Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Basics of Organic Chemistry question

2017 · Shift 2 · Q8
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Advanced
  3. /Chemistry
  4. /Basics of Organic Chemistry
  5. /2017 · Shift 2 · Q8

Basics of Organic Chemistry question

2017 · Shift 2 · Q8

JEE AdvancedChemistryBasics of Organic ChemistryMultiple correct+4 / −1
For the following compounds, the correct statement(s) with respect to nucleophilic substitution reaction is (are) JEE Advanced 2017 Paper 2 Offline Chemistry - Basics of Organic Chemistry Question 36 English
  1. A
    I{\rm I}I and III{\rm I}{\rm I}{\rm I}III follow SN1{S_N}1SN​1 mechanism
  2. B
    I{\rm I}I and II{\rm II}II follow SN2{S_N}2SN​2 mechanism
  3. C
    Compound IV{\rm IV}IV undergoes inversion of configuration
  4. D
    The order of reactivity for I,III{\rm I},{\rm I}{\rm I}{\rm I}I,III and IV{\rm IV}IV is : IV>I>III{\rm I}V \gt {\rm I} \gt {\rm I}{\rm I}{\rm I}IV>I>III
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: B, C

This question asks to identify the correct statements regarding nucleophilic substitution reactions for four given compounds.

Let's first analyze the structure of each compound and its tendency to undergo SN1{S_N}1SN​1 or SN2{S_N}2SN​2 reactions.

Compound I: CH3−CH2−BrCH_3-CH_2-BrCH3​−CH2​−Br (Ethyl bromide)

  • This is a primary (1∘1^\circ1∘) alkyl halide.
  • It is sterically unhindered, favoring backside attack by a nucleophile.
  • The primary carbocation (CH3−CH2+CH_3-CH_2^+CH3​−CH2+​) that would be formed in an SN1{S_N}1SN​1 reaction is highly unstable.
  • Therefore, compound I strongly favors the SN2{S_N}2SN​2 mechanism.

Compound II: H2C=CH−CH2−BrH_2C=CH-CH_2-BrH2​C=CH−CH2​−Br (Allyl bromide)

  • This is a primary (1∘1^\circ1∘) allylic halide.
  • Being a primary halide, it is unhindered and thus a good substrate for SN2{S_N}2SN​2 reactions. The rate is even enhanced due to the stabilization of the transition state by the adjacent π\piπ-bond.
  • The allyl carbocation (H2C=CH−CH2+H_2C=CH-CH_2^+H2​C=CH−CH2+​) formed in an SN1{S_N}1SN​1 reaction is stabilized by resonance, so it can also undergo SN1{S_N}1SN​1 reactions under appropriate conditions (polar protic solvent, weak nucleophile).

Compound III: (CH3)3C−Br(CH_3)_3C-Br(CH3​)3​C−Br (tert-Butyl bromide)

  • This is a tertiary (3∘3^\circ3∘) alkyl halide.
  • It is sterically hindered, preventing backside attack required for the SN2{S_N}2SN​2 mechanism.
  • The tertiary carbocation ((CH3)3C+(CH_3)_3C^+(CH3​)3​C+) formed upon departure of the bromide ion is very stable due to hyperconjugation and inductive effects.
  • Therefore, compound III strongly favors the SN1{S_N}1SN​1 mechanism.

Compound IV: C6H5−CH(CH3)−BrC_6H_5-CH(CH_3)-BrC6​H5​−CH(CH3​)−Br (1-Bromo-1-phenylethane)

  • This is a secondary (2∘2^\circ2∘) benzylic halide.
  • The carbocation formed in an SN1{S_N}1SN​1 reaction, C6H5−C+H(CH3)C_6H_5-C^+H(CH_3)C6​H5​−C+H(CH3​), is a secondary benzylic carbocation. It is highly stabilized by resonance with the benzene ring.
  • This high stability of the carbocation strongly favors the SN1{S_N}1SN​1 mechanism.
  • However, being a secondary halide, it can also undergo SN2{S_N}2SN​2 reactions, especially with strong nucleophiles in polar aprotic solvents.

Now, let's evaluate each statement:

A: I and III follow SN1{S_N}1SN​1 mechanism

  • Compound I (CH3−CH2−BrCH_3-CH_2-BrCH3​−CH2​−Br) is a primary halide and undergoes SN2{S_N}2SN​2 reactions, not SN1{S_N}1SN​1.
  • Compound III ((CH3)3C−Br(CH_3)_3C-Br(CH3​)3​C−Br) is a tertiary halide and undergoes SN1{S_N}1SN​1 reactions.
  • Since the statement is not true for compound I, statement A is incorrect.

B: I and II follow SN2{S_N}2SN​2 mechanism

  • Compound I (CH3−CH2−BrCH_3-CH_2-BrCH3​−CH2​−Br) is a classic example of a substrate that undergoes SN2{S_N}2SN​2 reactions.
  • Compound II (H2C=CH−CH2−BrH_2C=CH-CH_2-BrH2​C=CH−CH2​−Br) is a primary allylic halide, which is unhindered and readily undergoes SN2{S_N}2SN​2 reactions.
  • Thus, statement B is correct.

C: Compound IV undergoes inversion of configuration

  • Inversion of configuration is the stereochemical outcome of an SN2{S_N}2SN​2 reaction.
  • Compound IV (C6H5−CH(CH3)−BrC_6H_5-CH(CH_3)-BrC6​H5​−CH(CH3​)−Br) is a chiral secondary benzylic halide. While it prefers the SN1{S_N}1SN​1 pathway in many conditions due to its stable carbocation, it can undergo an SN2{S_N}2SN​2 reaction under conditions that favor it (e.g., a strong, non-bulky nucleophile in a polar aprotic solvent).
  • Since an SN2{S_N}2SN​2 pathway is possible for compound IV, it can undergo inversion of configuration.
  • Therefore, statement C is correct.

D: The order of reactivity for I, III and IV is : IV>I>IIIIV > I > IIIIV>I>III

  • The order of reactivity depends on the reaction mechanism.
  • For SN1{S_N}1SN​1 reactions (favored by III and IV), reactivity depends on carbocation stability: IV>III>>IIV > III >> IIV>III>>I.
  • For SN2{S_N}2SN​2 reactions (favored by I), reactivity depends on steric hindrance: I>IV>IIII > IV > IIII>IV>III (III is essentially unreactive).
  • The given order IV>I>IIIIV > I > IIIIV>I>III is inconsistent. The part I>IIII > IIII>III suggests an SN2{S_N}2SN​2 trend, while IV>IIV > IIV>I suggests an SN1{S_N}1SN​1 trend. If we compare under conditions that allow both (like solvolysis), the order would be determined by carbocation stability, i.e., IV>III>IIV > III > IIV>III>I. The given order does not match any standard reactivity series.
  • Therefore, statement D is incorrect.

Based on the analysis, the correct statements are B and C.

Comparison with Stored Answer: The stored answer is A, B, C. This is logically inconsistent. Statement A claims compound I follows the SN1{S_N}1SN​1 mechanism, while statement B claims it follows the SN2{S_N}2SN​2 mechanism. Both statements cannot be simultaneously correct. As established, compound I follows the SN2{S_N}2SN​2 mechanism, making statement A incorrect and statement B correct. Therefore, the stored answer key appears to be erroneous.

PreviousNext

More from Basics of Organic Chemistry

  • In the following mono-bromination reaction, the number of possible chiral product(s) is (are)... Includes diagram2016 · Numerical
  • The total number of stereoisomers that can exist for M is ​. Includes diagram2015 · Numerical
  • The correct combination of names for isomeric alcohols with molecular formula C4​H{}_{10}$O is/are2014 · Multiple correct
  • The total number(s) of stable conformers with non-zero dipole moment for the following compound is(are) Includes diagram2014 · Numerical
  • Isomers of hexane, based on their branching, can be divided into three distinct classes as shown in the figure. The correct order of their boiling point is Includes diagram2014 · MCQ
  • The hyperconjugative stabilities of tert-butyl cation and 2-butene, respectively, are due to2013 · Multiple correct
  • Which of the following molecules, in pure form, is(are) unstable at room temperature?2012 · Multiple correct
  • When the following aldohexose exists in its D-configuration, the total number of stereoisomers in its pyranose form is ​. Includes diagram2012 · Numerical