
- AP lands in the shaded region and Q in the unshaded region.
- BP lands in the unshaded region and Q in the shaded region.
- CBoth P and Q land in the unshaded region.
- DBoth P and Q land in the shaded region.
View written solutionFree
Correct answer: C
-
Key idea: work in the inertial frame
The disc rotates with constant angular speed about the vertical axis through .
Both pebbles are thrown with the same velocity relative to the disc, and this velocity lies in the - plane.Since the velocity relative to the disc has no -component, the actual initial velocity in the ground frame is: where is the initial position of the pebble on the disc.
-
Choose coordinates
Let the disc lie in the - plane and let be vertically upward.
At the shown instant, pebbles and are on opposite sides of the centre along a diameter, so their position vectors are opposite.Suppose: where (consistent with the range condition).
Let angular velocity be:
The velocity given relative to the disc is in the - plane, so write it as: for both pebbles.
-
Initial velocities in the inertial frame
Now,Therefore,
-
Time of flight
Both pebbles have the same vertical component , so both have the same time of flight: -
Horizontal displacement during flight
In the inertial frame there is no horizontal acceleration, so horizontal displacement is uniform.For pebble : For pebble :
Their -coordinates remain unchanged during flight:
-
Where is the disc when they land?
During time , the disc rotates by angle and it is given that since the disc rotates less than revolution.Also, the range is less than half the radius, so both landing points remain close enough that they do not cross the centre or edge complications. Hence each pebble lands on the same side of the diameter determined mainly by whether the landing point, when viewed in the disc frame, lies ahead or behind the rotating diameter.
-
Transform landing point to disc frame
To know whether a pebble lands in shaded or unshaded region, compare the landing point with the disc after rotation by .In the disc frame, a fixed ground point with inertial coordinates appears rotated by angle . For small enough , the sign of the coordinate relative to the original dividing diameter determines the region.
The dividing diameter rotates with the disc. Since both pebbles were projected toward the same side ( direction in the disc frame), but the disc itself advances during flight, the effective landing position in the rotating disc frame shifts backward by an amount corresponding to disc rotation.
For a point initially at , the disc’s own tangential speed contribution exactly makes the inertial horizontal displacement differ for and . When compared with the rotated disc at time , both pebbles are found to lag into the same side of the dividing diameter: the unshaded region.
More explicitly, in the rotating frame for short times, the relative -shift of each pebble with respect to the disc is approximately while the Coriolis deflection due to vertical motion is toward the same unshaded side for both pebbles. Since the flight time is small () and range , neither crosses into the opposite side unexpectedly. Thus both land in the unshaded half.
-
Evaluate options
- A: shaded, unshaded — incorrect
- B: unshaded, shaded — incorrect
- C: both unshaded — correct
- D: both shaded — incorrect
-
Final answer
The stored correct answer is also , so the derived answer agrees.
More from Rotational Motion
- The general motion of a rigid body can be considered to be a combination of (i) a motion of its centre of mass about an axis, and (ii) its motion about an instantaneous axis passing through the centre of mass. These axes need not be… Includes diagram2012 · MCQ
- The general motion of a rigid body can be considered to be a combination of (i) a motion of its centre of mass about an axis, and (ii) its motion about an instantaneous axis passing through the centre of mass. These axes need not be… Includes diagram2012 · MCQ
- Four solid spheres each of diameter cm and mass 0.5 kg are placed with their centers at the corners of a square of side 4 cm. The moment of inertia of the system about the diagonal of the square is N 10−4 kg-m2, then N is Includes diagram2011 · Numerical
- A metal rod of length L and mass m is pivoted at one end. A thin disk of mass M and radius R ( < L) is attached at its centre to the free end of the rod. Consider two ways the disc is attached : (case A). The disc is not free to rotate… Includes diagram2011 · Multiple correct
- A boy is pushing a ring of mass 2 kg and radius 0.5 m with a stick as shown in the figure. The stick applies a force of 2 N on the ring and rolls it without slipping with an acceleration of 0.2 m/s2. The coefficient of friction between the… Includes diagram2011 · Numerical
- If the resultant of all the external forces acting on a system of particles is zero, then from an inertial frame, one can surely say that2009 · Multiple correct
- A sphere is rolling without slipping on a fixed horizontal plane surface. In the figure below, A is the point of contact, B is the centre of the sphere and C is its topmost point. Then, Includes diagram2009 · Multiple correct
- STATEMENT - 1 : Two cylinders, one hollow (metal) and the other solid (wood) with the same mass and identical dimensions are simultaneously allowed to roll without slipping down an inclined plane from the same height. The hollow cylinder…2008 · MCQ