Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Work Power and Energy question

2011 · Shift 2 · Q53
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Advanced
  3. /Physics
  4. /Work Power and Energy
  5. /2011 · Shift 2 · Q53

Work Power and Energy question

2011 · Shift 2 · Q53

JEE AdvancedPhysicsWork Power and EnergyMultiple correct+4 / −2
A thin ring of mass 2 kg and radius 0.5 m is rolling without on a horizontal plane with velocity 1 m/s. A small ball of mass 0.1 kg, moving with velocity 20 m/s in the opposite direction hits the ring at a height of 0.75 m and goes vertically up with velocity 10 m/s. Immediately after the collision, IIT-JEE 2011 Paper 2 Offline Physics - Work Power & Energy Question 7 English
  1. A
    the ring has pure rotation about its stationary CM.
  2. B
    the ring comes to a complete stop.
  3. C
    friction between the ring and the ground is to the left.
  4. D
    there is no friction between the ring and the ground.
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: A

  1. Initial data and setup
  • Ring mass: M=2 kgM=2\,\text{kg}M=2kg
  • Ring radius: R=0.5 mR=0.5\,\text{m}R=0.5m
  • Initial speed of ring: v=1 m s−1v=1\,\text{m s}^{-1}v=1m s−1
  • Since it is rolling without slipping, ω=vR=10.5=2 rad s−1\omega = \frac{v}{R} = \frac{1}{0.5}=2\,\text{rad s}^{-1}ω=Rv​=0.51​=2rad s−1

Take rightward as positive xxx.

The ring moves to the right, so its angular velocity is clockwise. I will take counterclockwise as positive, hence initially ωi=−2 rad s−1\omega_i=-2\,\text{rad s}^{-1}ωi​=−2rad s−1

For a thin ring, ICM=MR2=2(0.5)2=0.5 kg m2I_{\text{CM}}=MR^2=2(0.5)^2=0.5\,\text{kg m}^2ICM​=MR2=2(0.5)2=0.5kg m2

The ball has:

  • mass m=0.1 kgm=0.1\,\text{kg}m=0.1kg
  • initial velocity −20 m s−1-20\,\text{m s}^{-1}−20m s−1 (to the left)
  • final velocity vertically upward =10 m s−1=10\,\text{m s}^{-1}=10m s−1, so final horizontal velocity is 000.

The collision point is at height 0.75 m0.75\,\text{m}0.75m above ground. Since the ring center is at height R=0.5 mR=0.5\,\text{m}R=0.5m, the hit point is y=0.75−0.5=0.25 my=0.75-0.5=0.25\,\text{m}y=0.75−0.5=0.25m above the center.


  1. Horizontal impulse delivered by the ball to the ring

For the ball, horizontal momentum changes from px,i=0.1(−20)=−2p_{x,i}=0.1(-20)=-2px,i​=0.1(−20)=−2 to px,f=0p_{x,f}=0px,f​=0 So the change in horizontal momentum of the ball is Δpx=0−(−2)=+2 kg m s−1\Delta p_x=0-(-2)=+2\,\text{kg m s}^{-1}Δpx​=0−(−2)=+2kg m s−1

Thus the ring receives an equal and opposite horizontal impulse: J=−2 N sJ=-2\,\text{N s}J=−2N s (i.e. toward the left).

This changes the translational momentum of the ring: MVf=MVi+JM V_f = M V_i + JMVf​=MVi​+J 2Vf=2(1)−2=02V_f = 2(1) - 2 = 02Vf​=2(1)−2=0 Hence Vf=0V_f=0Vf​=0

So immediately after collision, the center of mass of the ring is momentarily at rest.

Therefore, option B (“the ring comes to a complete stop”) is false, because it may still rotate.


  1. Angular impulse about the center of the ring

The impulse acts horizontally leftward at height y=0.25 my=0.25\,\text{m}y=0.25m above the center.

Torque impulse about CM: ΔLCM=r⃗×J⃗\Delta L_{\text{CM}} = \vec r \times \vec JΔLCM​=r×J Here, r⃗=(0,0.25),J⃗=(−2,0)\vec r=(0,0.25), \quad \vec J=(-2,0)r=(0,0.25),J=(−2,0) So, ΔLz=xJy−yJx=0−(0.25)(−2)=+0.5 kg m2/s\Delta L_z = xJ_y - yJ_x = 0 - (0.25)(-2)=+0.5\,\text{kg m}^2\text{/s}ΔLz​=xJy​−yJx​=0−(0.25)(−2)=+0.5kg m2/s This is positive, i.e. counterclockwise.

Initial angular momentum of ring about CM: Li=Iωi=0.5(−2)=−1 kg m2/sL_i = I\omega_i = 0.5(-2)=-1\,\text{kg m}^2\text{/s}Li​=Iωi​=0.5(−2)=−1kg m2/s

Thus final angular momentum: Lf=Li+ΔL=−1+0.5=−0.5 kg m2/sL_f = L_i + \Delta L = -1 + 0.5 = -0.5\,\text{kg m}^2\text{/s}Lf​=Li​+ΔL=−1+0.5=−0.5kg m2/s So ωf=LfI=−0.50.5=−1 rad s−1\omega_f = \frac{L_f}{I} = \frac{-0.5}{0.5}=-1\,\text{rad s}^{-1}ωf​=ILf​​=0.5−0.5​=−1rad s−1

Hence after collision the ring is still rotating clockwise with angular speed 1 rad s−11\,\text{rad s}^{-1}1rad s−1, while its CM is stationary.

Therefore option A is true: the ring has pure rotation about its stationary CM.


  1. Direction of friction just after collision

Immediately after collision:

  • VCM=0V_{\text{CM}}=0VCM​=0
  • ω=−1 rad s−1\omega=-1\,\text{rad s}^{-1}ω=−1rad s−1 (clockwise)

For pure rotation with clockwise angular velocity, the bottom point of the ring tends to move left relative to the center. Since the center is stationary, the point in contact tends to slip left relative to ground.

Friction opposes this tendency, so friction on the ring must act to the right, not to the left.

Hence option C is false.

Since there is a tendency to slip, friction is not zero. So option D is also false.


  1. Final evaluation of options
  • A: True
  • B: False
  • C: False
  • D: False

So the correct answer is: A\boxed{A}A​


  1. Comparison with stored answer

Stored correct answer: A, C

My derived answer is A only.

Reason for disagreement: after collision the ring has VCM=0V_{\text{CM}}=0VCM​=0 and clockwise rotation. The bottom point therefore tends to move left relative to ground, so friction on the ring must act to the right, not left. Hence option C should be false.

PreviousNext

More from Work Power and Energy

  • A block of mass 2 kg is free to move along the x-axis. It is at rest and from t = 0 onwards, it is subjected to a time-dependent force F(t) in the x-direction. The force F(t) varies with t as shown in the figure. The kinetic energy of the… Includes diagram2010 · MCQ
  • A light inextensible string that goes over a smooth fixed pulley as shown in the figure connects two blocks of masses 0.36 kg and 0.72 kg. Taking g = 10 m/s2, find the work done (in joules) by the string on the block of mass 0.36 kg during… Includes diagram2009 · Numerical
  • Three objects A, B and C are kept in a straight line on a frictionless horizontal surface. These have masses m, 2m and m, respectively. The object A moves towards B with a speed 9 m/s and makes an elastic collision with it. Thereafter, B…2009 · Numerical
  • A block (B) is attached to two unstretched springs S1 and S2 with spring constants k and 4k respectively (see figure I). The other ends are attached to identical supports M1 and M2 not attached to the walls. The springs and supports have… Includes diagram2008 · MCQ
  • A bob of mass M is suspended by a massless string of length L. The horizontal velocity V at position A is just sufficient to make it reach the point B. The angle θ at which the speed of the bob is half of that at A, satisfies, Includes diagram2008 · MCQ
  • Statement 1 : A block of mass m starts moving on a rough horizontal surface with a velocity v. It stops due to friction between the block and the surface after moving through a certain distance. The surface is now tilted to an angle of 30 ∘…2007 · MCQ
  • A student skates up a ramp that makes an angle 30 ∘ with the horizontal. He/she starts (as shown in the figure) at the bottom of the ramp with speed v0 and wants to turn around over a semicircular path xyz of radius R during which… Includes diagram2020 · Multiple correct
  • A particle is moved along a path AB-BC-CD-DE-EF-FA, as shown in figure, in presence of a force F=(αyi+2αxj​) N, where x and y are in meter and α=− 1 Nm-1. The work done on the particle by this… Includes diagram2019 · Numerical