JEE AdvancedPhysicsElectrostaticsMCQ+3 / −1
Consider an evacuated cylindrical chamber of height h having rigid conducting plates at the ends and an insulating curved surface as shown in the figure. A number of spherical balls made of a light weight and soft material and coated with a conducting material are placed on the bottom plate. The balls have a radius r << h. Now, a high voltage source (HV) connected across the conducting plates such that the bottom plate is at +V0 and the top plate at V0. Due to their conducting surface, the balls will get charge, will become equipotential with the plate and are repelled by it. The balls will eventually collide with the top plate, where the coefficient of restitution can be taken to be zero due to the soft nature of the material of the balls. The electric field in the chamber can be considered to be that of a parallel plate capacitor. Assume that there are no collisions between the balls and the interaction between them is negligible. (Ignore gravity)
Which one of the following statement is correct?
Which one of the following statement is correct?- AThe balls will execute simple harmonic motion between the two plates
- BThe balls will bounce back to the bottom plate carrying the same charge they went up with
- CThe balls will stick to the top plate and remain there
- DThe balls will bounce back to the bottom plate carrying the opposite charge they went up with
View written solutionFree
Correct answer: D
Step-by-step Solution:
-
Analyze the Initial Setup:
- We have a cylindrical chamber with two conducting plates at the top and bottom, separated by a height
h. - A potential difference
Vis applied across the plates. Let's assume the top plate is at a positive potential+Vand the bottom plate is grounded (at 0 potential). This creates a uniform electric fieldEdirected downwards, with magnitudeE = V/h(ignoring edge effects). - Conducting spherical balls are placed on the bottom plate.
- We have a cylindrical chamber with two conducting plates at the top and bottom, separated by a height
-
Charging of the Balls at the Bottom Plate:
- The balls are conducting and are in direct contact with the bottom plate, which is at 0 potential. Therefore, the balls will also be at 0 potential.
- The downward electric field
Epolarizes the conducting balls. It attracts negative charges (electrons) to the top surface of the balls and repels positive charges to the bottom surface. - Since the balls are in contact with the bottom plate, the repelled positive charge can flow away into the plate (or electrons can be drawn from the plate to neutralize the induced positive charge and add to the induced negative charge). The result is that each ball acquires a net negative charge, let's call it
q.
-
Motion Towards the Top Plate:
- Once a ball has a net negative charge
q, it experiences an electrostatic force . - Since
qis negative and the electric fieldEis directed downwards, the force is directed upwards (). - There is also a downward gravitational force , where
mis the mass of the ball. - The problem states the balls are made of a "light weight" material, which implies that the upward electrostatic force is greater than the downward gravitational force:
|q|E > mg. - Under the net upward force , the ball accelerates and moves towards the top plate.
- Once a ball has a net negative charge
-
Interaction with the Top Plate:
- The ball, carrying a negative charge
q, reaches and collides with the top plate. - The top plate is a conductor at a positive potential
+V. - Upon contact, charge is redistributed between the ball and the top plate until the ball also reaches the potential
+V. - To reach a positive potential, the ball must lose its excess electrons and become positively charged. Let's call its new charge
q'.
- The ball, carrying a negative charge
-
Motion Towards the Bottom Plate (Bouncing Back):
- Now the ball has a net positive charge
q'. - The electric field
Eis still directed downwards. - The electrostatic force on the ball is now . Since
q'is positive, this force is also directed downwards. - The total downward force on the ball is .
- This net downward force causes the ball to accelerate and move back towards the bottom plate.
- Now the ball has a net positive charge
-
Evaluating the Options:
- A: The balls will execute simple harmonic motion between the two plates. The force on the ball during its transit is constant (
|q|E - mgon the way up,q'E + mgon the way down). Simple harmonic motion requires a restoring force proportional to displacement (F = -kx), which is not the case here. So, A is incorrect. - B: The balls will bounce back to the bottom plate carrying the same charge they went up with. The ball goes up with a negative charge
q. It acquires a positive chargeq'at the top plate before bouncing back. The charges are different. So, B is incorrect. - C: The balls will stick to the top plate and remain there. After touching the top plate, the ball acquires a positive charge
q', and there is a net downward force (q'E + mg) acting on it. This force will push it away from the top plate, not make it stick. So, C is incorrect. - D: The balls will bounce back to the bottom plate carrying the opposite charge they went up with. The ball travels up with a negative charge (
q). After contacting the top plate, it acquires a positive charge (q') for its journey back down. The charge it carries on its return trip (q') is opposite in sign to the charge it had on its way up (q). This statement is consistent with our analysis. So, D is correct.
- A: The balls will execute simple harmonic motion between the two plates. The force on the ball during its transit is constant (
This process will repeat, causing the balls to oscillate between the plates, acting as charge carriers. This is the principle behind devices like Franklin's bells.
More from Electrostatics
- Consider an evacuated cylindrical chamber of height h having rigid conducting plates at the ends and an insulating curved surface as shown in the figure. A number of spherical balls made of a light weight and soft material and coated with… Includes diagram2016 · MCQ
- The figures below depict two situations in which two infinitely long static line charges of constant positive line charge density are kept parallel to each other. In their resulting electric field, point charges and are… Includes diagram2015 · Multiple correct
- An infinitely long uniform line charge distribution of charge per unit length lies parallel to the y-axis in the y-z plane at a (see figure). If the magnitude of the flux of the electric field through… Includes diagram2015 · Numerical
- Consider a uniform spherical charge distribution of radius centred at the origin In this distribution, a spherical cavity of radius centred at with distance (see figure) is made. If the… Includes diagram2015 · Multiple correct
- Let and be the respective electric field at a distance from a point charge an infinitely long wire with constant linear charge density and an…2014 · Multiple correct
- Charges and are uniformly distributed in three dielectric solid spheres and of radii and respectively, as shown in figure. If magnitude of the electric fields at point at a distance from the… Includes diagram2014 · MCQ
- Four charges Q1, Q2, Q3 and Q4 of same magnitude are fixed along the x axis at x = 2a, a, +a and +2a, respectively. A positive charge q is placed on the positive y axis at a distance b > 0. Four options of the signs of these… Includes table Includes diagram2014 · MCQ
- Two non-conducting solid spheres of radii and having uniform volume charge densities and respectively, touch each other. The net electric field at a distance from the center of the smaller sphere,…2013 · MCQ