Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Current Electricity question

2009 · Shift 1 · Q49
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Advanced
  3. /Physics
  4. /Current Electricity
  5. /2009 · Shift 1 · Q49

Current Electricity question

2009 · Shift 1 · Q49

JEE AdvancedPhysicsCurrent ElectricityMultiple correct+4 / −2
For the circuit shown in the figure IIT-JEE 2009 Paper 1 Offline Physics - Current Electricity Question 4 English
  1. A
    The current I through the battery is 7.5 mA.
  2. B
    The potential difference across RLR_LRL​, is 18 V.
  3. C
    Ratio of powers dissipated in R1R_1R1​ and R2R_2R2​ is 3.
  4. D
    If R1R_1R1​ and R2R_2R2​ are interchanged, magnitude of the power dissipated in RLR_LRL​ will decrease by a factor of 9.
View written solutionFree

Correct answer:

Analysis of the Circuit

  1. Identify the circuit topology: The circuit shown is a Wheatstone bridge. The battery with voltage V=30 VV = 30 \text{ V}V=30 V is connected across the input terminals. The resistor RLR_LRL​ is connected between the intermediate nodes of the two parallel branches.

  2. List the component values:

    • R1=2 kΩR_1 = 2 \text{ k}\OmegaR1​=2 kΩ
    • R2=4 kΩR_2 = 4 \text{ k}\OmegaR2​=4 kΩ
    • R3=2 kΩR_3 = 2 \text{ k}\OmegaR3​=2 kΩ
    • R4=4 kΩR_4 = 4 \text{ k}\OmegaR4​=4 kΩ
    • RL=8 kΩR_L = 8 \text{ k}\OmegaRL​=8 kΩ
    • V=30 VV = 30 \text{ V}V=30 V
  3. Check for the balance condition: A Wheatstone bridge is balanced if the ratio of resistances in the opposite arms is equal. The condition is R1R2=R3R4\frac{R_1}{R_2} = \frac{R_3}{R_4}R2​R1​​=R4​R3​​.

    • Substituting the given values: 2 kΩ4 kΩ=12\frac{2 \text{ k}\Omega}{4 \text{ k}\Omega} = \frac{1}{2}4 kΩ2 kΩ​=21​ and 2 kΩ4 kΩ=12\frac{2 \text{ k}\Omega}{4 \text{ k}\Omega} = \frac{1}{2}4 kΩ2 kΩ​=21​.
    • Since 12=12\frac{1}{2} = \frac{1}{2}21​=21​, the bridge is balanced.
  4. Consequences of a balanced bridge: For a balanced bridge, the potential at the node between R1R_1R1​ and R3R_3R3​ (let's call it C) is equal to the potential at the node between R2R_2R2​ and R4R_4R4​ (let's call it D). Therefore, no current flows through the resistor RLR_LRL​. The circuit can be simplified by removing RLR_LRL​.

Evaluation of the Options

Option A: The current I through the battery is 7.5 mA.

  1. With the bridge balanced, the circuit simplifies to two parallel branches.
    • Top branch resistance: Rtop=R1+R3=2 kΩ+2 kΩ=4 kΩR_{top} = R_1 + R_3 = 2 \text{ k}\Omega + 2 \text{ k}\Omega = 4 \text{ k}\OmegaRtop​=R1​+R3​=2 kΩ+2 kΩ=4 kΩ.
    • Bottom branch resistance: Rbottom=R2+R4=4 kΩ+4 kΩ=8 kΩR_{bottom} = R_2 + R_4 = 4 \text{ k}\Omega + 4 \text{ k}\Omega = 8 \text{ k}\OmegaRbottom​=R2​+R4​=4 kΩ+4 kΩ=8 kΩ.
  2. The equivalent resistance of the circuit is the parallel combination of these two branches: Req=Rtop×RbottomRtop+Rbottom=4×84+8=3212=83 kΩR_{eq} = \frac{R_{top} \times R_{bottom}}{R_{top} + R_{bottom}} = \frac{4 \times 8}{4 + 8} = \frac{32}{12} = \frac{8}{3} \text{ k}\OmegaReq​=Rtop​+Rbottom​Rtop​×Rbottom​​=4+84×8​=1232​=38​ kΩ
  3. The total current III from the battery is: I=VReq=30 V(8/3) kΩ=30×38×103 A=908 mA=11.25 mAI = \frac{V}{R_{eq}} = \frac{30 \text{ V}}{(8/3) \text{ k}\Omega} = \frac{30 \times 3}{8 \times 10^3} \text{ A} = \frac{90}{8} \text{ mA} = 11.25 \text{ mA}I=Req​V​=(8/3) kΩ30 V​=8×10330×3​ A=890​ mA=11.25 mA
  4. The calculated current is 11.25 mA, not 7.5 mA. Therefore, Option A is incorrect.

Option B: The potential difference across RLR_LRL​ is 18 V.

  1. As established, the bridge is balanced. This means the potential difference across the central resistor RLR_LRL​ is zero.
  2. Therefore, Option B is incorrect.

Option C: Ratio of powers dissipated in R1R_1R1​ and R2R_2R2​ is 3.

  1. The voltage across both parallel branches is 30 V.
  2. Current through the top branch (R1,R3R_1, R_3R1​,R3​): I1=VRtop=30 V4 kΩ=7.5 mAI_1 = \frac{V}{R_{top}} = \frac{30 \text{ V}}{4 \text{ k}\Omega} = 7.5 \text{ mA}I1​=Rtop​V​=4 kΩ30 V​=7.5 mA.
  3. Current through the bottom branch (R2,R4R_2, R_4R2​,R4​): I2=VRbottom=30 V8 kΩ=3.75 mAI_2 = \frac{V}{R_{bottom}} = \frac{30 \text{ V}}{8 \text{ k}\Omega} = 3.75 \text{ mA}I2​=Rbottom​V​=8 kΩ30 V​=3.75 mA.
  4. Power dissipated in R1R_1R1​: P1=I12R1=(7.5×10−3)2×(2×103)=56.25×10−6×2×103=112.5 mWP_1 = I_1^2 R_1 = (7.5 \times 10^{-3})^2 \times (2 \times 10^3) = 56.25 \times 10^{-6} \times 2 \times 10^3 = 112.5 \text{ mW}P1​=I12​R1​=(7.5×10−3)2×(2×103)=56.25×10−6×2×103=112.5 mW.
  5. Power dissipated in R2R_2R2​: P2=I22R2=(3.75×10−3)2×(4×103)=14.0625×10−6×4×103=56.25 mWP_2 = I_2^2 R_2 = (3.75 \times 10^{-3})^2 \times (4 \times 10^3) = 14.0625 \times 10^{-6} \times 4 \times 10^3 = 56.25 \text{ mW}P2​=I22​R2​=(3.75×10−3)2×(4×103)=14.0625×10−6×4×103=56.25 mW.
  6. The ratio of powers is P1P2=112.556.25=2\frac{P_1}{P_2} = \frac{112.5}{56.25} = 2P2​P1​​=56.25112.5​=2.
  7. The option states the ratio is 3. Therefore, Option C is incorrect.

Option D: If R1R_1R1​ and R2R_2R2​ are interchanged, magnitude of the power dissipated in RLR_LRL​ will decrease by a factor of 9.

  1. In the original configuration, the bridge is balanced, so the power dissipated in RLR_LRL​ is PL=0P_L = 0PL​=0.
  2. Now, interchange R1R_1R1​ and R2R_2R2​. The new values are R1′=4 kΩR'_1 = 4 \text{ k}\OmegaR1′​=4 kΩ and R2′=2 kΩR'_2 = 2 \text{ k}\OmegaR2′​=2 kΩ. The other resistors remain the same: R3=2 kΩR_3 = 2 \text{ k}\OmegaR3​=2 kΩ, R4=4 kΩR_4 = 4 \text{ k}\OmegaR4​=4 kΩ.
  3. Check the balance condition for the new circuit: R1′R2′=42=2\frac{R'_1}{R'_2} = \frac{4}{2} = 2R2′​R1′​​=24​=2. And R3R4=24=12\frac{R_3}{R_4} = \frac{2}{4} = \frac{1}{2}R4​R3​​=42​=21​. Since 2≠122 \neq \frac{1}{2}2=21​, the new bridge is unbalanced.
  4. Because the new bridge is unbalanced, a non-zero current will flow through RLR_LRL​, and the power dissipated in it, PL′P'_LPL′​, will be greater than zero.
  5. The power changes from PL=0P_L=0PL​=0 to PL′>0P'_L > 0PL′​>0. This is an increase, not a decrease. The phrasing "decrease by a factor of 9" is nonsensical in this context.
  6. Therefore, Option D is incorrect.

Conclusion

Based on a rigorous analysis of the circuit diagram and the values provided, none of the options are correct. There is likely an error in the problem statement (either the values of the components or the options provided) or the stored correct answer.

For instance, if we assume there is a typo in the resistance values such that R3=4 kΩR_3=4\text{ k}\OmegaR3​=4 kΩ and R4=8 kΩR_4=8\text{ k}\OmegaR4​=8 kΩ, the bridge would still be balanced (2/4=4/82/4 = 4/82/4=4/8), and the equivalent resistance would be Req=(R1+R3)∣∣(R2+R4)=(2+4)∣∣(4+8)=6∣∣12=4 kΩR_{eq} = (R_1+R_3) || (R_2+R_4) = (2+4)||(4+8) = 6||12 = 4 \text{ k}\OmegaReq​=(R1​+R3​)∣∣(R2​+R4​)=(2+4)∣∣(4+8)=6∣∣12=4 kΩ. This would make the total current I=30V/4kΩ=7.5 mAI = 30V / 4k\Omega = 7.5 \text{ mA}I=30V/4kΩ=7.5 mA, making option A correct. However, even with this change, option D's statement remains problematic as the power in RLR_LRL​ would increase from zero upon interchanging R1R_1R1​ and R2R_2R2​.

Given the contradictions, and sticking strictly to the information provided, no option is valid.

PreviousNext

More from Current Electricity

  • Figure shows three resistor configurations R1, R2 and R3 connected to 3 V battery. If the power dissipated by the configuration R1, R2 and R3 is P1, P2 and P3, respectively, then Includes diagram2008 · MCQ
  • STATEMENT - 1 In a Meter Bridge experiment, null point for an unknown resistance is measured. Now, the unknown resistance is put inside an enclosure maintained at a higher temperature. The null point can be obtained at the same point as…2008 · MCQ
  • A resistance of 2 Ω is connected across one gap of a metre-bridge (the length of the wire is 100 cm) and an unknown resistance, greater than 2 Ω, is connected across the other gap. When these resistance are interchanged, the…2007 · MCQ
  • In the following circuit C1​=12μF,C2​=C3​=4μF and C4​=C5​=2μF. The charge stored in C3​ is ​μC. Includes diagram2022 · Numerical
  • The figure shows a circuit having eight resistances of 1Ω each, labelled R1​ to R8​, and two ideal batteries with voltages ε1​=12 V and ε2​=6 V. Which of the following… Includes diagram2022 · Multiple correct
  • Two resistances R1​=XΩ and R2​=1Ω are connected to a wire AB of uniform resistivity, as shown in the figure. The radius of the wire varies linearly along its axis from 0.2 mm at A to 1 mm at… Includes diagram2022 · Numerical
  • In Circuit-1 and Circuit- 2 shown in the figures, R1​=1Ω,R2​=2Ω and R3​=3Ω. P1​ and P2​ are the power dissipations in Circuit-1 and Circuit-2 when the switches S1​ and… Includes diagram2022 · Multiple correct
  • In order to measure the internal resistance r1 of a cell of emf E, a meter bridge of wire resistance R0 = 50 Ω, a resistance R0/2, another cell of emf E/2 (internal resistance r) and a galvanometer G are used in a circuit, as shown… Includes diagram2021 · Numerical