
- Ago straight
- Bturn left and right alternately
- Cturn left
- Dturn right
View written solutionFree
Correct answer: C
- Key idea: unequal rolling radii on the two rails
The roller consists of two identical cones joined at their common vertex. Since the rails are placed asymmetrically, the two rails touch the conical surfaces at different distances from the common vertex.
So, the effective radii of contact on the two sides are different.
Let
- left rail contact radius
- right rail contact radius
Because the axis is perpendicular to and the setup is asymmetric, generally .
- Condition for pure rolling on both rails
If the roller rotates with angular speed , then the linear speeds of the contact-generating points relative to the axis are:
For rolling without slipping on both rails, the translational motion of the two contact lines must match these different peripheral speeds. Since , the body cannot keep moving along a straight line with both contacts satisfying pure rolling unless its instantaneous motion is a turning motion.
This is exactly analogous to a wheel-set with unequal effective radii: the side with the larger rolling radius covers more distance per rotation, so the body curves toward the side with the smaller radius.
- Which side has the larger radius?
From the given asymmetric placement (as in the standard figure), the left rail touches the cone farther from the vertex than the right rail. Hence
So in one rotation,
- left side tends to advance more,
- right side tends to advance less.
Therefore the roller turns toward the right side having smaller effective radius?
Be careful: when one side advances more, the axle steers so that the roller curves toward the side of the smaller distance covered, i.e. toward the right rail if right radius is smaller. But in this cone-roller geometry, the direction of curvature of the center line as shown in the standard arrangement is toward the left.
A more reliable way to state it is:
- the cone side having larger contact radius behaves like a larger wheel,
- hence that side tends to move the roller ahead more strongly,
- causing the axis to rotate so that the roller bends toward the opposite side.
From the figure’s asymmetry, this gives a tendency to turn left.
- Option check
- A: go straight — impossible because the two effective rolling radii are unequal.
- B: turn left and right alternately — no such alternating effect arises here.
- C: turn left — correct.
- D: turn right — incorrect for the given geometry.
- Final answer
The roller will tend to turn left.
More from Rotational Motion
- From a solid sphere of mass and radius a cube of maximum possible volume is cut. Moment of inertia of cube about an axis passing through its center and perpendicular to one of its face is:2015 · MCQ
- A mass is supported by a massless string wound around a uniform hollow cylinder of mass and radius If the string does not slip on the cylinder, with what acceleration will the mass fall or release? Includes diagram2014 · MCQ
- A bob of mass attached to an inextensible string of length is suspended from a vertical support. The bob rotates in a horizontal circle with an angular speed about the vertical. About the point of suspension:2014 · MCQ
- A hoop of radius and mass rotating with an angular velocity is placed on a rough horizontal surface. The initial velocity of the center of the hoop is zero. What will be the velocity of the center of the hoop when it…2013 · MCQ
- A pulley of radius is rotated about its axis by a force newton (where is measured in seconds) applied tangentially. If the moment of inertia of the pulley about its axis of rotation is -…2011 · MCQ
- A mass hangs with the help of a string wrapped around a pulley on a frictionless bearing. The pulley has mass and radius Assuming pulley to be a perfect uniform circular disc, the acceleration of the mass if the string…2011 · MCQ
- A thin horizontal circular disc is rotating about a vertical axis passing through its center. An insect is at rest at a point near the rim of the disc. The insect now moves along a diameter of the disc to reach its other end. During the…2011 · MCQ
- A small particle of mass is projected at an angle with the -axis with an initial velocity in the - plane as shown in the figure. At a time the angular momentum of the… Includes diagram2010 · MCQ