Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Electrostatics question

2012 · Shift 1 · Q41
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Advanced
  3. /Physics
  4. /Electrostatics
  5. /2012 · Shift 1 · Q41

Electrostatics question

2012 · Shift 1 · Q41

JEE AdvancedPhysicsElectrostaticsMultiple correct+4 / −1
A cubical region of side aaa has its center at the origin. It encloses three fixed point charges, −q-q−q at (0,−a/4,0),+3q\left( {0, - a/4,0} \right), + 3q(0,−a/4,0),+3q at (0,0,0)\left( {0,0,0} \right)(0,0,0) and −q-q−q at (0,+a/4,0).\left( {0, + a/4,0} \right).(0,+a/4,0). Choose the correct option(s) IIT-JEE 2012 Paper 1 Offline Physics - Electrostatics Question 53 English
  1. A
    The net electric flux crossing the plane x=+a/2x=+a/2x=+a/2 is equal to the net electric flux crossing the plane x=−a/2x=-a/2x=−a/2
  2. B
    The net electric flux crossing the plane y=+a/2y=+a/2y=+a/2 is more than the net electric flux crossing the plane y=−a/2.y=-a/2.y=−a/2.
  3. C
    The net electric flux crossing the entire region is qε0{q \over {{\varepsilon _0}}}ε0​q​
  4. D
    The net electric flux crossing the plane z=+a/2z = + a/2z=+a/2 is equal to the net electric flux crossing the plane x=+a/2.x=+a/2.x=+a/2.
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: A, C, D

The problem asks us to evaluate four statements about the electric flux through the faces of a cube centered at the origin, which encloses three point charges. We will analyze each option using Gauss's Law and symmetry principles.

The given charges are:

  • q1=−qq_1 = -qq1​=−q at (0,−a/4,0)(0, -a/4, 0)(0,−a/4,0)
  • q2=+3qq_2 = +3qq2​=+3q at (0,0,0)(0, 0, 0)(0,0,0)
  • q3=−qq_3 = -qq3​=−q at (0,+a/4,0)(0, +a/4, 0)(0,+a/4,0)

The cube has side length 'a' and is centered at the origin. Its faces are the planes x=±a/2x=\pm a/2x=±a/2, y=±a/2y=\pm a/2y=±a/2, and z=±a/2z=\pm a/2z=±a/2.

Evaluation of Option C

C: The net electric flux crossing the entire region is qε0{q \over {{\varepsilon _0}}}ε0​q​.

  1. Gauss's Law: The total electric flux Φtotal\Phi_{total}Φtotal​ through a closed surface is given by Gauss's Law: Φtotal=Qencε0\Phi_{total} = \frac{Q_{enc}}{\varepsilon_0}Φtotal​=ε0​Qenc​​ where QencQ_{enc}Qenc​ is the total charge enclosed by the surface.
  2. Calculate Enclosed Charge: The cube encloses all three charges. The total enclosed charge is the sum of the individual charges: Qenc=q1+q2+q3=(−q)+(+3q)+(−q)=qQ_{enc} = q_1 + q_2 + q_3 = (-q) + (+3q) + (-q) = qQenc​=q1​+q2​+q3​=(−q)+(+3q)+(−q)=q
  3. Calculate Total Flux: Using Gauss's Law, the net electric flux crossing the entire cubical region is: Φtotal=qε0\Phi_{total} = \frac{q}{\varepsilon_0}Φtotal​=ε0​q​
  4. Conclusion: Statement C is correct.

Evaluation of Option A

A: The net electric flux crossing the plane x=+a/2x=+a/2x=+a/2 is equal to the net electric flux crossing the plane x=−a/2x=-a/2x=−a/2.

  1. Symmetry Analysis: Let's consider the symmetry of the charge distribution with respect to the y−zy-zy−z plane (the plane x=0x=0x=0). All three charges lie on the y-axis, which is contained within the y−zy-zy−z plane. This charge distribution is symmetric with respect to reflection across the x=0x=0x=0 plane.
  2. Electric Field Symmetry: Due to this symmetry, the x-component of the electric field must be an odd function of xxx. That is, for any point (x,y,z)(x, y, z)(x,y,z), the electric field components satisfy Ex(−x,y,z)=−Ex(x,y,z)E_x(-x, y, z) = -E_x(x, y, z)Ex​(−x,y,z)=−Ex​(x,y,z).
  3. Flux Calculation:
    • The flux through the face at x=+a/2x=+a/2x=+a/2 (let's call it the right face) is given by Φright=∫rightE⃗⋅dA⃗\Phi_{right} = \int_{right} \vec{E} \cdot d\vec{A}Φright​=∫right​E⋅dA. Here, dA⃗=dydz i^d\vec{A} = dy dz \, \hat{i}dA=dydzi^. So, Φright=∫−a/2a/2∫−a/2a/2Ex(a/2,y,z) dydz\Phi_{right} = \int_{-a/2}^{a/2} \int_{-a/2}^{a/2} E_x(a/2, y, z) \, dy dzΦright​=∫−a/2a/2​∫−a/2a/2​Ex​(a/2,y,z)dydz
    • The flux through the face at x=−a/2x=-a/2x=−a/2 (left face) is Φleft=∫leftE⃗⋅dA⃗\Phi_{left} = \int_{left} \vec{E} \cdot d\vec{A}Φleft​=∫left​E⋅dA. Here, dA⃗=dydz (−i^)d\vec{A} = dy dz \, (-\hat{i})dA=dydz(−i^). So, Φleft=∫−a/2a/2∫−a/2a/2Ex(−a/2,y,z) (−1) dydz\Phi_{left} = \int_{-a/2}^{a/2} \int_{-a/2}^{a/2} E_x(-a/2, y, z) \, (-1) \, dy dzΦleft​=∫−a/2a/2​∫−a/2a/2​Ex​(−a/2,y,z)(−1)dydz
  4. Comparing Fluxes: Using the symmetry property Ex(−a/2,y,z)=−Ex(a/2,y,z)E_x(-a/2, y, z) = -E_x(a/2, y, z)Ex​(−a/2,y,z)=−Ex​(a/2,y,z), we get: Φleft=−∫−a/2a/2∫−a/2a/2[−Ex(a/2,y,z)] dydz=∫−a/2a/2∫−a/2a/2Ex(a/2,y,z) dydz=Φright\Phi_{left} = -\int_{-a/2}^{a/2} \int_{-a/2}^{a/2} [-E_x(a/2, y, z)] \, dy dz = \int_{-a/2}^{a/2} \int_{-a/2}^{a/2} E_x(a/2, y, z) \, dy dz = \Phi_{right}Φleft​=−∫−a/2a/2​∫−a/2a/2​[−Ex​(a/2,y,z)]dydz=∫−a/2a/2​∫−a/2a/2​Ex​(a/2,y,z)dydz=Φright​
  5. Conclusion: The fluxes are equal. Statement A is correct.

Evaluation of Option B

B: The net electric flux crossing the plane y=+a/2y=+a/2y=+a/2 is more than the net electric flux crossing the plane y=−a/2y=-a/2y=−a/2.

  1. Symmetry Analysis: Let's consider the symmetry of the charge distribution with respect to the x−zx-zx−z plane (the plane y=0y=0y=0). The charges are located at (0,−a/4,0)(0, -a/4, 0)(0,−a/4,0), (0,0,0)(0, 0, 0)(0,0,0), and (0,+a/4,0)(0, +a/4, 0)(0,+a/4,0). This distribution is symmetric upon reflection across the y=0y=0y=0 plane (i.e., replacing yyy with −y-y−y). The two −q-q−q charges swap positions, and the +3q+3q+3q charge remains on the plane.
  2. Electric Field Symmetry: Due to this symmetry, the y-component of the electric field must be an odd function of yyy: Ey(x,−y,z)=−Ey(x,y,z)E_y(x, -y, z) = -E_y(x, y, z)Ey​(x,−y,z)=−Ey​(x,y,z).
  3. Flux Calculation: A similar analysis as for Option A can be done.
    • Flux through the top face (y=+a/2y=+a/2y=+a/2): Φtop=∫Ey(x,a/2,z) dxdz\Phi_{top} = \int E_y(x, a/2, z) \, dx dzΦtop​=∫Ey​(x,a/2,z)dxdz.
    • Flux through the bottom face (y=−a/2y=-a/2y=−a/2): Φbottom=∫Ey(x,−a/2,z) (−1) dxdz\Phi_{bottom} = \int E_y(x, -a/2, z) \, (-1) \, dx dzΦbottom​=∫Ey​(x,−a/2,z)(−1)dxdz.
  4. Comparing Fluxes: Using Ey(x,−a/2,z)=−Ey(x,a/2,z)E_y(x, -a/2, z) = -E_y(x, a/2, z)Ey​(x,−a/2,z)=−Ey​(x,a/2,z), we find: Φbottom=−∫[−Ey(x,a/2,z)] dxdz=∫Ey(x,a/2,z) dxdz=Φtop\Phi_{bottom} = -\int [-E_y(x, a/2, z)] \, dx dz = \int E_y(x, a/2, z) \, dx dz = \Phi_{top}Φbottom​=−∫[−Ey​(x,a/2,z)]dxdz=∫Ey​(x,a/2,z)dxdz=Φtop​
  5. Conclusion: The flux through the top face is equal to the flux through the bottom face. Therefore, statement B is incorrect.

Evaluation of Option D

D: The net electric flux crossing the plane z=+a/2z = + a/2z=+a/2 is equal to the net electric flux crossing the plane x=+a/2x=+a/2x=+a/2.

  1. Symmetry Analysis: Consider the symmetry of the charge distribution with respect to rotations about the y-axis. All charges lie on the y-axis. Therefore, the charge distribution has rotational (cylindrical) symmetry about the y-axis.
  2. Geometric Symmetry: The cube itself is symmetric under a 90∘90^\circ90∘ rotation about the y-axis. This rotation transforms the face at x=+a/2x=+a/2x=+a/2 into the face at z=+a/2z=+a/2z=+a/2. Similarly, it transforms the faces z=+a/2→x=−a/2→z=−a/2→x=+a/2z=+a/2 \to x=-a/2 \to z=-a/2 \to x=+a/2z=+a/2→x=−a/2→z=−a/2→x=+a/2.
  3. Comparing Fluxes: Since both the source of the field (the charges) and the geometry of the faces are symmetric under this rotation, the physical situation is identical for the four side faces (x=±a/2,z=±a/2x=\pm a/2, z=\pm a/2x=±a/2,z=±a/2). Therefore, the electric flux through these faces must be related by this symmetry.
  4. Specifically, the flux through the face at x=+a/2x=+a/2x=+a/2 must be equal to the flux through the face at z=+a/2z=+a/2z=+a/2. That is, Φx=+a/2=Φz=+a/2\Phi_{x=+a/2} = \Phi_{z=+a/2}Φx=+a/2​=Φz=+a/2​.
  5. Conclusion: Statement D is correct.

Summary: Based on the analysis:

  • Option A is correct.
  • Option B is incorrect.
  • Option C is correct.
  • Option D is correct.
PreviousNext

More from Electrostatics

  • Consider a thin spherical shell of radius R with center at the origin, carrying uniform positive surface charge density. The variation of the magnitude of the electric field ​E(r)​ and the…2012 · MCQ
  • Two large vertical and parallel metal plates having a separation of 1cm are connected to a DC voltage source of potential difference X. A proton is released at rest midway between the two plates. It is found to move at 45∘…2012 · MCQ
  • An infinitely long solid cylinder of radius R has a uniform volume charge density ρ. It has a spherical cavity of radius R/2 with its centre on the axis of the cylinder, as shown in the figure. The magnitude of the electric field at… Includes diagram2012 · Numerical
  • Six point charges are kept at the vertices of a regular hexagon of side L and center O, as shown in the figure. Given that K=4πε0​1​L2q​, which of the following statement(s) is (are) correct… Includes diagram2012 · Multiple correct
  • Consider an electric field E=E0​x where E0​ is a constant. The flux through the shaded area (as shown in the figure) due to this field is Includes diagram2011 · MCQ
  • A spherical metal shell A of radius RA​ and a solid metal sphere B of radius RB​(<RA​) are kept far apart and each is given charge ′+Q′. Now they are connected by a thin metal wire. Then2011 · Multiple correct
  • Four point charges, each of +q, are rigidly fixed at the four corners of a square planar soap film of side a. The surface tension of the soap film is γ. The system of charges and planar film are in equilibrium, and a=k[γq2​]1/N…2011 · Numerical
  • Which of the following statement(s) is/are correct?2011 · Multiple correct