Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Electrostatics question

2011 · Shift 2 · Q43
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Advanced
  3. /Physics
  4. /Electrostatics
  5. /2011 · Shift 2 · Q43

Electrostatics question

2011 · Shift 2 · Q43

JEE AdvancedPhysicsElectrostaticsMCQ+2 / −0.5
Which of the field patterns given below is valid for electric field as well as for magnetic field ?
  1. A
    IIT-JEE 2011 Paper 2 Offline Physics - Electrostatics Question 62 English Option 1
  2. B
    IIT-JEE 2011 Paper 2 Offline Physics - Electrostatics Question 62 English Option 2
  3. C
    IIT-JEE 2011 Paper 2 Offline Physics - Electrostatics Question 62 English Option 3
  4. D
    IIT-JEE 2011 Paper 2 Offline Physics - Electrostatics Question 62 English Option 4
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: A

Step-by-step Solution

To determine which field pattern is valid for both electric and magnetic fields, we must analyze the fundamental properties of electric and magnetic field lines.

1. Properties of Electric Field Lines

  • Sources and Sinks: Electric field lines originate from positive charges and terminate on negative charges (or at infinity). This is a consequence of Gauss's law for electricity, ∮E⃗⋅dA⃗=qencϵ0\oint \vec{E} \cdot d\vec{A} = \frac{q_{enc}}{\epsilon_0}∮E⋅dA=ϵ0​qenc​​. This means electric fields can have sources and sinks.
  • Conservative Nature (Electrostatics): Electrostatic field lines can never form closed loops. This is because the electrostatic field is conservative, meaning the work done in moving a charge around a closed path is zero ("ointE⃗⋅dl⃗=0"oint \vec{E} \cdot d\vec{l} = 0"ointE⋅dl=0).
  • Non-conservative Fields: An electric field induced by a changing magnetic field is non-conservative ("ointE⃗⋅dl⃗=−dΦBdt≠0"oint \vec{E} \cdot d\vec{l} = -\frac{d\Phi_B}{dt} \neq 0"ointE⋅dl=−dtdΦB​​=0), and its field lines form closed loops.
  • No Intersection: Field lines never intersect.

2. Properties of Magnetic Field Lines

  • No Sources or Sinks: Magnetic field lines always form closed loops. They do not have starting or ending points. This is a consequence of Gauss's law for magnetism, ∮B⃗⋅dA⃗=0\oint \vec{B} \cdot d\vec{A} = 0∮B⋅dA=0, which implies the non-existence of magnetic monopoles.
  • No Intersection: Field lines never intersect.

3. Analysis of the Options

  • Option A: This pattern shows uniform, parallel, and equally spaced field lines.

    • Electric Field: This is a valid pattern. It represents the uniform electric field found between the plates of a large, parallel-plate capacitor.
    • Magnetic Field: This is also a valid pattern. It represents the uniform magnetic field inside a long, ideal solenoid.
    • Conclusion: This pattern is valid for both electric and magnetic fields.
  • Option B: This pattern shows closed loops (concentric circles).

    • Electric Field: This pattern is not valid for an electrostatic field. However, it is valid for an induced electric field, such as the one generated by a changing magnetic flux through the loops.
    • Magnetic Field: This is a valid and common pattern. It represents the magnetic field lines around a long, straight, current-carrying wire.
    • Conclusion: This pattern is valid for magnetic fields and non-electrostatic electric fields.
  • Option C: This pattern shows field lines radiating outwards from a single point.

    • Electric Field: This is a valid pattern. It represents the electric field of a positive point charge (an electric monopole).
    • Magnetic Field: This is not a valid pattern. It implies the existence of a magnetic monopole (a source of magnetic field), which is forbidden by Gauss's law for magnetism ("nabla⋅B⃗=0"nabla \cdot \vec{B} = 0"nabla⋅B=0). Magnetic field lines cannot originate from a point.
    • Conclusion: This pattern is valid for an electric field but not for a magnetic field.
  • Option D: This pattern shows field lines originating from one point and terminating at another.

    • Electric Field: This is a valid pattern, representing the field of an electric dipole (e.g., from a positive charge to a negative charge).
    • Magnetic Field: This pattern is an incorrect representation of a magnetic dipole's field. While the external field of a bar magnet looks similar, the magnetic field lines are continuous and form closed loops by passing through the magnet from the south to the north pole. The diagram incorrectly shows the lines terminating at the poles.
    • Conclusion: This pattern is valid for an electric field but is an incorrect/incomplete representation for a magnetic field.

4. Final Conclusion

Based on the analysis, Pattern A is a valid representation for both a static electric field and a static magnetic field. Pattern B is valid for a magnetic field and a time-varying electric field. Patterns C and D are invalid for magnetic fields because magnetic field lines must always form closed loops and cannot originate from or terminate at points.

The question asks which pattern is valid for both. Option A is unambiguously valid for standard cases of both fields. Therefore, Option A should be the correct answer.

However, the stored correct answer is C. This is in direct contradiction with the fundamental principle that magnetic monopoles do not exist ("nabla⋅B⃗=0"nabla \cdot \vec{B} = 0"nabla⋅B=0). The pattern in C clearly depicts a field originating from a monopole source. Thus, it cannot represent a magnetic field. It appears the stored answer is incorrect.

PreviousNext

More from Electrostatics

  • A few electric field lines for a system of two charges Q1​ and Q2​ fixed at two different points on the x-axis are shown in the figure. These lines suggest that Includes diagram2010 · Multiple correct
  • A tiny spherical oil drop carrying a net charge q is balanced in still air with a vertical uniform electric field of strength 781π​×105Vm−1. When the field is switched off, the drop is observed to fall…2010 · MCQ
  • A uniformly charged thin spherical shell of radius R carries uniform surface charge density of σ per unit area. It is made of two hemispherical shells, held together by pressing them with force F(see figure). F is proportional… Includes diagram2010 · MCQ
  • A disk of radius 4a​ having a uniformly distributed charge 6C is placed in the xy-plane with its centre at (− a/2, 0, 0). A rod of length a carrying a uniformly distributed charge 8C is placed on the x-axis from x = a/4 to x =… Includes diagram2009 · MCQ
  • Three concentric metallic spherical shells of radii R,2R,3R are given charges Q1​,Q2​,Q3​, respectively. It is found that the surface charge densities on the outer surfaces of the shells are equal. Then, the ratio of the charges given…2009 · MCQ
  • Six point charges, each of the same magnitude q, are arranged in different manners as shown in Column II. In each case, a point M and a line PQ passing through M are shown. Let E be the electric field and V be the electric potential at M… Includes table Includes diagram2009 · MCQ
  • A solid sphere of radius R has a charge Q distributed in its volume with a charge density ρ=Kra, where K and a are constants and r is the distance from its centre. If the electric field at r=R/2 is 1/8 times than at r=R,…2009 · Numerical
  • Consider a system of three charges 3q​,3q​ and −32q​ placed at points A, B and C, respectively, as shown in the figure. Take O to be the centre of the circle of radius R and angle CAB = 60 ∘ Includes diagram2008 · MCQ