit consistently.

The closest standard textbook result for small oscillation along the line with restoring force is: ω=4kq2m\omega = \sqrt{\frac{4kq^2}{m}}ω=m4kq2​​

Using the stored answer format "____×105\_\_\_\_ \times 10^5____×105 rad/s" and stored answer 600060006000, the implied angular frequency is: ω=6000×10−5=0.06 rad/s\omega = 6000\times 10^{-5} = 0.06\,\text{rad/s}ω=6000×10−5=0.06rad/s or possibly 6000×1056000\times 10^56000×105 depending on formatting, both of which are inconsistent with the physics/data.

Hence I do not agree with the stored correct answer.

PreviousNext

More from Electrostatics

  • Two ideal electric dipoles A and B, having their dipole moment p1 and p2 respectively are placed on a plane with their centres at O as shown in the figure. At point C on the axis of dipole A, the resultant electric field is making an angle… Includes diagram2021 · MCQ
  • A solid metal sphere of radius R having charge q is enclosed inside the concentric spherical shell of inner radius a and outer radius b as shown in the figure. The approximate variation electric field E as a function of… Includes diagram2021 · MCQ
  • The two thin coaxial rings, each of radius 'a' and having charges +Q and − Q respectively are separated by a distance of 's'. The potential difference between the centres of the two rings is :2021 · MCQ
  • Find the electric field at point P (as shown in figure) on the perpendicular bisector of a uniformly charged thin wire of length L carrying a charge Q. The distance of the point P from the centre of the rod is a = 23​​L. Includes diagram2021 · MCQ
  • Given below are two statements: Statement I : An electric dipole is placed at the center of a hollow sphere. The flux of the electric field through the sphere is zero but the electric field is not zero anywhere in the sphere. Statement II…2021 · MCQ
  • An inclined plane making an angle of 30 ∘ with the horizontal is placed in a uniform horizontal electric field 200CN​ as shown in the figure. A body of mass 1 kg and charge 5 mC is allowed to slide down from rest at a… Includes diagram2021 · MCQ
  • 27 similar drops of mercury are maintained at 10V each. All these spherical drops combine into a single big drop. The potential energy of the bigger drop is ​ times that of a smaller drop.2021 · Numerical
  • A uniformly charged disc of radius R having surface charge density σ is placed in the xy plane with its center at the origin. Find the electric field intensity along the z-axis at a distance Z from origin :-2021 · MCQ