JEE AdvancedChemistryP Block ElementsMCQ+3 / −1
There are some deposits of nitrates and phosphates in earth's crust. Nitrates are more soluble in water. Nitrates are difficult to reduce under the laboratory conditions but microbes do it easily. Ammonia forms large number of complexes with transition metal ions. Hybridisation easily explains the ease of sigma donation capability of NH and PH . Phosphine is a flammable gas and is prepared from white phosphorus.Among the following, the correct statement is :
- ABetween NH and PH , NH is better electron donor because the lone pair of electrons occupies spherical 's' orbital and is less directional.
- BBetween NH and PH , PH is a better electron donor because the lone pair of electrons occupies sp orbital and is more directional.
- CBetween NH and PH , NH is a better electron donor because the lone pair of electrons occupies sp orbital and is more directional.
- DBetween NH and PH , PH is better electron donor because the lone pair of electrons occupies spherical 's' orbital and is less directional.
View written solutionFree
Correct answer: C
Step-by-step Solution:
-
Analyze the Structures and Hybridization of NH₃ and PH₃:
- Ammonia (NH₃): The central atom is Nitrogen (N). The electronic configuration of N is
[He] 2s² 2p³. In NH₃, nitrogen forms three single bonds with hydrogen atoms and has one lone pair of electrons. The steric number is 4 (3 bond pairs + 1 lone pair). According to VSEPR theory, this corresponds to a tetrahedral electron geometry and a trigonal pyramidal molecular shape. The H-N-H bond angle is approximately 107.8°, which is close to the ideal tetrahedral angle of 109.5°. This indicates that the nitrogen atom is approximatelysp³hybridized. The lone pair resides in one of the foursp³hybrid orbitals. - Phosphine (PH₃): The central atom is Phosphorus (P). The electronic configuration of P is
[Ne] 3s² 3p³. Similar to NH₃, phosphorus forms three single bonds with hydrogen atoms and has one lone pair. However, the H-P-H bond angle is about 93.5°. This angle is very close to 90°, which is the angle between pure p-orbitals. This suggests that in PH₃, there is very little hybridization (or it can be explained by Drago's rule). The P-H bonds are formed mainly by the overlap of the three3porbitals of phosphorus with the1sorbitals of hydrogen. Consequently, the lone pair of electrons resides in an orbital with a very high s-character, which is nearly the pure3sorbital.
- Ammonia (NH₃): The central atom is Nitrogen (N). The electronic configuration of N is
-
Compare the Electron Donation Capability (Lewis Basicity):
- A Lewis base is a substance that can donate a pair of electrons. The ease of donation depends on the availability and orientation of the lone pair.
- In NH₃: The lone pair is in an
sp³hybrid orbital. Ansp³orbital has 25% s-character and 75% p-character. The significant p-character makes the orbital highly directional, extending out into space away from the N-H bonds. This directional nature facilitates effective overlap with an empty orbital of a Lewis acid (like a proton or a metal ion). - In PH₃: The lone pair is in an orbital with high s-character (almost pure
3s). Ans-orbital is spherical and non-directional. Furthermore, electrons in ans-orbital are held more tightly by the nucleus compared to electrons inpor hybrid orbitals of the same principal quantum number. This makes the lone pair in PH₃ less available for donation and less effective in forming a directional coordinate bond.
-
Conclusion:
- Due to the directional nature of the
sp³hybrid orbital containing the lone pair, ammonia (NH₃) is a much better electron donor (stronger Lewis base) than phosphine (PH₃). - The lone pair in PH₃ is less available and less directional because it resides in an orbital with high s-character.
- Due to the directional nature of the
-
Evaluate the Options:
- A: Between NH₃ and PH₃, NH₃ is a better electron donor because the lone pair of electrons occupies spherical 's' orbital and is less directional. This statement correctly identifies NH₃ as the better donor but gives the wrong reason. The lone pair in NH₃ is in a directional
sp³orbital, not a spherical 's' orbital. - B: Between NH₃ and PH₃, PH₃ is a better electron donor because the lone pair of electrons occupies sp³ orbital and is more directional. This statement is incorrect. NH₃ is the better donor, and the lone pair in PH₃ has high s-character, not
sp³. - C: Between NH₃ and PH₃, NH₃ is a better electron donor because the lone pair of electrons occupies sp³ orbital and is more directional. This statement is correct. It correctly identifies NH₃ as the better donor and provides the correct reason based on the
sp³hybridization and the resulting directionality of the lone pair orbital. - D: Between NH₃ and PH₃, PH₃ is better electron donor because the lone pair of electrons occupies spherical 's' orbital and is less directional. This statement is incorrect. PH₃ is a weaker donor precisely because its lone pair occupies an orbital with high s-character which is less directional.
- A: Between NH₃ and PH₃, NH₃ is a better electron donor because the lone pair of electrons occupies spherical 's' orbital and is less directional. This statement correctly identifies NH₃ as the better donor but gives the wrong reason. The lone pair in NH₃ is in a directional
More from P Block Elements
- There are some deposits of nitrates and phosphates in earth's crust. Nitrates are more soluble in water. Nitrates are difficult to reduce under the laboratory conditions but microbes do it easily. Ammonia forms large number of complexes…2008 · MCQ
- Statement 1 : In water, orthoboric acid behaves as a weak monobasic acid. Statement 2 : In water, orthoboric acid acts as a proton donor.2007 · MCQ
- The noble gases have closed-shell electronic configuration and are monoatomic gases under normal conditions. The low boiling points of the lighter noble gases are due to weak dispersion forces between the atoms and the absence of other…2007 · MCQ
- The noble gases have closed-shell electronic configuration and are monoatomic gases under normal conditions. The low boiling points of the lighter noble gases are due to weak dispersion forces between the atoms and the absence of other…2007 · MCQ
- The noble gases have closed-shell electronic configuration and are monoatomic gases under normal conditions. The low boiling points of the lighter noble gases are due to weak dispersion forces between the atoms and the absence of other…2007 · MCQ
- The percentage of p-character in the orbitals forming P-P bonds in P 4 is2007 · MCQ
- STATEMENT-1 : Band gap in germanium is small. STATEMENT-2 : The energy gap of each germanium atomic energy level is infinitesimally small.2007 · MCQ
- The heating of at 60–70 °C and at 200–250 °C is associated with the formation of nitrogen containing compounds X and Y, respectively. X and Y, respectively, are2025 · MCQ