Sign in
12thPass logo
New chatPYQ LibraryDoubtsRank report
Sign in to see Recents

Your guest activity stays on this device

Sign in to save progress →
Sign in

Basics of Organic Chemistry question

2009 · Shift 2 · Q4
Guest · filters and generic practice availableBrowsing as a guest · PYQ filters and generic practice are available. Sign in only for personalised features and saved progress.
  1. PYQ Library
  2. /JEE Advanced
  3. /Chemistry
  4. /Basics of Organic Chemistry
  5. /2009 · Shift 2 · Q4

Basics of Organic Chemistry question

2009 · Shift 2 · Q4

JEE AdvancedChemistryBasics of Organic ChemistryMCQ+3 / −1
The correct stability order of the following resonance structures is IIT-JEE 2009 Paper 2 Offline Chemistry - Basics of Organic Chemistry Question 6 English
  1. A
    (I) > (II) > (IV) > (III)
  2. B
    (I) > (III) > (II) > (IV)
  3. C
    (II) > (I) > (III) > (IV)
  4. D
    (III) > (I) > (IV) > (II)
View written solutionFree

Correct answer: B

To determine the correct stability order of the given resonance structures, we will apply the standard rules for assessing resonance contributor stability, in approximate order of importance:

  1. Octet Rule: Structures where all second-row atoms have a complete octet (8 valence electrons) are more stable. Structures with more covalent bonds are generally more stable.
  2. Charge Separation: Neutral structures are most stable. Among charged structures, those with the least amount of formal charge are more stable.
  3. Electronegativity: For charged structures, the most stable ones have negative charges on the most electronegative atoms and positive charges on the least electronegative atoms.

Let's analyze each structure based on these rules:

Structure (I): H2C=CH−C¨l:H_2C = CH - \ddot{C}l:H2​C=CH−C¨l:

  • Octet: All carbon atoms and the chlorine atom have a complete octet.
  • Charge: This structure is neutral with no formal charges.
  • Conclusion: Being neutral and satisfying the octet rule for all atoms, structure (I) is the most stable contributor.

Structure (II): H2C⊖−CH=C⊕l:\stackrel{\ominus}{H_2C} - CH = \stackrel{\oplus}{C}l:H2​C⊖​−CH=C⊕​l:

  • Octet: In this structure, all atoms (C1, C2, and Cl) have a complete octet. The negative charge on C1 implies a lone pair, and the positive charge on Cl (with a double bond) implies it has two lone pairs.
  • Charge: It is a charge-separated (zwitterionic) structure.
  • Electronegativity: It has a positive charge on the highly electronegative chlorine atom and a negative charge on the less electronegative carbon atom. This is a very unfavorable charge distribution.

Structure (III): H2C⊕−CH=C¨l:⊖\stackrel{\oplus}{H_2C} - CH = \ddot{C}l:^{\ominus}H2​C⊕​−CH=C¨l:⊖

  • Octet: The terminal carbon atom (C1) is a carbocation, having only 6 valence electrons, thus an incomplete octet. Other atoms have complete octets.
  • Charge: It is a charge-separated structure.
  • Electronegativity: It has a positive charge on a carbon atom and a negative charge on the highly electronegative chlorine atom. This charge distribution is favorable according to electronegativity principles.

Structure (IV): H2C⊕−C⊖H−C¨l:\stackrel{\oplus}{H_2C} - \stackrel{\ominus}{C}H - \ddot{C}l:H2​C⊕​−C⊖​H−C¨l:

  • Octet: The terminal carbon atom (C1) has an incomplete octet (6 electrons).
  • Charge: It is a charge-separated structure. It also has adjacent opposite charges.
  • Bonds: It has fewer covalent bonds (only single bonds in the carbon backbone) compared to structures (I), (II), and (III), which contain a double bond. Structures with more bonds are more stable.

Ranking the structures:

  1. Most Stable: Structure (I) is the most stable because it is neutral and all atoms have a complete octet. So the order is (I) > ...

  2. Least Stable: Structure (IV) is the least stable. It has an incomplete octet on C1 and also has fewer covalent bonds than the other structures. The order is ... > (IV).

  3. Comparing (II) and (III): This is the key comparison.

    • Structure (II) has complete octets for all atoms but a very unfavorable charge distribution (+ on electronegative Cl).
    • Structure (III) has an incomplete octet on one carbon but a favorable charge distribution (- on electronegative Cl).
    • Generally, the octet rule takes precedence. However, a positive charge on a highly electronegative atom like chlorine is extremely destabilizing. The energetic penalty for this is so high that it can outweigh the stability gained from completing an octet. Therefore, structure (III), despite its incomplete octet, is considered more stable than structure (II) because its charge distribution is much more reasonable.
    • So, the stability order is (III) > (II).

Final Order: Combining our findings, the overall stability order is: (I) > (III) > (II) > (IV)

This corresponds to option B.

PreviousNext

More from Basics of Organic Chemistry

  • Hyperconjugation involves overlapping of the following orbitals:2008 · MCQ
  • The correct statement(s) concerning the structures E, F and G is(are) : Includes diagram2008 · Multiple correct
  • The correct stability order for the following species is : Includes diagram2008 · MCQ
  • The number of structural isomers for C 6​ H 14​ is :2007 · MCQ
  • The number of stereoisomers obtained by bromination of trans-2-butene is :2007 · MCQ
  • Match the reactions in List-I with the features of their products in List-II and choose the correct option. Includes table Includes diagram2023 · MCQ
  • The maximum number of possible isomers (including stereoisomers) which may be formed on mono-bromination of 1-methylcyclohex-1-ene using Br2​ and UV light is ​.2021 · Numerical
  • Among the following, the conformation that corresponds to the most stable conformation of meso-butane-2,3-diol is2021 · MCQ