Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Properties of Matter question

2011 · Shift 1 · Q61
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Advanced
  3. /Physics
  4. /Properties of Matter
  5. /2011 · Shift 1 · Q61

Properties of Matter question

2011 · Shift 1 · Q61

JEE AdvancedPhysicsProperties of MatterMultiple correct+4 / −2
A composite block is made of slabs A, B, C, D and E of different thermal conductivities (given in terms of a constant K) and sizes (given in terms of length, L) as shown in the figure. All slabs are of same width. Heat Q flows only from left to right through the blocks. Then, in steady-state IIT-JEE 2011 Paper 1 Offline Physics - Properties of Matter Question 16 English
  1. A
    heat flow through A and E slabs are same.
  2. B
    heat flow through slab E is maximum.
  3. C
    temperature difference across slab E is smallest.
  4. D
    heat flow through C = heat flow through B + heat flow through D.
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: A, B

Analysis of the Setup

  1. The composite block is arranged such that slab A is in series with a parallel combination of slabs B, C, and D. This parallel group is then in series with slab E.
  2. Let HXH_XHX​, ΔTX\Delta T_XΔTX​, and RXR_XRX​ be the rate of heat flow, temperature difference, and thermal resistance of slab X, respectively.
  3. The thermal resistance RRR of a slab is given by the formula R=LlenkAR = \frac{L_{len}}{kA}R=kALlen​​, where LlenL_{len}Llen​ is the length, kkk is the thermal conductivity, and AAA is the cross-sectional area.
  4. From the problem description, we have the following parameters:
    • kA=2K,LA=Lk_A=2K, L_A=LkA​=2K,LA​=L
    • kB=3K,LB=4Lk_B=3K, L_B=4LkB​=3K,LB​=4L
    • kC=4K,LC=5Lk_C=4K, L_C=5LkC​=4K,LC​=5L
    • kD=6K,LD=2Lk_D=6K, L_D=2LkD​=6K,LD​=2L
    • kE=K,LE=Lk_E=K, L_E=LkE​=K,LE​=L
  5. The slabs have the same width. The diagram shows that the cross-sectional area of A and E must be the same (AA=AEA_A = A_EAA​=AE​) because they serve as the entry and exit for the parallel combination of B, C, and D.

Evaluation of Options

A: heat flow through A and E slabs are same.

  1. In steady state, the rate of heat flow (analogous to current in an electrical circuit) is the same through all components in a series circuit.
  2. Slab A, the parallel combination (B||C||D), and slab E are in series.
  3. Therefore, the total heat flow rate, HtotalH_{total}Htotal​, that enters through A must be the same as the heat flow rate that exits through E.
  4. So, HA=HE=HtotalH_A = H_E = H_{total}HA​=HE​=Htotal​.
  5. This statement is correct.

B: heat flow through slab E is maximum.

  1. As established above, the total heat flow HtotalH_{total}Htotal​ passes through slabs A and E.
  2. This total heat flow splits among the parallel branches: Htotal=HB+HC+HDH_{total} = H_B + H_C + H_DHtotal​=HB​+HC​+HD​.
  3. Since heat flows from left to right, the heat flow rates HB,HC,HDH_B, H_C, H_DHB​,HC​,HD​ are all positive.
  4. This implies HE=Htotal>HBH_E = H_{total} > H_BHE​=Htotal​>HB​, HE>HCH_E > H_CHE​>HC​, and HE>HDH_E > H_DHE​>HD​.
  5. The heat flows are {HA,HB,HC,HD,HEH_A, H_B, H_C, H_D, H_EHA​,HB​,HC​,HD​,HE​} = {Htotal,HB,HC,HD,HtotalH_{total}, H_B, H_C, H_D, H_{total}Htotal​,HB​,HC​,HD​,Htotal​}. The maximum value among these is HtotalH_{total}Htotal​.
  6. Thus, the heat flow through slab E is maximum (equal to the heat flow through A).
  7. This statement is correct. (Note: This option was not in the stored answer, which seems to be an omission.)

C: temperature difference across slab E is smallest.

  1. The temperature difference across a slab is given by ΔTX=HXRX\Delta T_X = H_X R_XΔTX​=HX​RX​.
  2. For slabs A and E, we have ΔTA=HARA\Delta T_A = H_A R_AΔTA​=HA​RA​ and ΔTE=HERE\Delta T_E = H_E R_EΔTE​=HE​RE​.
  3. Since HA=HEH_A = H_EHA​=HE​, the ratio of their temperature differences is ΔTEΔTA=RERA\frac{\Delta T_E}{\Delta T_A} = \frac{R_E}{R_A}ΔTA​ΔTE​​=RA​RE​​.
  4. Let's calculate the resistances RAR_ARA​ and RER_ERE​. We know AA=AEA_A = A_EAA​=AE​. RA=LAkAAA=L(2K)AAR_A = \frac{L_A}{k_A A_A} = \frac{L}{(2K) A_A}RA​=kA​AA​LA​​=(2K)AA​L​ RE=LEkEAE=LKAE=LKAAR_E = \frac{L_E}{k_E A_E} = \frac{L}{K A_E} = \frac{L}{K A_A}RE​=kE​AE​LE​​=KAE​L​=KAA​L​
  5. The ratio is: RERA=L/(KAA)L/(2KAA)=2\frac{R_E}{R_A} = \frac{L/(K A_A)}{L/(2K A_A)} = 2RA​RE​​=L/(2KAA​)L/(KAA​)​=2
  6. Therefore, ΔTE=2ΔTA\Delta T_E = 2 \Delta T_AΔTE​=2ΔTA​. The temperature difference across slab E is twice the temperature difference across slab A.
  7. This proves that ΔTE\Delta T_EΔTE​ is not the smallest temperature difference, as ΔTA\Delta T_AΔTA​ is smaller.
  8. This statement is incorrect.

D: heat flow through C = heat flow through B + heat flow through D.

  1. This statement is equivalent to HC=HB+HDH_C = H_B + H_DHC​=HB​+HD​.
  2. Slabs B, C, and D are in parallel, so the temperature difference across them is the same: ΔTB=ΔTC=ΔTD=ΔTparallel\Delta T_B = \Delta T_C = \Delta T_D = \Delta T_{parallel}ΔTB​=ΔTC​=ΔTD​=ΔTparallel​.
  3. Using H=ΔT/RH = \Delta T / RH=ΔT/R, the condition becomes ΔTparallelRC=ΔTparallelRB+ΔTparallelRD\frac{\Delta T_{parallel}}{R_C} = \frac{\Delta T_{parallel}}{R_B} + \frac{\Delta T_{parallel}}{R_D}RC​ΔTparallel​​=RB​ΔTparallel​​+RD​ΔTparallel​​.
  4. This simplifies to a condition on the thermal resistances: 1RC=1RB+1RD\frac{1}{R_C} = \frac{1}{R_B} + \frac{1}{R_D}RC​1​=RB​1​+RD​1​.
  5. Let's check this condition using the given values. The cross-sectional areas AB,AC,ADA_B, A_C, A_DAB​,AC​,AD​ are not specified. Let's test the condition assuming they are equal (AB=AC=AD=AA_B=A_C=A_D=AAB​=AC​=AD​=A for simplicity, a common assumption in schematic problems if not specified). RB=4L3KA,RC=5L4KA,RD=2L6KA=L3KAR_B = \frac{4L}{3KA}, \quad R_C = \frac{5L}{4KA}, \quad R_D = \frac{2L}{6KA} = \frac{L}{3KA}RB​=3KA4L​,RC​=4KA5L​,RD​=6KA2L​=3KAL​ 1RC=4KA5L\frac{1}{R_C} = \frac{4KA}{5L}RC​1​=5L4KA​ 1RB+1RD=3KA4L+3KAL=(34+3)KAL=3.75KAL\frac{1}{R_B} + \frac{1}{R_D} = \frac{3KA}{4L} + \frac{3KA}{L} = (\frac{3}{4} + 3)\frac{KA}{L} = 3.75 \frac{KA}{L}RB​1​+RD​1​=4L3KA​+L3KA​=(43​+3)LKA​=3.75LKA​
  6. Since 45≠3.75\frac{4}{5} \neq 3.7554​=3.75, the condition is not satisfied.
  7. As the condition depends on the unknown areas and does not hold for the simple case of equal areas, it cannot be considered a correct statement based on the given information.
  8. This statement is incorrect.

Conclusion

Based on the analysis, only options A and B are demonstrably correct. Option C is demonstrably incorrect, as ΔTE=2ΔTA\Delta T_E = 2\Delta T_AΔTE​=2ΔTA​. Option D is a specific condition on the slab properties that is not fulfilled by the given values under simple assumptions and cannot be proven true in general. Therefore, the stored correct answer {A, C, D} appears to be incorrect.

PreviousNext

More from Properties of Matter

  • Two solid spheres A and B of equal volumes but of different densities dA and dB are connected by a string. They are fully immersed in a fluid of density dF. They get arranged into an equilibrium state as shown in the figure with a tension… Includes diagram2011 · Multiple correct
  • When liquid medicine of density ρ is to be put in the eye, it is done with the help of a dropper. As the bulb on the top of the dropper is pressed, a drop forms at the opening of the dropper. We wish to estimate the size of the drop.…2010 · MCQ
  • When liquid medicine of density ρ is to be put in the eye, it is done with the help of a dropper. As the bulb on the top of the dropper is pressed, a drop forms at the opening of the dropper. We wish to estimate the size of the drop.…2010 · MCQ
  • When liquid medicine of density ρ is to be put in the eye, it is done with the help of a dropper. As the bulb on the top of the dropper is pressed, a drop forms at the opening of the dropper. We wish to estimate the size of the drop.…2010 · MCQ
  • Two soap bubbles A and B are kept in a closed chamber where the air is maintained at pressure 8 N/m 2. The radii of bubbles A and B are 2 cm and 4 cm, respectively. Surface tension of the soap-water used to make bubbles is 0.04 N/m.…2009 · Numerical
  • A cylindrical vessel of height 500 mm has an orifice (small hole) at its bottom. The orifice is initially closed and water is filled in it up to height H. Now the top is completely sealed with a cap and the orifice at the bottom is opened.…2009 · Numerical
  • STATEMENT - 1 : The stream of water flowing at high speed from a garden hose pipe tends to spread line a fountain when held vertically up, but tends to narrow down when held vertically down. and STATEMENT - 2 : In any steady flow of an…2008 · MCQ
  • A small spherical monoatomic ideal gas bubble (γ=35​) is trapped inside a liquid of density ρ1​ (see figure). Assume that the bubble does not exchange any heat with the liquid. The bubble contains n… Includes diagram2008 · MCQ