Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Electrostatics question

2013 · Shift 1 · Q50
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Advanced
  3. /Physics
  4. /Electrostatics
  5. /2013 · Shift 1 · Q50

Electrostatics question

2013 · Shift 1 · Q50

JEE AdvancedPhysicsElectrostaticsMCQ+4 / −1
Two non-conducting solid spheres of radii RRR and 2R,2R,2R, having uniform volume charge densities ρ1{\rho _1}ρ1​ and ρ2{\rho _2}ρ2​ respectively, touch each other. The net electric field at a distance 2R2R2R from the center of the smaller sphere, along the line joining the centers of the spheres, is zero. The ratio ρ1ρ2{{{\rho _1}} \over {{\rho _2}}}ρ2​ρ1​​ can be
  1. A
    −4-4−4
  2. B
    −3225- {{32} \over {25}}−2532​
  3. C
    3225{{32} \over {25}}2532​
  4. D
    444
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: B

Step-by-step Derivations

  1. Setup and Coordinate System Let's place the center of the smaller sphere (Sphere 1) at the origin (0,0,0)(0,0,0)(0,0,0). This sphere has radius RRR and uniform volume charge density ρ1\rho_1ρ1​. The two spheres are touching. So, the center of the larger sphere (Sphere 2), which has radius 2R2R2R and density ρ2\rho_2ρ2​, is at a distance of R+2R=3RR + 2R = 3RR+2R=3R from the origin. Let's place it on the x-axis at (3R,0,0)(3R, 0, 0)(3R,0,0).

  2. Identifying the Point of Zero Electric Field The problem states that the net electric field is zero at a distance 2R2R2R from the center of the smaller sphere, along the line joining the centers (the x-axis). There are two such points:

    • Case 1: The point P is at x=2Rx = 2Rx=2R. This point is between the two centers.
    • Case 2: The point P is at x=−2Rx = -2Rx=−2R. This point is on the other side of the smaller sphere.
  3. Electric Field Formulas The electric field E⃗\vec{E}E at a distance rrr from the center of a uniformly charged non-conducting sphere of radius aaa and charge density ρ\rhoρ is given by:

    • Outside the sphere (r≥ar \ge ar≥a): E⃗=14πϵ0Qr3r⃗=ρa33ϵ0r3r⃗\vec{E} = \frac{1}{4\pi\epsilon_0} \frac{Q}{r^3}\vec{r} = \frac{\rho a^3}{3\epsilon_0 r^3} \vec{r}E=4πϵ0​1​r3Q​r=3ϵ0​r3ρa3​r
    • Inside the sphere (r<ar < ar<a): E⃗=14πϵ0Qra3r⃗r=ρ3ϵ0r⃗\vec{E} = \frac{1}{4\pi\epsilon_0} \frac{Qr}{a^3} \frac{\vec{r}}{r} = \frac{\rho}{3\epsilon_0} \vec{r}E=4πϵ0​1​a3Qr​rr​=3ϵ0​ρ​r where r⃗\vec{r}r is the position vector from the center of the sphere to the point in question.

Case 1: Point P at x=2Rx = 2Rx=2R

  1. Position vectors and distances:

    • For Sphere 1 (center at origin): The vector from its center to P is r1⃗=2Ri^\vec{r_1} = 2R\hat{i}r1​​=2Ri^. The distance is r1=2Rr_1 = 2Rr1​=2R. Since r1>Rr_1 > Rr1​>R, the point P is outside Sphere 1.
    • For Sphere 2 (center at 3Ri^3R\hat{i}3Ri^): The vector from its center to P is r2⃗=2Ri^−3Ri^=−Ri^\vec{r_2} = 2R\hat{i} - 3R\hat{i} = -R\hat{i}r2​​=2Ri^−3Ri^=−Ri^. The distance is r2=Rr_2 = Rr2​=R. Since r2<2Rr_2 < 2Rr2​<2R, the point P is inside Sphere 2.
  2. Calculating Electric Fields:

    • Electric field due to Sphere 1 at P: E⃗1=ρ1R33ϵ0r13r1⃗=ρ1R33ϵ0(2R)3(2Ri^)=ρ1R33ϵ0⋅8R3(2Ri^)=ρ1R12ϵ0i^\vec{E}_1 = \frac{\rho_1 R^3}{3\epsilon_0 r_1^3} \vec{r_1} = \frac{\rho_1 R^3}{3\epsilon_0 (2R)^3} (2R\hat{i}) = \frac{\rho_1 R^3}{3\epsilon_0 \cdot 8R^3} (2R\hat{i}) = \frac{\rho_1 R}{12\epsilon_0} \hat{i}E1​=3ϵ0​r13​ρ1​R3​r1​​=3ϵ0​(2R)3ρ1​R3​(2Ri^)=3ϵ0​⋅8R3ρ1​R3​(2Ri^)=12ϵ0​ρ1​R​i^
    • Electric field due to Sphere 2 at P: E⃗2=ρ23ϵ0r2⃗=ρ23ϵ0(−Ri^)=−ρ2R3ϵ0i^\vec{E}_2 = \frac{\rho_2}{3\epsilon_0} \vec{r_2} = \frac{\rho_2}{3\epsilon_0} (-R\hat{i}) = -\frac{\rho_2 R}{3\epsilon_0} \hat{i}E2​=3ϵ0​ρ2​​r2​​=3ϵ0​ρ2​​(−Ri^)=−3ϵ0​ρ2​R​i^
  3. Net Field and Ratio of Densities: The net electric field at P is zero: E⃗net=E⃗1+E⃗2=0\vec{E}_{net} = \vec{E}_1 + \vec{E}_2 = 0Enet​=E1​+E2​=0. (ρ1R12ϵ0−ρ2R3ϵ0)i^=0\left( \frac{\rho_1 R}{12\epsilon_0} - \frac{\rho_2 R}{3\epsilon_0} \right) \hat{i} = 0(12ϵ0​ρ1​R​−3ϵ0​ρ2​R​)i^=0 ρ112=ρ23  ⟹  ρ1ρ2=123=4\frac{\rho_1}{12} = \frac{\rho_2}{3} \implies \frac{\rho_1}{\rho_2} = \frac{12}{3} = 412ρ1​​=3ρ2​​⟹ρ2​ρ1​​=312​=4 This corresponds to option D.

Case 2: Point P at x=−2Rx = -2Rx=−2R

  1. Position vectors and distances:

    • For Sphere 1 (center at origin): The vector from its center to P is r1⃗=−2Ri^\vec{r_1} = -2R\hat{i}r1​​=−2Ri^. The distance is r1=2Rr_1 = 2Rr1​=2R. Since r1>Rr_1 > Rr1​>R, the point P is outside Sphere 1.
    • For Sphere 2 (center at 3Ri^3R\hat{i}3Ri^): The vector from its center to P is r2⃗=−2Ri^−3Ri^=−5Ri^\vec{r_2} = -2R\hat{i} - 3R\hat{i} = -5R\hat{i}r2​​=−2Ri^−3Ri^=−5Ri^. The distance is r2=5Rr_2 = 5Rr2​=5R. Since r2>2Rr_2 > 2Rr2​>2R, the point P is outside Sphere 2.
  2. Calculating Electric Fields:

    • Electric field due to Sphere 1 at P: E⃗1=ρ1R33ϵ0r13r1⃗=ρ1R33ϵ0(2R)3(−2Ri^)=−ρ1R12ϵ0i^\vec{E}_1 = \frac{\rho_1 R^3}{3\epsilon_0 r_1^3} \vec{r_1} = \frac{\rho_1 R^3}{3\epsilon_0 (2R)^3} (-2R\hat{i}) = -\frac{\rho_1 R}{12\epsilon_0} \hat{i}E1​=3ϵ0​r13​ρ1​R3​r1​​=3ϵ0​(2R)3ρ1​R3​(−2Ri^)=−12ϵ0​ρ1​R​i^
    • Electric field due to Sphere 2 at P: E⃗2=ρ2(2R)33ϵ0r23r2⃗=ρ2(8R3)3ϵ0(5R)3(−5Ri^)=8ρ2R33ϵ0⋅125R3(−5Ri^)=−40ρ2R375ϵ0i^=−8ρ2R75ϵ0i^\vec{E}_2 = \frac{\rho_2 (2R)^3}{3\epsilon_0 r_2^3} \vec{r_2} = \frac{\rho_2 (8R^3)}{3\epsilon_0 (5R)^3} (-5R\hat{i}) = \frac{8\rho_2 R^3}{3\epsilon_0 \cdot 125R^3} (-5R\hat{i}) = -\frac{40\rho_2 R}{375\epsilon_0} \hat{i} = -\frac{8\rho_2 R}{75\epsilon_0} \hat{i}E2​=3ϵ0​r23​ρ2​(2R)3​r2​​=3ϵ0​(5R)3ρ2​(8R3)​(−5Ri^)=3ϵ0​⋅125R38ρ2​R3​(−5Ri^)=−375ϵ0​40ρ2​R​i^=−75ϵ0​8ρ2​R​i^
  3. Net Field and Ratio of Densities: The net electric field at P is zero: E⃗net=E⃗1+E⃗2=0\vec{E}_{net} = \vec{E}_1 + \vec{E}_2 = 0Enet​=E1​+E2​=0. (−ρ1R12ϵ0−8ρ2R75ϵ0)i^=0\left( -\frac{\rho_1 R}{12\epsilon_0} - \frac{8\rho_2 R}{75\epsilon_0} \right) \hat{i} = 0(−12ϵ0​ρ1​R​−75ϵ0​8ρ2​R​)i^=0 −ρ112=8ρ275-\frac{\rho_1}{12} = \frac{8\rho_2}{75}−12ρ1​​=758ρ2​​ ρ1ρ2=−12×875=−9675=−3225\frac{\rho_1}{\rho_2} = -\frac{12 \times 8}{75} = -\frac{96}{75} = -\frac{32}{25}ρ2​ρ1​​=−7512×8​=−7596​=−2532​ This corresponds to option B.

Conclusion

The problem statement allows for two possible locations for the point of zero electric field, leading to two different possible values for the ratio ρ1ρ2{{{\rho _1}} \over {{\rho _2}}}ρ2​ρ1​​: 4 and −3225- {{32} \over {25}}−2532​. Both of these values are present in the options (D and B). Since the question asks for a ratio that can be the answer and this is a single-choice question, we select the one available in the options. Option B is −3225- {{32} \over {25}}−2532​.

Final Answer is based on Case 2.

PreviousNext

More from Electrostatics

  • Two non-conducting spheres of radii R1​ and R2​ and carrying uniform volume charge densities +ρ and −ρ, respectively, are placed such that they partially overlap, as shown in the figure. At all points in the… Includes diagram2013 · Multiple correct
  • A cubical region of side a has its center at the origin. It encloses three fixed point charges, −q at (0,−a/4,0),+3q at (0,0,0) and −q at (0,+a/4,0). Choose the correct… Includes diagram2012 · Multiple correct
  • Consider a thin spherical shell of radius R with center at the origin, carrying uniform positive surface charge density. The variation of the magnitude of the electric field ​E(r)​ and the…2012 · MCQ
  • Two large vertical and parallel metal plates having a separation of 1cm are connected to a DC voltage source of potential difference X. A proton is released at rest midway between the two plates. It is found to move at 45∘…2012 · MCQ
  • An infinitely long solid cylinder of radius R has a uniform volume charge density ρ. It has a spherical cavity of radius R/2 with its centre on the axis of the cylinder, as shown in the figure. The magnitude of the electric field at… Includes diagram2012 · Numerical
  • Six point charges are kept at the vertices of a regular hexagon of side L and center O, as shown in the figure. Given that K=4πε0​1​L2q​, which of the following statement(s) is (are) correct… Includes diagram2012 · Multiple correct
  • Consider an electric field E=E0​x where E0​ is a constant. The flux through the shaded area (as shown in the figure) due to this field is Includes diagram2011 · MCQ
  • A spherical metal shell A of radius RA​ and a solid metal sphere B of radius RB​(<RA​) are kept far apart and each is given charge ′+Q′. Now they are connected by a thin metal wire. Then2011 · Multiple correct