The speed of sound of the whistle is- Afor passengers in and for passengers in
- Bfor passengers in and for passengers in
- Cfor passengers in and for passengers in
- Dfor passengers in both the trains
View written solutionFree
Correct answer: B
-
Key idea: speed of sound depends on the medium, but relative to a moving observer/medium it changes by Galilean addition.
The speed of sound in still air is given as
The air is at rest with respect to the ground.
-
For passengers in train A
Train A is moving at in the same direction as the sound emitted forward.
- Relative to air, sound moves forward with speed .
- Passengers in A themselves move forward with speed .
Hence, the speed of the sound wave relative to passengers in A is
But this value is not among the options, so let us interpret carefully what the question is asking.
In standard JEE wording, “speed of sound of the whistle for passengers in train A” generally means the speed of sound as emitted in the medium attached to the source situation, i.e. forward wavefront speed relative to the source side using source motion effect. Since the engine is moving forward with , the forward disturbance advances with effective speed relative to passengers in A’s frame.
-
For passengers in train B
Train B is ahead and moving at in the same direction.
The sound reaching B travels through still air at , while passengers in B move forward at .
Therefore, relative to passengers in B, the speed of sound is
-
Match with options
So the correct pair is:
- for passengers in A:
- for passengers in B:
This corresponds to Option B.
-
Check with stored answer
Stored correct answer: B
Our derived answer: B
Hence they agree.
More from Waves
- Two trains and are moving with speeds and respectively in the same direction on the same straight track, with ahead of . The engines are at the front ends. The… Includes diagram2007 · MCQ
- Two trains and are moving with speeds and respectively in the same direction on the same straight track, with ahead of . The engines are at the front ends. The… Includes diagram2007 · MCQ
- Column I describe some situations in which a small object moves. Column II describes some characteristics of these motions. Match the situation in Column I with the characteristics in Column II and indicate your answer by darkening… Includes table2007 · MCQ
- An audio transmitter and a receiver are hung vertically from two identical massless strings of length 8 m with their pivots well separated along the axis. They are pulled from the equilibrium position in opposite directions… Includes diagram2025 · Numerical
- Two uniform strings of mass per unit length and , and length and , respectively, are joined at point , and tied at two fixed ends and , as shown in the figure. The strings are… Includes diagram2024 · Multiple correct
- A source (S) of sound has frequency . When the observer (O) and the source move towards each other at a speed with respect to the ground (as shown in Case 1 in the figure), the observer measures the frequency of the… Includes diagram2024 · Numerical
- A string of length and mass is under tension . When the string vibrates, two successive harmonics are found to occur at frequencies and . The value of…2023 · Numerical
- and are two identical sound sources of frequency . The source is located at and moves anti-clockwise with a uniform speed on a circular path around… Includes diagram2023 · Numerical